Albert Hoffman, the Swiss chemist who invented LSD, turns 100 today. I'm going to celebrate his birthday by jumping out a window of the seventh-floor of my apartment building, and then running down the street for several miles with two broken legs as a tribe of ghost Indians in flying saucers chase me. How are you planning to celebrate this important date?
If you were Fidel Castro, from what profession in America would you recruit spies? A professor, Carlos Alvarez, who doubles as a diversity trainer, and his university administrator wife, Elsa, were arrested on Friday, and arraigned on Monday, for spying for Cuba. Both worked at Florida International University, a school with a sizable population of Cuban immigrants opposed to Castro, and attended a local Catholic Church known for its support of anti-Castro activists. The FBI charges that the Alverezes sent encrypted messages to Cuba via shortwave radio, and transported messages to and from Cuba on trips to the island prison. The Alvarezes travelled to Cuba several times under the guise of academic exchanges organized by FIU.
Three years ago, I spoke at FIU. Amidst an overflowing crowd, I encountered a hostile group of radical professors, students, and activists who shouted throughout my afternoon talk. I'm sure Mr. and Mrs. Alvarez fit in well in their FIU surroundings. Who knows? Perhaps they attended my speech on Why the Left Hates America with the heckling professors. What troubles me is that on that memorable FIU trip, I also met numerous Cuban Americans active in opposing Castro. The organizer of my FIU speech, as well as the talk-show host who interviewed me on one of Miami's Spanish language radio stations, were both Cubans vehemently opposed to Castro (A type of Cuban not hard to find in Miami--or in Havana for that matter.). The FBI alleges that the academic couple provided Castro with information on Cuban Americans in South Florida. Perhaps information on friends that I made at FIU? What was this information used for? Most anti-Castro activists in South Florida have relatives in the old country. Is the Communist state exacting retribution upon them? Harassing them? Making their lives hard?
Legally, the couple faces lesser punishment because they allegedly spied on private citizens instead of the U.S. government. Morally, the accused may have committed a more horrific offense in spying on private citizens because of the track record Communist governments have compiled in punishing family members of defectors and dissidents.
The Alvarezes face ten years behind bars if found guilty. I know a prison ninety miles south of Florida that would be glad to have them.
Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad hopes that God will afflict Ariel Sharon's cohorts with similar maladies, and will send Sharon to hell because he was too harsh towards his Palestinian and Islamic enemies. Televangelist Pat Robertson implies that God may have given Ariel Sharon a stroke because he was too generous towards his Palestinian and Islamic enemies. When confronted with the opposing motivations for these disturbingly similar reactions, it's easy to see why peace in the Middle East is so difficult. That the dispute's spectators rather than its participants made these vile utterances demonstrates how passion has overriden reason among even those who have no land, no relatives, and no direct interest at risk in how Israelis and Palestinians come to peace. Manichaeism, fanaticism, and self-righteousness don't lend themselves well to finding common ground.
Pat Robertson suggests that God may have struck Ariel Sharon down. I'm not sure if God took special interest in Ariel Sharon. I do know that Sharon is 77-years old, overweight, holds a stressful job, and has recently suffered from a series of health problems. Might any of these factors have played a larger role in Sharon's grim state than God's wrath?
An Italian man is suing a Catholic priest for claiming in a parish newspaper that Jesus existed. Italy's version of Michael Newdow is basing his suit on laws against swindlers and impersonators. "I started this lawsuit because I wanted to deal the final blow against the Church, the bearer of obscurantism and regression," Luigi Cascioli explained to Reuters. Exibit A, Exibit B, Exibit C, and Exibit D support the defendant's case. What evidence will exist 2,000 years from now of Mr. Cascioli's existence?
President Bush addressed the nation Sunday night from the Oval Office. I address the FlynnFiles nation Sunday night from my office (which is also my living room and my dining room). Here are five points from President Bush's speech that deserve comment:
1. Good for Bush for changing his tone. He ran in 2000 on a foreign policy based on humility and not arrogance. His concession that the Iraq campaign was "more difficult than we expected," his admission that "we did not find" WMDs and that "much of the intelligence turned out to be wrong," his inclusion of opposition concerns (Are we "creating more problems than we are solving"?), and his assessment that "some of my decisions have led to terrible loss" all represent a return to conciliation. He assumed responsibility. He was George W. Bush and not William Jefferson Clinton.
2. Bush divided the anti-war camp into "honest critics" and "defeatists." As someone who opposes both the president and the tone of the anti-war movement, I'm grateful President Bush made this distinction. I've written about the "defeatists" here, here, here, and elsewhere. In the midst of a heavy amount of criticism of the president, I've highlighted what's going right here, here, here, and elsewhere. I think of myself as an honest critic, but I'm sure all of the people I would throw into the "defeatist" camp think of themselves as "honest critics" too.
3. The president noted that the terrorists "object to our deepest values and our way of life." But they also object to the billions we give in aid to Israel, the presence of the American military on Muslim soil, and repeated American military strikes and invasions in such places as Iran, Libya, Iraq, Somalia, Kosovo, Lebanon, Sudan, and Afghanistan. This is not to suggest that we should change policy merely because someone with a bomb wants us to. It is to suggest that the terrorists do care less about how we live in the Western world than they do about how they live in the Islamic world.
4. A case can be made that two of the three "critical elements" of the president's plan aren't in the concrete interests of the United States. The first goal, "finding and clearing out the enemy," is the essential goal of any war. It's necessary to win. But goals two ("helping the Iraqi government establish the institutions of a unified and lasting democracy") and three ("a reconstruction plan to revive Iraq's economy and infrastructure") come at the expense of American lives and taxdollars. Goals two and three suggest a foreign policy based on altruism rather than national just interests, and they go against campaign promises of Governor Bush and the sentiments of the entire pre-9/11 conservative movement.
5. President Bush reminded the American people of the benefits of the campaign: the removal of a tyrant whose "power to harm a single man, woman, or child is gone forever" and ten million Iraqis choosing their own government. If the president hopes to win the public-relations war at home, accentuating the positives is necessary. But his definition of victory, "a democratic Iraq that can defend itself, that will never again be a safe haven for terrorists, and that will serve as a model of freedom for the Middle East," seems more in the hands of Iraqis than Americans. Basing an exit strategy on the progress of a third party is dangerous. Iraqis, not Americans, will determine whether a future Iraq is "free and democratic." We can help their future course. We can't determine it. Benjamin Franklin, 218 years ago, told a crowd of Americans that he and his fellow statesmen had given them "a republic, if you can keep it." In other words, Americans, not the delegates to the Constitutional Convention, would determine the ultimate fate of republican governance. America's current position is akin to Franklin's, while Iraq's is akin to the inquisitive crowd of Americans. Americans can help give Iraq a republic, but only Iraqis can ensure that they keep it.
Time magazine honors Bono and Bill Gates for the wrong reasons. I like Bono and Bill Gates for how they made their money. Time likes Bono and Bill Gates for how they part with their money, or more accurately in Bono's case, how he makes governments part with their citizens' money. Time named the U2 singer, the Microsoft cofounder, and his wife (what???) as their "persons of the year" for "being shrewd about doing good, for rewiring politics and re-engineering justice, for making mercy smarter and hope strategic and then daring the rest of us to follow."
Bono has written some of the best rock songs--"One," "Bad," "Stay," "With or Without You," "New Year's Day,"--of the last quarter century, and his band, U2, have been the most important rock band since Rolling Stone declared them the "band of the eighties" in 1985. As a writer and editor, my life has been made easier by Microsoft, and other computer companies. Microsoft saves me paper, saves me from spelling mistakes, saves me time. I'm sure accountants, lawyers, and stock brokers could detail how Microsoft has improved their lives. I'm also quite sure that nearly all impoverished Africans, the people Time believes Bono and Gates have helped, could not point to a single concrete way in which Bono and Gates have improved their lives. They're not listening to U2. They're not using computers. And with more than a half-billion sub-Saharan Africans, it's doubtful that the relief efforts of Gates and Bono are making much of a difference.
Let's call this Muhammad Ali syndrome. Muhammad Ali is arguably the greatest heavyweight boxer in history. But so many of his admirers could care less how he beat George Foreman by unconventionally leading with his right, brilliantly using the loose ropes to his advantage, and courageously letting his opponent punch himself out. What matters to them is that he opposed the Vietnam war. Millions of people did that. Only Muhammad Ali did what Muhammad Ali did in the ring. The same goes for Bono and Gates. Their philanthropic endeavors are pedestrian, and in some ways, not even philanthropic. Their accomplishments in computers and music, on the other hand, have enriched the lives of millions. Time magazine missed that. But that's okay. I missed what "person of the year" Melinda Gates has accomplished other than convincing the world's richest man to marry her.
When Australians riot against Muslims, white racism is to blame. When Muslims riot against France, white racism is to blame.
Iranian President President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad doesn't want Jews in the Middle East. He has proposed that various Western states, including Germany and Austria, give up land for Israeli Jews to settle. Living in Germany, Austria, and other central European states didn't work out for Jews in the 20th century, so I doubt that Mr. Ahmadinejad's proposal will spur 21st-century Jews to want move back.
But there is a proposal that Mr. Ahmadinejad should consider if he truly wants Jews to hand over Israel to the Palestinans: leave Iran so that its previous occupants, the Zoroastrians, can return. Zoroastrians, despite living in Persia for centuries, endured persecution at the hands of the newcomers. Zoroastrians have an ancestral claim to Iran, just as you say Palestinians have an ancestral claim to Israel. The Muslim extremists who rule Iran, on the other hand, took Persia by force. That history book that you're reading, the one that denies Hitler's mass-murder of European Jews, probably denies the Muslim conquest of Iran, too. But this, like the Holocaust, happened.
Mr. Ahmadinejad, Iranian Muslims could return and assimilate into the Arabian peninsula whence the Muslims came fourteen centuries ago. This would certainly be easier than transplanting Israelis from the Middle East into European nations that speak different languages, practice different religions, and derive from a separate tribal stock. Sure, you'd have cultural obstacles to overcome by moving hundreds of miles from where you've lived your entire life. But would those burdens be as great as the ones you're proposing for Israelis, whom you wish to migrate to another continent thousands of miles away?
The Arabian conquest of Persia ultimately dispersed the Zoroastrians into numerous countries in which they form tiny minorities. Even the Palestinians have their own land. The Zoroastrians don't. But you can do something about this, Mr. Ahmadinejad. Encourage your coreligionists to migrate west and turn over your country to the 22,000 Zoroastrians still living there and the quarter-million or so living elsewhere.
By your example, you may inspire Jews to abandon the Middle East and hand over Israel to the Palestinians. Of course, giving up your country may not incite the Jews to give up theirs. But at least you'll sleep well knowing that you practice what you preach in regard to righting historic injustices and the like. And the rest of us will sleep better, too, knowing that Iran's nuclear program is in the hands of Zoroastrians and not Muslim lunatics. It's a win-win. What do you say?
The United Nations conference on climate change, an annual follow-up to Kyoto, is right now taking place in Montreal, where it's 19 degrees and snowing. The delegate from Ghana can't be pleased. If climate change were put to a vote at the Montreal conference, I dare say that the "yeas" would win the day. It might be better from a message standpoint to hold next year's event in the Mojave Desert or downtown Calcutta.
Sixty-four years ago today, Japan launched a preemptive strike against the United States at Pearl Harbor. What they were preempting is anyone's guess, but that's the rationalization that some writers hostile to America still make. Thankfully, the Congress, at President Roosevelt's request, responded on December 8 by declaring war on Japan rather than authorizing military force on some other country in the region, say, Mongolia, that had nothing to do with Pearl Harbor.
The White House today released a plan to win the war in Iraq. Read National Strategy for Victory in Iraq in HTML, or read it in PDF format here. We are fortunate that our enemies neither know how to read nor have Internet access--lest they learn about the plan. As its media promotion suggests, National Strategy for Victory in Iraq is more public relations than military blueprint. But at this point, Americans and not just Iraqis need to be won over. The mere existence of a plan, more so than its actual substance, is encouraging. And encouragement, amidst a lot of discouragement, is I suppose the point.
On China, George W. Bush is not his father's son. Remember George H. W. Bush's tepid condemnation of China's crackdown in Tiananmen Square? President Bush's subsequent support of "Most Favored Nation" trading status for China? Today, on the eve of his visit to China, the son of Richard Nixon's envoy to China pointed to Taiwan, the free island coveted and claimed by the totalitarian mainland, as a model that China might aspire to become. "By embracing freedom at all levels," George W. Bush declared from South Korea, "Taiwan has delivered prosperity to its people and created a free and democratic Chinese society." He then challenged Red China to become more free, more open, more democratic. George W. Bush's challenge to the Chinese may be more displeasing to the ears of party bosses than the rhetoric of past U.S. presidents, but it's not like he didn't warn them that 43 was different from 41--and 42, 39, and 37 for that matter.
Pressure, from Main Street to Capitol Hill, is building for U.S. forces to leave Iraq. Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld wants to stay in Iraq until Iraq can sustain a democracy. He explained Tuesday, "We must be careful not to give terrorists the false hope that if they can simply hold on long enough, that they can outlast us." Making a similar point, Majority Leader Bill Frist proclaimed yesterday that America doesn't need an exit strategy in Iraq, America needs a victory strategy. Rumsfeld and Frist seem to be saying that the attainment of a clear objective, rather than an arbitrary box on the calendar, should be the deciding factor regarding when it's time to end a military campaign.
But what constitutes victory in Iraq? And does our victory depend less on the performance of American soldiers than it does on the good citizenship of Iraqis? These are important questions. I don't know the answers. I'm hoping that the readership does--or at least has some ideas on the subject.
What is your threshold for victory in Iraq?
A. We already achieved victory when we ousted Saddam Hussein's government
B. Victory will be achieved if a regime that is friendly to U.S. interests remains in power
C. Victory will be achieved if we establish a free, stable, and democratic Iraq
D. Both B & C
E. Victory will be achieved if we cripple the terrorists within Iraq and set up a beachhead of democracy in Iraq that spreads throughout the region
F. Fill in your own answer
"We do not rule out that Mr. Cohen is serving someone's political order designed to present Kazakhstan and its people in a derogatory way," Yerzhan Ashykbayev, a spokesman for the Kazakh government, said yesterday. "We reserve the right to any legal action to prevent new pranks of the kind." The Mr. Cohen he refers to is comedian Sasha Baron Cohen, aka Staines, UK-based white rapper Ali G, aka Austrian homosexual club kid Bruno, aka Kazakhstani state-television reporter Borat. It is this last character, who depicts Kazakhstan as a backwater of sibling rape, anti-Semitism, and political killings, that has the Kazakhstan government upset.
While Ali G has landed interviews with international figures such as Boutros-Boutros Ghali, Borat has caused an international incident in enraging Kazakhstan. So which one of Sasha Baron Cohen's alter-egos rules the world? Ali G, who once asked Buzz Aldrin what it was like to walk on the sun? Borat, who displayed peculiar pictures of himself and his sister to a pair of Old South wine connoisseurs? Or, the dark horse, Bruno, who coaxed a group of college muscleheads on spring break to take their shirts off and get rowdy for the cameras only to reveal that he worked for Austrian Gay TV? Cast your votes.
France glorifies the destructive. The patriotic Frenchman is one who celebrates the destruction of France that began in 1789. The French killed their monarchs and then their church. Now, through massive immigration, the French are content to balkanize France. France, above all nations, venerates the alienated intellectual--Michel Foucault, Jean Paul Sartre, Frantz Fanon. "The only way to love France today," French fascist Pierre Drieu La Rochelle declared between the world wars, "is to hate it in its present form." Many French intellectuals of a more fashionable ideological pedigree concur. So do Muslim youths--well, they at least concur with the hating France part. "We hate France and France hates us," one young Muslim Frenchman proclaimed to the UK's Guardian. That no Charles Martel has put an end to the Islamic trashing of France is because France no longer lionizes such multiculturally inconvenient heroes as Charles Martel. How could France given that is has invited in massive numbers of those Martel fought to keep out?
On Tuesday a court in China sent a married couple, and the wife's brother, to prison for printing Bibles. China is so afraid of God's big black book because it refutes Mao's little red book. "If God had the face of a seventy-year-old man, we wouldn't care if he was back," a Communist Party official explained in the late 1990s. "But he has the face of millions twenty-year-olds, so we are worried."
The colonialists of the 20th century are the colonized of the 21st century. There aren't too many Frenchmen left in Tunis and Algiers. There are quite a few Tunisians and Algerians in Paris. The white man's burden of empire weighs heavy, even upon the progeny of imperialists.
Mikhail Gorbachev is touring the United States on a tour of the 20th anniversary of Perestroika, the reform campaign designed to prolong the Communist Party's hold on Russia and its satellite states. Last night, the former General Secretary of the Communist Party told an audience at the University of the Pacific McGeorge School of Law that it's "hard to imagine a calm, safe, and secure world" with current poverty levels. "If people's lives are not becoming better," he held, "people begin to change their minds and say democracy is worthless." His analysis reveals that long after Marxism lost its grip on Eastern Europe, it still holds a tight grip on him. One of the main pillars of Marxism is the materialist interpretation of history. This provides a one-size-fits-all answer to whatever questions come along. Most who reflexively invoke the economic causation argument do so without realizing that it is one of Karl Marx's central ideas.
Like most of Marx's ideas, applying the materialist interpretation to current events displays its ineptitude. Did poverty inspire the multimillionaire Osama bin Laden to wage jihad against the United States? Why are Mulsims the combatants in a majority of current wars? Is it economics, or ethnic and religious hatred, that motivated Iran's president to proclaim that Israel should be "wiped off the map"? To see the world through a Marxist lens is to always see an economic explanation even when one relating to nationalism, ideology, or religion would do.
Anti-gun zealots in Brazil thought their nationwide referendum to ban firearms was a slamdunk. As much as 80 percent of voters, according to polls, supported the ballot measure. "Most of the media supported the ban, so before the television spots, nobody gave it much thought, but when the pro-gun lobby got equal time the opinion really shifted," Jessica Galeria, a researcher for a Rio think-tank, told the Associated Press. "They were smart, using images of Nelson Mandela, Tiananmen Square and the Berlin Wall to link owning a gun with freedom." Brazilians got the message. On Sunday, they voted to defeat the gun ban by an almost 2 to 1 margin. Though Brazil contains 100 million less people than the United States, it witnesses significantly more gun deaths. Brazilians said no to giving a monopoly on gun ownership to the people who have done such a poor job protecting them. People living in dangerous places don't want to give up their guns, they want them close by.
A Spanish judge issued warrants Wednesday for the arrests of three U.S. Army tank crewmen who fired a round that killed two journalists staying in an Iraq hotel. Relying on the same authority, I am issuing a warrant for the arrest of Judge Santiago Pedraz. When your posse catches up with him, just make up a charge that suits you and proceed to administer punishment: a nature wedgie, a gookie cookie, and an Indian sunburn should suffice. As you send him on his way, kick him really hard in his hindquarters and say "hasta la vista." Pretend that you're proud of yourself for knowing Spanish. This will at once let him know that you're an American for using such a generic Spanish phrase, and reinforce his stereotype of Americans as ignorant cowboys. The effect of this will be to keep him thousands of miles away from us, and prevent his emigration to the United States even on the condition of the Moors return to Spain. Alright, you've heard my judicial order. Now saddle up and get this guy.
Joe McCarthy once told ex-Wisconsin governor Phil LaFollette, and brother of Senator Robert LaFollette, Jr., McCarthy's 1946 opponent, that he had a team of men who would go about the state wearing masks of his brother. They are going to randomly bump into people, McCarthy informed an aghast LaFollette, and say things like, "Hey, who do you think you are bumping into a United States Senator?"
Today in court, Saddam Hussein played the arrogant role McCarthy imagined for his Senatorial opponent. Jail humbles many a man, but not Saddam Hussein. I don't recognize "this so-called court," Hussein announced to the courtroom. Like some pathetic descendant of European royalty, he held on to his now meaningless title despite the change of government. He was still "president of Iraq," he declared. Perhaps his boldest move was pleading not guilty. Hussein tussled with guards, interrupted the prosecution, and even told the judge: "Who are you? What is all this?" Will he act so imperious when confronted with his executioner, or Who he meets after his execution?
Amidst the many negative stories--the truly negative, and those spun that way by reverse cheerleaders in the media--the trial (which is more than Saddam afforded to the innocent) of a murderer is a definite positive outcome of the Iraq war. Future General Amins, Colonel Qaddafis, and Colonel Mengistus, take notice of new consequences for old behavior. The law can catch up with any man, even a tyrant.
"God Almighty knows how much I miss meeting with you, how much I long to join you," begins Ayman al-Zawahiri's steamy letter to Abu Musab al-Zarqawi. "I think that if I could find a way to you, I would not delay a day, God willing." You can almost hear "It's Raining Men" playing in the background as Zawahiri writes. Had the repressed Mr. Zawahiri worked out his identity issues as a teenager, he would be happier and the world would be a better place.
Pakistan's government gave $1 million to the victims of Hurricane Katrina. The U.S. government has pledged $50 million to the victims of the earthquake in Pakistan. This comes atop $275 million in foreign aid allocated to Pakistan last year, and, hopefully, a good deal of charitable contributions from Americans recognizing the horror of Saturday's earthquake. Some Pakistanis have complained about the smallness of the U.S. government's financial commitment. No Americans, that I know of, have complained about the stinginess of the Pakistani government's Hurricane Katrina aid. It wouldn't occur to anyone to do so. Who expects Pakistan to come to the rescue when disasters strike? Even when disasters don't strike, many non-Westerners feel entitled to Western money. When the same people who burn U.S. flags, give a 10 percent favorability rating to America, and provide safe harbor to terrorists express ingratitude at hundreds of millions of dollars in aid, one has to wonder what level of U.S. aid would satisfy? Americans get burned twice over: first, by the U.S. government's habit of making donations with our money but without our consent; and second, by recipient nations berating us for not giving more. Is it culturally insensitive for Americans to expect a "thank you" instead of a "blank you" when giving up Fort Knox to foreigners?
Five hundred and thirteen years ago, Rodrigo de Triana shouted: "Tierra! Tierra!" The sailor aboard the Pinta spotted land--the New World--after more than two uneasy months at sea. "I," Christopher Columbus noted of his first encounter with the natives, "in order that they might feel great amity toward us, because I knew that they were a people to be delivered to our holy faith by faith rather than force, gave to some among them some red caps and some glass beads, which they hung round their necks, and many other things of little value." Columbus reported that the "Indians" were "pleased" and "became our friends." Columbus found the encountered pleasing too, describing them as "very gentle." The relationship between Europeans and Native Americans went downhill from there.
The Indians gave the Europeans syphillis. The Europeans gave the Indians smallpox. Despite the best efforts of countermythologists to make it so, Europeans did not introduce the Indians to slavery or war. Columbus found evidence of both within a few days of arrival and noted it in his journal. He found no sign of iron, the wheel, or a written language. Europeans would export such handy staples of post-Stone Age societies to the New World. But Europe's military superiority, alongside the white man's lust for gold, religious converts, and land--as well as the geographic isolation of the Native Americans that impeded their immune systems to combat fatal diseases--decimated the primitive people in the decades that followed.
One's view of the Americas, or more specifically the nation that bears that name, generally determines one's view of Columbus. "Happy Columbus Day," like "Merry Christmas," is increasingly heard as an insult. Enemies of the Italian sea captain celebrate Indigenous People's Day, protest Columbus Day observances, and compare Columbus to Hitler. Columbus kidnapped, enslaved, and exploited, his detractors exclaim. Indeed, he did. He also discovered the continent Americans live upon. Truth commands that we remember his misdeeds. Proportion suggests that we remember him first for his magnificent find.
A jury convicted Lynndie England and a cop arrested Cindy Sheehan on Monday. Sheehan, a mother victimized by war, plays a traditional feminine role in relation to war. England, an enlistee who mistreated Iraqi prisoners, plays a less familiar one. Women make war policy (Condi Rice), and protest war policy (Cindy Sheehan). They've played the hero (Jessica Lynch). They've played the goat (Lynndie England). They've even played terrorist. Shortly after the war began, for instance, two women--one pregnant--unleashed a suicide bombing that killed three coalition soldiers.
We've never become used to women in their traditional war role, as the grieving mother, widow, or sister. It's not likely that civilization will be quicker to embrace these new roles--woman as soldier, woman as terrorist, woman as sadistic jailer. Women shooting and getting shot, as prisoner-of-war brutalizer and brutalized, blowing up themselves and other people--all this seems even more unnatural for women than for men. It's only 2005. There's more on the way. At least when it comes to war, for woman to approach equality with man she had to subtract from her traditional station.
North Korea demands that the United States provide it with a nuclear-power plant, and then in return, North Korea will abandon its efforts to build nuclear weapons. Somebody in the White House should show President Bush Raiders of the Lost Ark so that he understands that this sort of deal never works out in the end.
"All FDNY, get the f*** out!," commanders ordered firefighters in the North Tower shortly after the South Tower collapsed. "We're not f***ing coming out!," the firemen answered. The heroes and the villains of September 11, 2001 number too many to list. Four years later, we can remember but not revise history. A year ago, I read the 9/11 Report. My reaction can be read in part one, part two, part three, and part four. Pray for the souls of the departed.
"Anywhere from two to 2,000 people near the plant were reported to have been killed by causes ranging from the initial blast to lethal radiation," Time magazine reported immediately following 1986's nuclear power plant disaster at Chernobyl, Ukraine in the USSR. Five years later, USA Today contended that up to 10,000 people had died. About a decade after that, the BBC pointed to an estimate of 15,000 deaths. This week, a UN commission of 100 scientists placed the death toll at 56. Environmentalists, anti-Communists, and media sensationalists all had motive to inflate the enormity of the Chernobyl nuclear catastrophe. No nuclear power plants have been built in Europe or North America since. The event gave a black eye to Mikhail Gorbachev's government, reinforcing the point that, despite the youthful makeover at the top, this was the same old Soviet Union. And, like the fabrications surrounding the current tragedy, Chernobyl myths sold newspapers. The lesson? Don't believe everything you read--unless I write it.
There are people in New Orleans who have had neither access to food nor, ironically, drinking water for several days. Who wouldn't raid a 7-11 if in a similar position? There are people in New Orleans who haven't had electricity for several days and won't have electricity for several months, yet have raided department stores in search of flat-screen televisions. Who would do this if in a similar position? A bad person. Looting adds insult to injury. It victimizes the victim a second time. It takes advantage of an already dredful situation. It's hard to imagine a more lawless situation than the packs setting upon Big Easy homes and businesses--until one learns the sad reality that some policemen have joined the roving brigands. The law-abiding citizens of New Orleans have awoken from one nightmare only to face another.
When terrorists killed 3,000 people on 9/11, they blamed the United States. When the Boxer Day tsunami took more than a hundred thousand lives, they blamed the United States. When Hurricane Katrina devastated the Gulf Coast, they blamed the United States. Stock answers are correct with about the same frequency as a broken clock. Events don't conform to ideological scripts. America has the right enemies.
President Bush yesterday commemorated the formal Japanese surrender on board the USS Missouri sixty years ago by delivering a speech in which he compared World War II with the Iraq war. "As we mark this anniversary," the president declared, "we are again a nation at war. Once again, war came to our shores with a surprise attack that killed thousands in cold blood." He subsequently referenced Iraq more than a dozen times.
Iraq is not Vietnam, as too many war opponents contend. More than 25 times as many Americans died in Vietnam as have died in Iraq. The enemy, the terrain, the tactics, and so much more differs.
Iraq is also not World War II. Had Franklin Roosevelt attacked China after Pearl Harbor, as Bush attacked Iraq 18 months after 9/11, then the comparison would hold. But since Japan attacked the American Navy, and Germany declared war on the United States, the comparison with Iraq does not hold--as Iraq neither attacked the United States nor declared war upon it. Similarly, Bush juxtaposed Japan's reconstruction with Iraq's reconstruction. "American and Japanese experts claimed that the Japanese weren't ready for democracy," he told those gathered in San Diego, who presumably were to fill in the blank with "Hey, people are saying the same thing about Iraq!" The difference is that Japan and Germany had some experience with self-government; Iraq has no such history. Other glaring differences emerge from such an ahistorical comparison, such as America's lack of allies in Iraq vis-a-vis our World War II experience. Ninety percent of the coalition war dead, for instance, are Americans.
Generals, the thought goes, foolishly prepare to fight the last war. War's proponents and opponents are far more guilty of this offense, rhetorically fighting their adversaries by appealing to the glories or horrors of distant conflicts regardless of their relevance to the present one.
The submitted draft of the Iraqi constitution is better than earlier drafts. Still, it contains much that disturbs Western eyes. "Islam is the official religion of the state and is a basic source of legislation," reads the draft Iraqi Constitution. "No law can be passed that contradicts the undisputed rules of Islam."
The constution gives all Iraqis accused of crime the right to a trial, but by the judiciary and not by a jury. Article 30 "guarantees social and health insurance." Article 34 proclaims: "Free education is a right for Iraqis in all its stages." The freedom from the federal government outlined in the American First Amendment are guaranteed, "as long as it does not violate public order and morality." The documents even points to a state "childrearing policy."
Despite the nit-picking, and the more substantial criticisms, the constitution improves upon what existed. Its most controversial plank, establishing federalism to foster self-government within the diverse localities, may prove the most important plank if this Iraqi government survives. But will any of this matter? Totalitarian governments made genuflections to high-minded principles in their constitutions, but rarely obeyed these power-limiting dictates. Even the governments of free nations regularly ignore facets of their constitutions that prove inconvenient. "On paper, many Arab states have liberal constitutions," writes Ivan Eland of the Independent Institute, "but they do not have the political culture or institutions to sustain an open political system." In other words, the fuss about the Iraqi constitution might be much ado about nothing. If the Iraqi government doesn't abide by the limitations its constitution demands of it, the constitution won't be worth the paper it is printed on. Whether the lofty promises made by the constitution already render the document of less worth than the paper it is printed on is another question.
It is unreasonable to reason with unreasonable people. Australia's leaders understand this. I wish they could make other Western leaders understand this. "You won't change the minds of people who are hardened fanatics and hardened extremists," Prime Minister John Howard explained last week. "You have to identify them and take measures to ensure that they don't become a problem." Those measures include, in extreme circumstances, deportation. The treasury minister echoed his boss. "If [Australian values] are not your values, if you want a country which has Sharia law or a theocratic state, then Australia is not for you." Ditto for the education minister, who suggested that Muslim radicals "clear off." Tolerance need not be a suicide pact.
Pat Robertson's has apologized for his unsolicited counsel to President Bush that he assassinate Venezuelan strongman Hugo Chavez, so just about everyone is in agreement, including apparently Robertson, that his televised remarks were stupid. But were they stupid simply because Chavez is a world leader supposedly immune from such indignities, or were they stupid because Chavez neither poses a direct threat to the U.S. nor oppresses his people in the manner of a Saddam Hussein or a Kim Jong Il? These last two dictators, Roberton also advocated killing, along with Osama bin Laden. Several years ago, Robertson asked: "Isn't it better to...take out Saddam Hussein, rather than to spend billions of dollars on a war that harms innocent civilians and destroys the infrastructure of a country?" Well, isn't it? Claus von Stauffenberg is a hero, not a terrorist. Right?
If one concedes that Hitler's would-be assassins' actions were heroic, then one can't logically dismiss out-of-hand the general idea that assassination is on very rare occassions a moral and beneficial act.
War and assassination, though, aren't the only two options available to U.S. presidents. The U.S. could stay out of the affairs of foreign nations that don't threaten its just interests. But if war--and the death, destruction, and financial waste that always accompanies it--is the primary option on the table, then isn't, we'll call it "the Robertson option," a more humane choice? In other words, why kill tens of thousands of hostile soldiers and innocent civilians, risk the lives of your fellow countrymen, destroy a nation's infrastructure, and waste billions of dollars when you could alleviate the problem with the cost of one bullet at the price of one tyrant's life? If killing dictators who murder their fellow countrymen and threaten their neighbors is wrong, why is killing foreign soldiers and civilians to depose such dictators right? Those who view the lives of reigning murderers as sacrosanct and the lives of innocents as expendable have things bassackwards.
Or, is assassination like torture--a practice that once used in understandable circumstances sanctions its use in all sorts of circumstances? Its use in U.S. interests condones its use against U.S. interests. In this view, assassination can be moral but not utilitarian. And while assassinating Hitler would have saved countless lives, in most instances assassinating a despot just leads to his replacement by another despot. Perhaps assassination is too simple a solution for a complex world.
Pat Robertson's specific advice to kill Hugo Chavez deserved the quick dismissal it received from the public, the media, and the politicians. The more generalized discussion regarding assassination evokes serious ethical questions, deserving of more serious debate than they are receiving.
Televangelist Pat Robertson believes U.S. operatives should ace Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez. Should they? Are there situations that warrant politically-ordered assassinations? Does this situation fit the bill? Do other governments retain the right to similarly act on their moral judgments? Or, is killing world leaders the prerogative of one nation's leaders?
I blog from England, which is even more politically correct than the United States. Tony Blair's common-sense proposal to eject radical clerics preaching violence against the United Kingdom has been met with hysteria. "I see similarities with Hitler," says Mohammed Naseem of Tony Blair. Sheikh Muhammad Umar opines: "The solution is not to ban these organisations, it is to engage with them. What Tony Blair need to do is he needs to do more casework. We need to have dialogue with these groups, not alienate them." Meanwhile, the national media, which is well left of the American media, is in an uproar over police on the lookout for men who fit the profile of the 7/7 bombers and the 7/21 wannabe bombers. One young male South Asian reporter walked about the London Underground with a hidden camera while wearing an overstuffed backpack. With an indignant tone, he showed viewers how police stopped him three times. One man's outrage is another man's good police work. On the television, one would never know such a thing as "England" exists, as "Britain" and other more inclusive labels have replaced it. So sensitive to offending Muslims are the authorities that Greater Manchester officials banned a newlywed couple from playing Robbie Williams's "Angels" after their civil marriage ceremony. Along with Bryan Adams's "Heaven" and Aretha Franklin's "I Say a Little Prayer," "Angels" risked offending non-Christians. When should we expect a crescent to join St. George's Cross on the Union Jack?
Japan announced its World War II surrender 60 years ago today. That date marks the height of America's power relative to the rest of the world. The US had defeated its enemies. The war left previous world powers, Germany and the United Kingdom, in shambles. The US alone had the bomb. The US GDP eclipsed the GDPs of the USSR, the UK, Germany, France, Japan, Italy, and Austria combined. Even more than upon the Soviet Union's collapse, or on 9/10, or today--when the US is commonly referred to as the world's lone superpower--recent American power can't compare to the power it held on August 15, 1945. Though US power has grown in absolute terms, it has unquestionably and inevitably declined in relative terms. Perhaps less significant than the power was how America used it (If not an American Century, consider the alternatives: The Nazi Century? The Soviet Century? The Century of British Empire?). The US rebuilt rather than gouged its enemies. The American Century that Henry Luce proclaimed on February 7, 1941 never rang so true than on the day Japan surrendered.
More than a decade ago, former Senator Fritz Hollings, angered by disparaging comments a Japanese official had made about American workers, got an idea for a t-shirt. "Made in America, Tested in Japan" the t-shirt would read. In the middle of the shirt, below the first phrase and above the second, would appear a mushroom cloud.
Sixty years ago today, the United States dropped an atomic bomb on the Japanese city of Hiroshima. The Enola Gay's 10,000-pound payload killed more than 80,000 Japanese civilians. The Japanese announced their surrender shortly thereafter.
Six decades later, the debate over Hiroshima rages. On the one hand, the United States government dropped an indiscriminant weapon of mass destruction on a civilian population. Do ethical principles change once war comes? Do the ends justify the means when the bad guys suffer the means? On the other hand, dropping the bomb saved lives, both American and Japanese. The Japanese surrender/survival rate at Iwo Jima and Tarawa was less than one percent. It took Hiroshima and Nagasaki to compel the Japanese to finally surrender.
You're Harry Truman. It's August 6, 1945. Do you drop the bomb?
Joan Collins gave a "wake up!" slap upside the head to fellow Brits Englishmen today, the likes of which we haven't seen since Alexis Carrington Colby belted Krystle Jennings. "I believe that when a country loses so much respect for itself that it can no longer even be identified by its historically correct name, insecurity and lack of respect filter down to its inhabitants," Collins wrote in Thursday's edition of the Daily Mail, deriding those who insist on erasing "English" for "British" and "England" for the "UK." Englishmen--not Muslims, not Asian street vendors, not Eurotrash--are destroying England from within. Pointing to bad manners, self-obsession, and "feral mobs" roaming the streets, Collins notes that the English aren't acting very English these days. "It's frightful how being told that you are no good makes you hate yourself, and hate others. And it's frightful how quickly a whole country of self-loathers can be bred."
The House of Representatives passed the Central American Free Trade Agreement by the slightest of margins this morning, 217 yeas to 215 nays. Just 15 Democrats broke ranks to support the agreement, and 25 Republicans rebelled against the president and House leadership to oppose the measure. CAFTA aims to lower tafiffs between Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, the Dominican Republic, and the United States.
Is the war on terror more like the Peloponnesian War, the Crusades, the Crimean War, and World War II, or is it more like the war on poverty, the war on drugs, the war on obesity, and other political marketing schemes? In other words, is it an actual war or just a slogan? A disturbing article in the International Herald Tribune suggests it's more the latter than the former, with Bush Administration officials discarding the phrase "war on terror" now that it has fallen out of fashion. Orange is the new pink.
The Keystone Terrorists struck London Thursday, injuring no one but themselves. For every 9/11 or Madrid where Westerners marvel at the diabolical ingenuity of the terrorists, there are many examples of bumbling terrorists whose incompetence suggests that they might have trouble executing a stinkbomb attack upon the Saturday matinee. When al Qaeda attempted to blow up the USS Sullivans in the Gulf of Aden, they failed because their overloaded, explosive-laden boat sank before reaching its target. The 9/11 Commission Report detailed hucksters swindling bin Laden in the Sudan for $1.5 million: "Al Qaeda apparently purchased the [weapons-grade uranium] cylander, then discovered it to be bogus." Similarly, terrorist stupidity led to the capture of the 1993 World Trade Center bombers. The 9/11 Commission Report noted how "Mohammed Salameh, who had rented the truck [used in the bombing] and reported it stolen, kept calling the rental office to get back his $400 deposit." Mr. Salameh's greed and impetuousness helped unravel the whole conspiracy. If only we were so fortunate that all our enemies were so stupid.
An Islamist fanatic blamed the West for the London bombings. The mayor of that city agrees with him. Considering this alternative, it's a good thing for New York that they had the leadership of Rudy Giuliani after the stateside terrorist attacks. But it's a better thing for Ken Livingstone that he's the mayor of London after 7/7 and not the mayor of New York after 9/11. Let's face it: the Gramercy Riffs, the Baseball Furies, the Turnbull ACs, and a dozen other fictional New York street gangs, including, even, the Orphans, would make quick work of this fool.
Anjem Choudary, an Islamic leader in Britain, refuses to condemn the London bombings. "The British government wants to show that they are on the side of justice and of truth, whereas in reality the real terrorists are the British regime, and even the British police, who have tried to divide the Muslim community into moderates and extremists, whereas this classification doesn't exist in Islam," Choudary remarked on state-run radio. Ken Livingstone, the socialist mayor of London, holds: "You've just had 80 years of Western intervention into predominantly Arab lands because of a Western need for oil. We've propped up unsavoury governments, we've overthrown ones that we didn’t consider sympathetic." He continued: "I think the particular problem we have at the moment is that in the 1980s...the Americans recruited and trained Osama bin Laden, taught him how to kill, to make bombs, and set him off to kill the Russians to drive them out of Afghanistan.... They didn’t give any thought to the fact that once he’d done that, he might turn on his creators." Yeah, sure Ken. Ronald Reagan did it. Keep reading Lyndon LaRouche tracts, why don't you? Screwball.
UPDATE: Four more blasts rocked London today. We can soon expect Ken Livingstone to put out an All Points Bulletin for Ollie North, the ghost of former CIA director William Casey, and Reagan-era Secretary of State George Shultz. I can hear Red Ken's radio dispatch now: "Ignore those Pakistani men with oversized backpacks! American right-wingers are the real culprits here! Get them! Track them down!"
Think our legal system is messed up? An Islamic judicial board in northern India ordered a woman to marry her rapist. The trouble is--apart from the obvious fact that he is her rapist--the woman is already married....to the rapist's son. Thus, the board ordered her to divorce her husband. "The fact that the woman was 'used' by her husband's blood relative makes her [unclean] for her husband and there is no way she can be allowed to live with him," the Islamic kooks ruled. "She had a physical relationship with her father-in-law, and it nullifies her marriage," contends Mohammad Masood Madani, a cleric at the theological school that issued the fatwa.
Within hours of the assassination of a drafter of the Iraqi Constitution, Iraqi President Jalal Talabani announced that a version of the constitution would be made public within the next month. But a working draft of the Iraqi Constitution (PDF) has already been released by Iraqi media. Parts of the document appear as though it were written by the mob awaiting their welfare checks.
"The basis of the national economy is social justice," Article 18 reads. "The state shall bear the responsibility for growth, developing production and services, building a solid infrastructure for the economy of the country, and providing services." "Iraqi citizens have the right to enjoy security and free health care," the document proclaims. "The state shall guarantee the realization of the social guarantee necessary for citizens in case of old age, disease, inability to work, or if they are homeless, orphans, widowed, or unemployed. It shall provide them social insurance services and health care and protect them from the talons of ignorance, fear, and want, providing them with housing, and special programs to train them and care for them." "Work is a right for every Iraqi citizen and a duty for him," the draft constitution explains. "The state and the governments of the regions shall strive to provide work opportunities for every able-bodied citizen."
Whereas the American Constitution and Bill of Rights outline limitations on state power, the would-be Iraqi Constitution outlines the vast powers of the state. In contrast to the First Amendment's prohibitions on congressional interference in speech, Iraq's Article 6 states: "There is no censorship on newspapers, printing, publishing, advertising, or media except by law." (Does not the final clause render its antecedent meaningless?) In contrast to the Second Amendment's acknowledgement of the right to keep and bear arms, Article 22 declares: "Citizens may not own, bear, buy, or sell weapons, except by a permit issued in accordance with law."
Elsewhere, the draft constitution's vagueness provides cover for future governmental mischief. "The Iraqi people are one people, unified by belief and the unity of the homeland and culture," Article 5 notes. "Anything that exposes this unity to danger is forbidden." Article 13 states: "Public and private freedoms are protected provided they do not conflict with moral values and public decency."
The Iraqi Constitution should not be a carbon copy of the American Constitution. Iraqis have a different history, a different religion, a different language, and a different culture than Americans. It makes sense that they also have a different constitution. But a recognition that difference doesn't mean disaster shouldn't blind us to differences that do mean disaster.
Civilized people don't celebrate Bastille Day. They mourn it. Two-hundred and sixteen years ago, a mob stormed a Paris prison "liberating a mere seven prisoners (including two lunatics, four forgers and an aristocratic delinquent who had been committed with de Sade)," informs Simon Schama, author of Citizens (buy it here). The jail-break of four criminals, two crazies, and a pervert was the immediate effect. Bastille Day's short-term effects included the murder of the King and Queen, the destruction of the Catholic Church in France, the Terror, revolution as end and not means, and twenty-three years of revolutionary wars to spread "liberty." In the long term, the French Revolution served as the dress rehearsal for the 20th Century.
"Liberty is a bitch who likes to be bedded on a mattress of cadavers," Desmoulins reported. "French Republicans," Robespierre pled, "it is for you to purify the earth that has been soiled and to recall to the earth Justice which has been banished from it." "Let us be terrible so that the people will not have to be," argued Danton. "There must be blood to cement the revolution," Madame Roland declared. Indeed, the "cadavers" and "blood" would include their own. The revolutionists planted skull and bones throughout France, but liberty did not grow.
Not all Frenchmen celebrated this bloodfest. Abbe Bernier, in the Grand Council's "Address to the French," charged: "Patriots, our enemies, you accuse us of overturning our patrie by rebellion but it is you, who, subverting all the principles of the religious and political order, were the first to proclaim that insurrection is the most sacred of duties. You have introduced atheism in the place of religion, anarchy in the place of laws, men who are tyrants in the place of the King who was our father. You reproach us with religious fanaticism, you whose pretensions to liberty have led to the most extreme penalties." "Citizens," Pierre Vergniaud courageously implored the Convention in 1793, "let us profit from the lessons of experience. We can overturn empires by victories but we can only make revolutions for other peoples by the spectacle of our own happiness. We want to upset thrones. Let us prove that we know how to be happy with a Republic." "Liberty, equality, and fraternity," Chamfort recognized, evolved into "Be my brother or I'll kill you."
"I take complete responsibility for my actions. I acted purely in the name of my religion," murderer Mohammed Bouyeri told a Dutch court. Bouyeri, a Muslim born in the Netherlands, killed filmmaker Theo Van Gogh because Van Gogh had criticized Islam. "I can assure you that one day, should I be set free, I would do exactly the same, exactly the same," admitted Bouyeri.
Does immigration inculcate Western values or does it threaten Western values? Probably a little bit of both. In the Netherlands, second-generation Dutch, such as Bouyeri, can live in a nation within a nation. The same goes for Muslims in Britain (2 million Muslims), France (5 million Muslims), and Germany (3.2 million Muslims). That internal Islamic nation can stand for everything that the surrounding society stands against. Certainly the Islamic fanatic Bouyeri didn't absorb religious intolerance and sectarian violence from Dutch society? But the Netherlands, by its open-borders policy of national suicide, is learning more about religious intolerance and sectarian violence from non-traditional Dutchmen like Bouyeri.
"Many Democrats who used to scoff at conservative fears about activist judges are now joining their barricades when it comes to eminent domain," John Fund writes in OpinionJournal.com. The Kelo decision, handed down by the court's liberal wing, empowers governments to transfer property from its owners to its coveters. Since the city of New London reasoned (in the court's words) that transferring working-class people's property to wealthy developers would "provide appreciable benefits to the community, including, but not limited to, new jobs and increased tax revenue," the court rationalized the government-sanctioned theft.
Since the targets of such expropriation tend to stand on the lower rungs of the economic ladder, those representing such constituences, including most of the Congressional Black Caucus, are fighting mad. Fund quotes Wilhelmina Leigh of the DC-based Joint Center for Political and Economic Studies: "[Kelo] means you have to hope and trust in the goodness of other human beings that if you buy real estate that you will be allowed to keep it." Kelo abolishes the right to private property, which theoretically makes property "rights" in the U.S. no more stable than....
...in Zimbabwe, which, based on the same logic that guided Kelo, has been expropriating the land of white farmers for several years. The farmers' land, it is argued, would better serve the community if it were split among the populace. The property of New Londoners, it is argued, would better serve the community if it were absorbed by a corporation. While there is an economic role reversal in those targeted, the guiding justification is the same: private property coveted by private citizens can be taken when politicians perceive reward (be it economic or electoral).
And now Zimbabwe targets shantytowns--urban blight, Africa-style--for destruction. Replacing open-air markets and humble domiciles with new structures, Robert Mugabe's government holds, will improve the lives of its citizens. The citizens living in the condemned dwellings don't agree. Michael Davies, chairman of a residential association of three million Zimbabweans, explains that Zimbabwe is "basically in a war situation where the police don't respect due process." Thus, many residents don't even get to make their case before a judge. And the residents who do get their day in court? "The police just ignore court orders," Davies continued. "We have criminals in charge of the state, and criminals don't respect the law. If you order them off your property, you are asking for a truncheon across the head."
Thank goodness I don't live in Zimbabwe, at least not yet.
I pass by the British Embassy in Washington, DC to and from work. In the wake of the London terrorist attacks that wounded more than 700, several camera crews taped in front of the Massachusetts Avenue complex as I drove by this morning. This afternoon, three young women approached the embassy's closed gates with bouquets of flowers. Covering the entrance were flowers and notes of support, with one posterboard stating: "We Stand With You." It's good that the British know who stands with them. It's more important that they know who doesn't. In the coming days, ghoulish individuals who relish civilian deaths in nations they have grievances with will emerge from the dark places they inhabit. Some of these people will be Londoners.
First Live 8, then the G8, then the Olympics announcement, and now a terrorist attack. Great Britain has been the center of the news universe the last few days. Unfortunately, this latest news is bad news. Islamic terrorists have claimed credit for four bombings in London that have killed more than 40 people. Despite no scarcity of Western military targets in their own backyard, the terrorists chose to kill civilians in London. Is not today's operation a tacit admission of both cowardice and weakness?
Live 8 didn't raise any money for starving or diseased Africans. It did raise quite a bit of cash for already wealthy entertainers. According to HMV, UK sales of greatest hits packages increased 1343 percent for Pink Floyd, 863 percent for The Who, and 500 percent for Annie Lennox. Just for appearing, performers received $12,000 "goodie bags"--an amount larger than the per capita GDP of every African nation--that included Bertolucci watches and Hugo Boss duffel bags.
Live 8 was not a charitable event, but a racket designed to persuade G8 governments to force taxpayers to make contributions to African governments. While liberals generally have no problem with such coercion, some do have a problem with Live 8. "Good God, this is a moral crime," writes left-wing writer Eric Alterman. "All that money available just for the asking--all those lives that could be saved by people who won’t miss the money--and these guys won't even bother to ask? They won’t even allow charities to canvass the audience. Turns out the concert is NOTHING, and I mean NOTHING but moral vanity, and the exploitation of starving, sick Africans, by pampered, rich as**oles and their self-interested corporate sponsors rather than their potential salvation. This is really unspeakably shameful."
I'm enjoying the music of Live 8, but not the evil cause behind it. The difference between Live 8 and Live Aid is the difference between force and freedom, between the the stick-up man and the Salvation Army Santa Claus. If Bono, Dave Matthews, and Paul McCartney wish to siphon off a portion of their lucrative earnings to give to African governments, then they should go ahead and do so. I'm not stopping you. Please don't stop me from using my money to the way I see fit. Live Aid was charity. Live 8 is a racket.
Without freedom, there is no virtue. Charity, a virtuous untertaking, presupposes free will. When Robin Hood points his arrow at you and you hand over your wallet, neither Robin Hood nor you has acted generously. Your act was compelled; Robin Hood's subsequent transfer of your lucre to the poor came at no financial sacrifice to him. The morality of governments taking your money to give to other governments is something akin to all this, only it's far worse. Robin Hood, after all, didn't distribute his plunder to the corrupt Sheriff of Nottingham or the tyrannical Prince John.
For the reasons above, there is nothing particularly noble in Live 8's call for increased aid to African governments. For another reason, there's nothing particularly effective in such socialist wealth transfers. This weekend's news of Nigeria's rulers stealing hundreds of billions from their nation's coffers demonstrates this.
Many legitimate charities help in the fight against AIDS, poverty, malaria, polluted water, and other diverse maladies that still afflict the Dark Continent. Your government is not one of these charities.
Noel Gallagher of Oasis thinks the concept behind Live 8 is foolish. "Correct me if I'm wrong, but are they hoping that one of these guys from the G8 is on a quick 15 minute break at Gleneagles (in Scotland) and sees Annie Lennox singing Sweet Dreams and thinks, 'F--- me, she might have a point there, you know?'" quipped the pugnacious guitarist. "It's not going to happen, is it?" I hope not, Noel. Even if the food rotted on Ethiopian docks, the event propped up socialist regimes, and routed charity to corrupt officials, at least the spirit behind 1985's Live Aid was humanitarian enough. No one forced anyone to give anything. Live 8, on the other hand, seeks to persuade our government, and the other member states of the G8, to absolve the debts of Third World governments and compel citizens in G8 nations to make involuntary contributions to these often corrupt and socialistic governments via foreign aid. Bob Geldof is as cavalier with other people's money as he was with that bathroom mirror in The Wall. Next time he would do better to pass the hat to his rich friends than to play stick-up man to the rest of us.
More Americans died in Iraq in April than in March, in May than in April, and, unfortunately, if the current rate holds, in June than in May. Partly because of this, the president's popularity and support for the Iraq war have both plummetted. According to a CBS News poll a majority of Americans believe we should have stayed out of Iraq, and six in ten believe things are going badly for the U.S. there. Senior officers have begun to concede as much about the nation-building operation. "We can’t kill them all," Lt. Col. Frederick Wellman observed. "When I kill one, I create three." Recruits, despite the lure of bonuses as great as $40,000, remain scarce in the Army and Navy.
The American people are telling their representatives something. Four are listening. Conservatives Ron Paul and Walter Jones and liberals Neil Abercrombie and Dennis Kucinich introduced "Withdrawal of United States Armed Forces From Iraq Resolution of 2005—Homeward Bound" in Congress on Thursday. It proposes U.S. troop reductions to begin in Iraq before October 1, 2006. The resolution calls for the president "at the earliest possible date, to turn over all military operations in Iraq to the elected Government of Iraq and provide for the prompt and orderly withdrawal of all United States Armed Forces from Iraq." Congressman Jones's support of the legislation is a profile in courage. Jones represents a coastal district in conservative North Carolina, teeming with retired veterans and active duty military. He vocally supported the war in 2003, but is now "troubled" by what he finds--or what we didn't find--in Iraq. Is he worried that his stance will alienate him from the Republican leadership or turn off constituencies back home? Jones answered yesterday, "I will never worry doing what's right."
June 15 stands as one of the most significant dates in the history of freedom. On this date in 1215, King John affixed his seal on the Magna Carta at Runnymede. The document, agreed to by King John under duress, outlined a number of matters in which the government and its agents couldn't infringe upon the liberties of free men. The first point affirms that "the Church of England shall be free, and shall have her whole rights and liberties involiable." Following the restriction of the King's power over the Church, the Magna Carta grants rights to women regarding marriage and inheritances, limits fines for trivial offenses, prohibits arbitrary land expropriation, forbids government officials from confiscating goods, and affirms the right of self-government within the Church and among the barons. "The barons shall elect twenty-five of their number to keep, and cause to be observed with all their might, the peace and liberties granted and confirmed to them by this charter," one of the document's concluding paragraphs notes.
The agedness of the Magna Carta and how meager the rights, privileges, and freedoms strike many moderns demonstrate that the societies of the West were made and not born. No genius in a laboratory, or council of wise men sitting round a fire, invented the government we have today. It developed. And as much as we might like our form of government, our mere example and persuasion can't convince outsiders to embrace it there overnight absent the historical set of circumstances that gave rise to it here over thousands of years.
"To hell with his human rights," shouts the menacing guard, "Give him Aguilera!" "No! I'll talk. I'll talk," the prisoner responds. "Anything but the Aguilera!" The detainee begins to intricately describe the inner workings of al Qaeda.
U.S. interrogators at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba employ a widely known but rarely used form of torture: the music of Christina Aguilera. You can bet that the bad guys will talk after a few minutes of "Beautiful." And if they don't, why then, the guards can just crank up Air Supply to eleven, or introduce the prisoner to the musical stylings of DeBarge. Somebody call Amnesty International to make the torment stop.
Al Qaeda killed 3,000 people on September 11, 2001. Guantanamo Bay holds hundreds of members of the group that carried out the 9/11 attacks. Jimmy Carter and the center bearing his name believe that President Bush should "Close down Guantanamo and the two dozen secret detention facilities run by the United States as soon as practicable." Other statesmen of Carter's stature agree, including this guy, this guy, this guy, and this guy. Good public relations doesn't always equate to good public policy.
"No one," Robespierre warned his countrymen in the early days of the French Revolution, "likes armed missionaries." If only they had heeded his advice, and if only Robespierre himself had only heeded it, everyone would have been the better for it. More than two-hundred years later, Robespierre's words, and the perils wrought from France's disregard of them, offer a lesson to Americans.
Islamic fanatics decapitated Nick Berg, slit Daniel Pearl's throat, and dragged the corpses of Americans through the streets of Iraq and Somalia. A few Americans, on the other hand, tortured...a book. The Pentagon released information late Friday detailing that a Guantanamo Bay interrogator kicked a Koran, while some prison guards had a water balloon fight that left some prisoners, and their Korans, damp. Oh, the humanity! It turns out Newsweek's story of a Koran thrown in a toilet did occur, only the culprit was a prisoner who despaired that he no loner cared for Islam. I guess it was all a misunderstanding--a misunderstanding that led to more than a dozen deaths in nations where less than half the population can even read the Koran.
Should Europe become a borderless supranation, or should Europe remain France, Germany, Italy, Holland, and so on? France prefers national preservation to state suicide. Polls indicate that the Dutch, who choose to adopt or reject the proposed constitution of the European Union today, prefer national preservation too. The EU constitution is a document drafted by elites to concentrate power in their hands. Arrogantly, the few expected the sanction of the many in tranferring the power from the many to the few. This weekend, Frenchmen issued a stern rebuke to this power grab. Understandably, French voters rejected the handover of the traditional powers of French voters to a supranational body less accountable to French voters. The EU is dangerous to the United States, but not as dangerous as it is to France, Germany, and England, which will cease to resemble France, Germany, and England if they continue to give up power to a distant government.
"The detention facility at Guantánamo Bay has become the gulag of our times," claims Irene Khan, the secretary general of Amnesty International. If Guantanamo Bay is the Gulag of our times, what does this say about our times? We know of 476 camps in the Soviet Gulag; there is but one Guantanamo Bay. The Gulag imprisoned about 18 million people over the course of several decades; Guantanamo Bay has housed fewer than 1,000 prisoners since the start of the war on terrorism. It currently holds less than 550 people. Historians place the number of deaths in the Soviet Gulag in the millions; treatment of the inmates at Guantanamo Bay has led to zero prisoner deaths. "When the most powerful country in the world thumbs its nose at the rule of law and human rights," Amnesty International's Khan maintains, "it grants a licence to others to commit abuse with impunity and audacity." A stronger case can be made that when the globe's most famous human rights organization makes such over-the-top statements as the Guantanamo/Gulag comparison, it grants a license to others to lie with impunity and audacity.
Memorial Day grew out of remembrances of the Civil War dead. It became a truly national holiday in the wake of the Great War. Today, our nation is immersed in another war. Since last Memorial Day, the number of Americans killed in Iraq has doubled. The number of American military fatalities in this current war stands at 1,657. This is a tiny fraction of the war losses from the Civil War, World War I, or World War II. But there is something dehumanizing in reducing human loss to a mathematical equation.
In 1861, 1918, and 1942, the U.S. government conscripted men to fight. In 2005, thankfully, America has an all-volunteer military. This, more than the lighter body count, stands as the prime reason that American civilians continue with their daily affairs, oblivious to the reality that faces their fellow countrymen a half-world away. Patriotic Americans treat war-dead inscripted monuments with religious veneration. Reminders from Nightline or Doonsebury of the more current war dead are treated as a nuisance.
Less than half of one percent of Americans serve under arms. During the Civil War, the fraction numbered greater than ten percent. During World War II, greater than twelve percent of the population served in some military capacity. It was common for brothers, fathers, sons, and husbands to be at risk. It is uncommon now. Most Americans may know of someone serving in Iraq. Most Americans don't know someone serving in Iraq. This war doesn't hit home because this war doesn't hit home.
This war hits home for me. For eight years, I called the Marine Corps home--at least one weekend a month, and a few weeks a year. A year after my service ended, my unit was called up to fight in Iraq. They all came back save one friend, Gregory MacDonald. I see Greg as a flesh and blood person, and not as a name on a roster of the war dead. When one approaches the names of the 1,657 Americans killed in Iraq from this human standpoint, one's view of this war becomes less narrow. When one approaches the million-plus Americans dead from war from a human rather than a utilitarian standpoint, one's view of war becomes less narrow. It's welcome that war personally impacts fewer and fewer Americans. The downside of this is that people immune from war's costs treat making war in a more flippant manner.
War is serious. War isn't a video game, however much night-vision images on the Fox News Channel make it seem as one. Real people die, even if they're not part of the social circles we travel in. That's worth remembering on Memorial Day, especially if you have no fallen veteran to remember.
Twelve Mexicans illegally entering the United States died over the weekend in the Arizona desert. No Americans died trying to get into Mexico. Over several decades, thousands of Cubans have drowned trying to float to Florida. No Floridians have perished making the reverse commute. During the Cold War, dozens of people were shot attempting to cross the Berlin Wall. They all went West. The individual will risk his life to flee socialism. The socialist will risk the lives of individuals to retain socialism. North, south, east, west, nearly all immigrants travel in the same direction: away from socialism.
Mark Malloch Brown, chief of staff for United Nations Secretary General Kofi Annan, criticized the United States at a commencement address at Pace University School of Law. Brown told graduates: "This ungainly giant of a nation that has led the world in advancing freedom, democracy and decency, cannot quite accept membership in the global neighborhood association, and the principle of all neighborhoods--that it must abide by others' rules as well as its own." Isn't the principle of all neighborhoods "good fences make good neighbors"? Our neighborhood, the United States, is a republic. Why should we accept rules to govern our own country set by those who don't live here?
As George W. Bush acknowledged earlier this week, World War II didn't turn out so well for the people of Eastern Europe. Does that mean it wasn't worth fighting?
This is the provocative question Pat Buchanan raises, at least when it comes to Britain and France, in a new column that echoes themes laid out in his book A Republic, Not an Empire (buy it here). For Americans, the debate over going to war in 1941 is moot. The decision, after all, was made for us. First at Pearl Harbor and a few days later in Berlin, when Hitler declared war on the United States. But a different situation confronted France and Britain, and it is upon these two nations that Buchanan's argument fixates.
Buchanan makes a few strong points. Chief amongst them is that it's hypocrisy to praise Churchill while condemning Chamberlain because they both signed away Eastern Europe--one at Munich the other at Yalta--to tyrants. The only difference is that Churchill signed away a larger chunk of real estate. But this, his strongest argument, is also his undoing. Buchanan, here, seems guilty of the same hypocrisy he ably points out in Churchill sycophants. To write an article questioning the wisdom of Britain and France launching a war on Nazism for absorbing eastern lebensraum, amidst a discussion about how awful it was to let Stalin have Eastern Europe, misses something that's rather glaring.
Elsewhere, there is a petty one-upsmanship regarding the bodycount of various socialist tyrants. "Where Hitler killed his millions," Buchanan writes, "Stalin, Mao, Ho Chi Minh, Pol Pot and Castro murdered their tens of millions." When a dictator gets into the seven digits, is it really all that constructive to turn moral questions into mathematical ones?
The enemy in World War II was straight from central casting. It is for this that it's called "the good war." Our friends, on the other hand, proved far more problemmatic. Because teaming with Stalin necessarily calls into question the traditional black-and-white presentation of the war, discussions of our Red allies provoke a changing of the subject in a hurry. Bush, and Buchanan, are right for calling attention to this. But in the case of the latter, couldn't he have made his point more effectively had he held National Socialists and Soviet Socialists to the same standard?
Amid a few bad weeks in Iraq, there is good news: Americans launched an offensive on insurgents along a smuggling route near the Iraq-Syria border. The good guys took out more than 100 bad guys, who no longer have the ability to implode car bombs outside mosques, assassinate elected leaders, behead civilians, or detonate roadside explosive devices that maim and kill Americans.
Politics makes strange bedfellows. Wars make even stranger ones. Today, George Bush sat in Red Square with Vladimir Putin and various world leaders to celebrate the victory over Nazism. The White House website promotes Bush's trip under a banner stating "Celebrating Freedom and Democracy." In reference to World War II, we can make that boast. Can the nation Bush celebrates in today do the same?
The Soviet Union sacrificed millions of men to defeat the Nazis, but not a single one to liberate Europe. While we went home after the war, the Soviet Union didn't. They used the war to incorporate Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania into the Soviet Union, to install puppet regimes by bayonet point in Poland, Romania, Bulgaria, Albania, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, and points beyond, and to make unsuccessful attempts to take over Finland, Greece, and other sovereign nations. Had Hitler not turned on his erstwhile ally Stalin in Operation Barbarossa--who knows?--a bunch of cartoonish fanatics in military garb might be celebrating victory with the Russians today. The people of Eastern Europe traded one oppressor for another. Did it matter all that much to them that one bore a swastika insignia while the other bore a sickle and hammer? In times of war, it's often necessary to align with unsavory individuals to defeat a common enemy. Recognizing this doesn't compel us to forget just what it meant when the U.S. and Britain liberated a nation from the Nazis, and what it meant when the Soviet Union "liberated" a nation from the Nazis.
A political party is not a church. Subtracting numbers for purity leaves you on the outside looking in. A church is not a political party. Subtracting purity for numbers leaves you on the outside looking in.
An Associated Press article intimates that Father Thomas J. Reese's decision to resign as editor of the liberal Catholic publication America came as the result of Vatican pressure. The piece notes that during Reese's recent trip to Rome a superior had "mentioned there had been complaints about a couple of articles." It doesn't offer any proof that Rome forced Reese to depart, although the entire tone of the article suggests it.
The famous Cardinal Ratzinger t-shirt explains, "Putting the Smackdown on Heresy Since 1981." While the pope's friends and foes benefit from laying Reese's resignation at his feet, there is no evidence suggesting that he compelled the liberal Jesuit scribe to leave the magazine America. Reese himself, in his resignation letter, makes no such charge. The fact that his successor, Father Drew Christiansen, shares Reese's left-wing views makes it unlikely that any such Rome-engineered coup occured.
But what if it did? Does not every church have the right to lay out its beliefs and have those beliefs accepted or rejected? If Thomas Reese wishes to start his own religion with women priests, divorce, homosexual marriage, and a clergy of the laity, he's entitled. He's not entitled to glom on to a two-thousand-year-old religion and hijack it for his own ends.
There's already a number of religions preaching the gospel according to liberals. Rather than join those sects, liberal anti-Catholics focus their energies on shutting down the religion that so offends them. Just as Unitarians have the right to remove believers in God from their pulpits, Catholics have the right to choose their own spokesmen based on their own beliefs.
More Americans believe going to war in Iraq was a mistake than believe it wasn't, according to a new USA Today poll. Public opinion of the war has soured, with just 41 percent of Americans holding that going to war was "worth it" and 57 percent maintaining it was "not worth it." When U.S. troops overthrew the Bathist regime, three in four Americans held that the war was "worth it."
The number of U.S. servicemen killed in Iraq rose sharply in April after two months of declines. Fifty-one Americans died in Iraq during April, with terrorist attacks escalating in the last few days. These are the unfortunate costs of nation-building in a place that is not a nation, but a geographic construct put together by colonial meddlers many decades ago. It's two years and a day since President Bush made his "mission accomplished" speech atop an aircraft carrier. If we accomplished the mission, then what are we still doing in Iraq?
Iraq Survey Group head Charles Duelfer officially wrapped up his investigation into Iraqi weapons of mass destruction by again conceding that no stockpiles have been found after an extensive search, calling speculation that Hussein transferred WMD to his Syrian neighbors "unlikely." "As matters now stand, the WMD investigation has gone as far as feasible," Duelfer explained in a supplement (released Monday night) to his main report (released last Fall). "After more than 18 months, the WMD investigation and debriefing of the WMD-related detainees has been exhausted." Meanwhile, Duelfer's former boss, departed Director of Central Intelligence George Tenet, conceded last night that his characterization of Iraqi WMD as a "slam dunk" were "the two dumbest words I ever said." Yet, right now, in the furthest recess of the Internet, some Republican hack types away about the immanent discovery of Iraqi WMD stockpiles in a manner reminiscent of the jilted Miss Havisham obsessing about her wedding day.
American judges aren't the only ones who've lost their minds. A French court ruled that DVDs and CDs that have copy-protection technology can't be sold in France. In other words, the law ruled in favor of the lawless. Looters won. The decision banning the anti-bootlegging safeguard will likely have ramifications in other European Union member states, enabling crooks to more easily siphon profits from recording artists and filmmakers. Ironically, the case stemmed from a man who sought to dub his copy of Mullholland Drive, perhaps the worst movie ever made and certainly one that nobody in a right mind would attempt to duplicate.
Long before he became pope, Joseph Ratzinger worked as a professor of theology. In the 1960s, Ratzinger, like other academics, experienced the invasion of his lecture hall by screaming radicals. ''That experience made it clear to me that the abuse of the faith had to be resisted,'' Ratzinger would later write of the experience. Reverend Hans Küng, one of Ratzinger's academic peers who experienced a similar classroom invasion, told the Boston Globe: "Our reaction was very different. He walked away. He just was not prepared or not willing to talk to those who spoke from emotion.... This is the negative side of the man, the intolerant side." Isn't this blaming the victim? Radicals shouted Ratzinger down, yet Küng calls Ratzinger rather than the radicals "intolerant."
Thumbnail biographies of Ratzinger point to the campus upheavals of 1968 as a philosophical turning point for the future pope, transforming a reformer into an orthodox defender of the faith. Radicals perhaps experience some therapeutic benefit from such shout-fests, but for the shoutee the trauma can induce an epiphany. And the reorientation of thinking ususally goes in a direction opposite of where the shouters had hoped it to go.
Does the Church exist to worship man or to worship God? If it is the former, then the Church should conform to the whims of those on the near side of the altar. If it is the latter, then the Church should conform to the commands of the Main Attraction on the far side of the altar. God answers this question in the First Commandment, obliging humanity to worship Him. To this, the "progressive" Catholic cries, "Worship me!"
Narcissistic Catholics want a Church that affirms rather than corrects their sins. This is why the elevation of Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger to the papacy has been met with such vitriol by "progressive" Catholics. Pope Benedict XVI sees himself as a steward of an old Church, not the inventor of a new one. To make the alterations demanded of him by reformist Catholics, the pope would reveal himself not only as a usurper, but a usurper of a power belonging to no man.
Times have changed. God hasn't. Has God "evolved" in his views on morality? Are the Ten Commandments passe? Did He recognize the error of his teachings on adultery, homosexuality, and abortion when confronted with the example of modernity? To answer in the affirmative is to deny God as God. If God no longer calls the shots, then man does. An earthly puppeteer pulling God's strings leads to an unjust God, forever negotiating right and wrong to fit the fashions of the times. Instead of bringing humanity nearer to God, the reformist vision seeks for God to slump toward humanity.
"Upon this rock," Jesus said of St. Peter, "I shall build my Church." Many liberal Catholics hoped that Peter's 264th successor would resemble less a rock than an amoeba: soft, spineless, and malleable. And that is a sound foundation to build no church, which is perhaps their point.
Joseph Ratzinger is a better source on what Pope Benedict XVI believes than the media. His writings aren't hidden. The 265th pope received his doctorate in theology, taught university, and authored more than a dozen books. Though evidently not as popular as Harry Potter, Ratzinger currently occupies eight slots on Amazon.com's twenty-five top-selling books. Stay ahead of the pack and pick up one of the new pope's books listed below.
The man who called on the College of Cardinals to rebel against the "dictatorship of relativism," examines Western thought and global faiths in Truth and Tolerance: Christian Belief and World Religion. Milestones is the memoirs of his first fifty years. The four-decade old Introduction to Christianity charts highest among his books on Amazon. Called to Communion: Understanding the Church Today is a short collection of essays. Salt of the Earth is more than 200-pages of transcribed and translated interviews, and appears to be most relevant to current debates surrounding the Church. If you've read Joseph Ratzinger's work, in book form or otherwise, share your take with the readership.
Pope Benedict XVI's honeymoon is over before it began. Preying upon the one ethnic stereotype safe from political correctness, critics labeled the former Cardinal Ratzinger the Panzer Pope and God's Rottweiler. The new pope wasn't just a conservative, but an "arch-conservative" (Reuters), a "staunch conservative" (Agence France-Presse), and the "Church's leading hard-liner" (Associated Press). Worst of all, Joseph Ratzinger is a Catholic who believes in the teachings of the Roman Catholic Church. For this, Andrew Sullivan labels his election "insular and regressive." Perhaps when a pope approves of HIV+ men seeking anonymous bareback sex, Andrew Sullivan will approve of the pope. Other leftists--churchgoers all, I'm sure--were more coarse in their condemnations.
Pope Benedict XVI is Catholic, conservative, and German. For a leftist, what's not to hate?
In solidarity with the toddler Prince Moulay Hassan, thousands of Morrocans underwent circumcisions Thursday. Indian police arrested eighty Hindus involved in a bizarre child-burial ritual in which parents drug and bury their first-born children for a minute or so before unearthing them. Attorneys for a German man who was convicted of manslaughter for killing and eating a man he met on the Internet are appealing his eight-and-a-half year sentence. How do you translate "quit while you're ahead" into German? As the state of Wisconsin debates cat hunting, an Australian lawmaker urges his fellow citizens to bludgeon poisonous toads as he did when he was a child: "We hit them with cricket bats and golf clubs and the like back then." Antarctica, which has survived without an official currency, flag, or even time zones, has its own marathon. As President Luis Inacio Lula da Silva apologized in Senegal for Brazil's role in the African slave trade, the nation he leads continues to play host to vestiges of slavery.
Prince Charles marries Camilla Parker Bowles today. Jealous?
Charles's former wife Diana died eight years ago, and some people are appalled that he's decided to remarry (and a divorcee at that!). I'm not scandalized by any of this. I recognize the royals are human beings, which is why my view of them is not automatically high in the first place. The sex lives of Richard III, Henry VIII, George I, and if you can believe the rumors, James I, reveal Prince Charles's failings to be rather, well, common. I object to his adultery, as I object to Diana's. Even more so, I object to their marriage--they didn't love each other. It was arranged. Diana was the woman Charles was supposed to marry, not the woman he loved. Today, he marries the woman he loves--and it doesn't matter if you don't love her because you're not marrying her. Charles is.
Prince Charles is subject to the same sins and failings that all of us are subject to--and I'm not sure that marrying his longtime sweetheart eight years after his first wife's death is sin or failing. In the eyes of many base people, Charles's current failing is marrying someone who doesn't meet the superficial standard set by Lady Di (whose substantive contributions are similarly overlooked by these "fans"). If Camilla looked like Grace Kelly or Jackie Kennedy--the way princesses are supposed to look--instead of a gracefully aging 58-year-old woman, would there be such a fuss?
On April 18, the College of Cardinals meets to elect a new pope. They've been voting on the Church's leader since 1059. Like other institutions that have come to employ the vote in the intervening years, they didn't always make the wisest of choices. In fact, they didn't always select an ordained priest as pope. On March 11, 1513, the College of Cardinals selected Giovanni de' Medici. "He was not yet a priest," historian Will Durant informs, "but this defect was remedied on March 15." Known as Martin Luther's excommunicator, Henry VIII's bestower of the title Defender of the Faith, and Raphael's patron, Leo X presided over a turbulent and eventful time in Church history. Upon his death, a popular verdict held: "Leo has eaten up three pontificates: the treasury of Julius II, the revenues of Leo, and those of his successor."
While Catholics view the faith of the Church as infallible, the same judgment can't be extended to the democratic decisions of the College of Cardinals, which has selected as pope a Borgia with numerous illegitimate children, among others unworthy of the responsibility as Christ's vicar on Earth. With all this in mind, especially the historical precedent of selecting a non-priest as pope, what living person would be the absolute worst person the College of Cardinals could select as the next pope when they convene on April 18?
On Dennis Miller's CNBC's program Thursday night, Christopher Hitchens blamed Pope John Paul II for AIDS and accused the late pontiff of being an apologist for Saddam Hussein--at least that's the impression I got. The revisionists have arrived early for work. While the positive coverage outweighs the negative coverage in the week leading to today's papal funeral, don't bet on this trend to continue. Until 1963, Pope Pius XII was thought of as a saintly figure inside and outside the flock. That year, playwright Rolf Hochhuth transformed the pope into an accomplice of the Third Reich in The Deputy. As the following 42 years attest, death was a bad public relations move for Pius XII. My suspicion is that it will be for Pope John Paul II as well. While John Paul II sought to canonize Pius XII, others have anathematized him as Hitler's Pope. The calumny doesn't stand.
Pope John Paul II not only held an advanced degree in theology, but obtained a doctorate in philosophy. This shows in reading his encyclicals, especially Evangelium Vitae published ten years ago.
"[W]e are facing an enormous and dramatic clash between good and evil, death and life, the 'culture of death' and the 'culture of life,'" proclaimed the Pope. "We find ourselves not only 'faced with' but necessarily 'in the midst of' this conflict: we are all involved and we all share in it, with the inescapable responsibility of choosing to be unconditionally pro-life." Does pro-life refer just to the unborn? No. In addition to abortion, one finds Evangelium Vitae (the Gospel of Life) condemning ghoulish medical experimentation, unnecessary war, infanticide, the death penalty, and euthanasia.
Abortion: "Choices once unanimously considered criminal and rejected by the common moral sense are gradually becoming socially acceptable. Even certain sectors of the medical profession, which by its calling is directed to the defence and care of human life, are increasingly willing to carry out these acts against the person. In this way the very nature of the medical profession is distorted and contradicted, and the dignity of those who practise it is degraded."
"No one more absolutely innocent could be imagined. In no way could this human being ever be considered an aggressor, much less an unjust aggressor! He or she is weak, defenceless, even to the point of lacking that minimal form of defence consisting in the poignant power of a newborn baby's cries and tears."
Capital Punishment: "Modern society in fact has the means of effectively suppressing crime by rendering criminals harmless without definitively denying them the chance to reform."
Medical Experimentation on Human Life: "[T]he use of human embryos or fetuses as an object of experimentation constitutes a crime against their dignity as human beings who have a right to the same respect owed to a child once born, just as to every person.... The killing of innocent human creatures, even if carried out to help others, constitutes an absolutely unacceptable act."
Euthanasia: "Here we are faced with one of the more alarming symptoms of the 'culture of death,' which is advancing above all in prosperous societies, marked by an attitude of excessive preoccupation with efficiency and which sees the growing number of elderly and disabled people as intolerable and too burdensome. These people are very often isolated by their families and by society, which are organized almost exclusively on the basis of criteria of productive efficiency, according to which a hopelessly impaired life no longer has any value.... True 'compassion' leads to sharing another's pain; it does not kill the person whose suffering we cannot bear.... The choice of euthanasia becomes more serious when it takes the form of a murder committed by others on a person who has in no way requested it and who has never consented to it. The height of arbitrariness and injustice is reached when certain people, such as physicians or legislators, arrogate to themselves the power to decide who ought to live and who ought to die."
Pope John Paul II wrote, "when the sense of God is lost, there is also a tendency to lose the sense of man, of his dignity and his life."
God needed only four words to say that murder is wrong. It is the shame of our age that the Pope needed nearly 50,000 to explain why.
One of the last towering figures of the twentieth century has died. Pope John Paul II will be remembered for forcefully standing up to both Communism and to politicized efforts to force the Church to abandon its teaching on hot-button issues. Succeeding one of the shortest serving popes, John Paul II served longer than all but two of his predecessors. We are used to seeing this pope as an old man, but when the college of cardinals elected Karol Józef Wojtyla the Holy Father in 1978 he was then the youngest pope since 1846. He was the first non-Italian pope since the 16th century. The Communists tried to kill him in 1981. He survived, but Communism didn't--at least on the continent he called home. The next pope has some large shoes to fill, but then again so do all popes.
"The pope?" Josef Stalin dismissively asked. "How many divisions has he got?" One of Stalin's successors apparently was more impressed with the power of the Church. Documents out of the late East Germany implicate the late Soviet Union in the 1981 assassination attempt on Pope John Paul II.
Shouting "science," as opposed to demonstrating the science, is a tactic used by the ignorant or the deceptive to shut up opponents. The problem with scientific opinion is that it's opinion, which isn't very scientific. Scientists often have conflicting opinions (on global warming, how the universe started, evolution, etc.), and not all of the opinions--even the ones labeled "science"--can be right. What's said in science's name isn't always truth. A U.S. scientist declared a "100 percent chance" of a tsunami following the earthquake that occurred earlier this week on the other side of the world. Well, a few days have passed, and, no tsunami. I'm sure being wrong never felt so right for the geologist. I'm mainly glad he was wrong for the same reason--that the absence of a tsunami spared perhaps thousands of people death. His incorrect yet certain assessment pleases me for a lesser reason: it demonstrates that science, too, is fallible.
Two weeks ago, several hundred Basra University students held a picnic. Then their party got crashed. A gang of militiamen loyal to Shiite leader Moqtada al-Sadr stormed the picnic, beating participants, firing guns, and briefly kidnapping more than a dozen party-goers. "They focused on the women," one witness remembered. "They were beating them viciously." While breaking up the dancing, ice cream, and singing, the fun police allegedly yelled, "There is no secular government! There is only the government of the Mahdi Army!" As if to prove their point, police from the real government looked away.
"They say freedom means they can do what they want. This is not freedom. Freedom does not mean you can transgress traditions," explained Heidar Jabari of Sadr's Shiite group. "There are traditions and rules in an Eastern society that are different from a Western society. Every Iraqi has a right to act against these transgressions."
As new problems arise, old problems dissipate. The resistance seems to have lost its momentum. Abu Musab al-Zarqawi is on the run, insurgents kill fewer and fewer Americans, and there's even talk of an "exit strategy" for beleaguered resistance fighters. This is the good news out of Iraq. But even if we pacify Iraq, will it all be worth it if a more Islamized nation emerges?
Changing a form of government doesn't change the culture. Middle Eastern theocracies, kingdoms, and dictatorships have all produced terrorists, religious fanatics, and America-haters. Democracy--if one indeed develops--doesn't magically remove terrorism. Terrorists have sprung from under all sorts of governing systems, including democracy. Rather than the form of government one lives under, the religion one follows serves as the denominator common to most present-day terrorists. To loosely paraphrase an Arkansan, "It's the religion, stupid."
Two years ago tonight, I delivered a speech to 400 students at St. John's University in Collegeville, Minnesota. Following my remarks, I learned that the campaign in Iraq had begun. I watched President Bush's speech from a Days Inn in rural Minnesota, and hoped with everyone else that the targeted bombs had hit an alleged meeting between Hussein and his top henchmen. They didn't, and nine months passed before Americans caught up to the Iraqi dictator.
"Our nation enters this conflict reluctantly--yet, our purpose is sure," President George W. Bush announced that night. "The people of the United States and our friends and allies will not live at the mercy of an outlaw regime that threatens the peace with weapons of mass murder. We will meet that threat now, with our Army, Air Force, Navy, Coast Guard and Marines, so that we do not have to meet it later with armies of fire fighters and police and doctors on the streets of our cities." The war's "purpose," removing the "weapons of mass murder" that threatened our nation, turned out to be based on a false premise.
The administration played the "Music Man" in selling the war. Officials advertised stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction, Hussein's pursuit uranium from Niger in the work-up to conflict, and Iraqi "connections" to 9/11. When the Music Man sales pitch fell apart, the White House went into Obi-Wan Kenobi mode. "These are not the droids you are looking for," administration figures intoned. The war wasn't about WMD. It was really about spreading democracy, Hussein's abuse of the UN's Oil for Food program, and cleverly drawing terrorists into an Iraq-sized mousetrap.
If winning a war were a justification for war, then we should invade every country on the face of the earth. What country, after all, could defeat us? But neither winning a war, nor making life better for foreigners satisfies the traditional litmus test: does the action promote the just interests of the United States? Iraq fails this test. There are many reasons why the war wasn't in the just interests of the United States. Here are a few:
1. The United States is not a means to some other country's end.
2. The Iraq war diverted men and resources from fighting al Qaeda to fighting a dictator who brutalized his own people but lacked the capability to do much else. Killing and capturing the perpetrators of 9/11 should play second fiddle to no venture.
3. President Bush's axis of evil has become more of an axis, if less evil, in bringing former enemies--Iraq and Iran--closer as a result of the war.
4. The central rationale for invading Iraq was a falsehood. The Bush administration, although not its fanatical backers, has admitted that U.S. intelligence was wrong about Iraqi weapons of mass destruction. The war has produced benefits--Saddam Hussein in jail, Iraqi elections--but the war was neither sold as an act of law enforcement, nor as a nation-building exercise. It was sold as a war to remove the threat of weapons of mass destruction posed to American cities. No weapons, no threat.
5. America has lost more than 1,500 of its best and brightest. Thousands more have been maimed.
6. America will have expended hundreds of billions of dollars on a country that Paul Wolfowitz explained would "finance its own reconstruction" and Ari Fleischer assured us would "shoulder much of the burden" for reconstruction. Aren't conservatives supposed to be against big-government--at home and abroad?
7. Despite dismissing Iraq war opponents as "isolationists," the war's proponents within the administration have isolated the United States from the world. Never in our history have we been more hated or had fewer friends than now. Who are the real isolationists?
8. By preempting a non-existent threat, the U.S. damaged its credibility. When a real threat emerges, the Iraq intelligence debacle may propel American lawmakers and foreign friends to see the situation through a boy-who-cried-wolf lens, thus impeding necessary action.
9. Estimates of Iraqi dead vary. Whether it's 16,000 or 100,000, the human toll of war (just like the human toll of not going to war) should be considered when evaluating the justice of a campaign.
10. Iraq creates a dangerous precedent. Up until this point, America's major foreign wars--the American Revolution, the War of 1812, the Mexican American War, the Spanish American War, World War I, World War II, the Korean War, Vietnam, and the Gulf War--all featured the U.S. spurred to war because of some act (real or perceived) of aggression by the enemy nation. Have we crossed the Rubicon?
A group of survivors and relatives of victims of the Indian Ocean tsunami are suing (who else?) the United States government. The group, which includes dozens of Europeans, alleges that the Pacific Tsunami Warning Center failed to provide adequate notice for the natural disaster. But as its name implies, the Pacific Tsunami Warning Center is in the Pacific, not the Indian, Ocean. If you're unfamiliar with geography, the United States of America is about as far from the Indian Ocean as anyplace in the world. Although U.S. taxpayers bankroll the Pacific Tsunami Warning Center, more than a dozen foreign countries benefit from the service it provides. Since the Indian Ocean is thousands of miles from our shores, the United States funds no similar center for that part of the world. If Thailand, India, and other nations surrounding the Indian Ocean aren't to blame for their failure to build a regional tsunami warning center, what makes the United States--a nation halfway round the world--complicit?
While we're on the subject of stupid lawsuits, the family of Rachel Corrie, who made the really bad decision of attempting block a bulldozer, is suing the manufacturer of the machine that ran her over. Corrie died while protesting the Israeli government's destruction of a Palestinian settlement. A dumbfounded spokeswoman for Caterpillar explained: "more than 2 million Caterpillar machines and engines are at work in virtually every region of the world each day. We have neither the legal right nor the means to police individual use of that equipment." One can debate the negligence of Corrie, the bulldozer operator, or both. But Caterpillar?
Today marks the seventy-fifth anniversary of Earthlings knowing of the existence of Pluto. No word yet on how long the Plutonese have known of us.
Relations between the Plutonese and the Earthlings have never been worse. Many Earthlings have begun to question whether we should even recognize Pluto as a fellow planet. It's an escaped moon of Neptune or an oversized asteroid, Earth men argue. In short, Pluto's too small to be a planet. But couldn't the Jupiterians say the same thing about us? A few years back, rumors circulated around the International Astronomical Union regarding internal debates to reclassify Pluto as a "minor planet" or a Kuiper Belt object. The group never reclassified the distant world, but, as the Plutonese rightly point out, what's an international body doing making decisions traditionally left to galaxian authorities? When we cast off our Earthocentric perspective, we realize that we're not so different from the Plutonese.
Take our moons, for instance. Unlike the seven other planets in the solar system, Earth and Pluto have but one moon. No other planets compare so closely in size to their moons as both the Earth and Pluto do. Peculiarly, Pluto and its moon Charon have synchronous orbits. Just as we see only one side of our moon (which is actually larger than Pluto) from Earth, the Plutonese see only one side of Charon. Lifeforms on Charon, assuming they exist (and have eyeballs), see but one side of Pluto too.
Being that the sun is like the hub of the solar system, Pluto's distance invites hick stereotypes. Not only does that bristle the locals, but Pluto's puny size--the Earth's circumference is almost six times greater--and its weakness in retaining its atmosphere give the Plutonese a major insecurity complex. Think Robert Plant with gym socks stuffed in his pants or Rudy Giuliani in the combover days, and you have the psychological makeup of your average Plutonese--only wearing the hayseed uniform of one-strap overalls. And like other rural folk (in Appalachia, the Nevada high-desert, or beyond), Pluto's major problem is meth--methane ice that is. Their planet is covered with it.
Seeking to shake its stereotype as an outpost of rubes and yahoos, the Plutonese every 200 years or so--kind of like the modernization attempts of Ataturk or Peter the Great--make a jailbreak towards the Sun in an attempt to be seen as more urbane. This lasts about twenty years, and then they resign themselves to their station as the ninth and last of the Sun's planets--until they try this all over again a couple of Earth-centuries later. The Neptunese, furious about this Plutonese encroachment upon their traditional orbital position about the Sun, recaptured their modest spot among the planets in 1999 after twenty years as the furthest planet from the Sun.
Perhaps some of the Earthling-Plutonese conflict is due to the lack of intercultural exchange. No spacecraft from either planet has ever visited the other. Unmanned craft from Earth have traveled to seven distant planets, but have gracelessly snubbed Pluto. But soon--after the Pluto-bound spacecraft New Horizons launches next year--all of this will change. And with a little luck, the frayed relationship will change too. The alternative--an intergalactic war that would surely ensnare the Time Lords, Vultan's Hawk Men, and the Cylons--is too horrific to contemplate.
Neoconservative stands as one of the most widely used but least defined words of the Bush presidency. As of late, neoconservatives have been primarily associated with a more adventurous use of American military might to promote democracy, particularly in the Middle East. But several of the most prominent neoconservatives have questioned the wisdom of Bush's Iraq campaign specifically, and the administration's Middle Eastern policies generally.
In his Claremont Review of Books essay "Leo Strauss and American Foreign Policy," Thomas West writes: "the attempt to build democracy in a place where the minimal preconditions of democracy are not present may well cause more harm than good. How many civilians will the American forces have to kill before it becomes clear that that well-intentioned goal is indefinitely out of reach?" If West is cautious about the Iraq venture, Francis Fukuyama is downright hostile. The campaign so infuriated the End of History and the Last Man author that he announced last year that he wouldn't be voting for Bush. "The Bush administration went into Iraq with enormous illusions about how easy the post-war situation would be: it thought the reconstruction would be self-financing, that Americans could draw on a lasting well of gratitude for liberating Iraq, and that we could occupy the country with a small force structure and even draw US forces down significantly within a few months," Fukuyama wrote last summer.
Daniel Pipes is the latest neoconservative to outline his reservations. While welcoming recent developments in the region, Pipes admits that he does so warily. He gives six reasons for caution:
1. "Yes, Mahmoud Abbas wishes to end the armed struggle against Israel but his call for a greater jihad against the 'Zionist enemy' points to his intending another form of war to destroy Israel." 2. "The Iraqi elections are bringing Ibrahim Jaafari, a pro-Iranian Islamist, to power." 3. "Likewise, the Saudi elections proved a boon for the Islamist candidates." 4. "Mubarak's promise is purely cosmetic; but should real presidential elections one day come to Egypt, Islamists will probably prevail there too." 5. "Removing Syrian control in Lebanon could well lead to Hezbollah, a terrorist group, becoming the dominant power there." 6. "Eliminating the hideous Assad dynasty could well bring in its wake an Islamist government in Damascus."
"Note a pattern?" asks Pipes. "Other than the sui generis Palestinian case, one main danger threatens to undo the good news: that a too-quick removal of tyranny unleashes Islamist ideologues and opens their way to power."
"All Syrian military forces and intelligence personnel must withdraw before the Lebanese elections, for those elections to be free and fair," George W. Bush said to an applauding audience at Fort McNair on Tuesday. He continued: "The Lebanese people have the right to determine their future, free from domination by a foreign power." Is it just Syrian occupation that taints an election, or any foreign occupation? No doubt Europeans, Arabs, and other non-Americans hearing Bush's words asked themselves that question.
It's difficult to envision last month's Iraqi election happening without U.S. occupation. It's equally difficult to envision a credible election in Lebanon with Syrian occupation. One can debate the effects, but the intents of Syrian and American occupation differ: the former seeks to dominate, the latter seeks to liberate. That said: given that we currently occupy two Muslim countries and have military outposts in several more, will President Bush's words have the effect of shaming Syria into vacating their neighbor or of solidifying Arab perceptions of U.S. hypocrisy?
Buried beneath coverage of pro- and anti-Syria demonstrations in Lebanon, the Pillow Fight Club rally in Tel Aviv, and the bare-breasted protest of Prince Charles in New Zealand is yesterday's march in Pakistan decrying the acquittal of five accused gang-rapists. Mukhtar Mai, the woman leading the protest, was raped by a group of men in 2002 on orders from village elders. The directed sexual attack came in response to allegations that Mai's twelve-year-old brother had sex with a woman of higher social status.
The case of Mukhtar Mai is extreme, even for Pakistan, but it represents a pattern. "Human rights groups estimate that anywhere from 70 to 90 percent of women are victims of domestic violence," the 2000 State Department report on human rights notes about Pakistan. Marital rape is legal, the literacy rate for women stands about half of the rate for men, several hundred "honor killings" occur annually, and rape victims occassionally find themselves jailed for "adultery." The judiciary system halves the value of female testimony in certain cases. Dowry killings and, among one Muslim sect of 100,000, female genital mutilation persist.
How do feminists, immersed in doctrines of cultural relativism, reconcile the mantra "all cultures are equal" with reality in South Asia? How does the Bush administration, which asked for and received $600 million in foreign aid for Pakistan, mesh its Carteresque rhetoric on human rights with its ally's abominable cultural and legal practices?
Tens of thousands of Lebanese rallied today in Beirut in a pro-Syria demonstration. This follows on the heels of several anti-Syria rallies in the wake of the murder of former president Rafik Hariri. One would be foolish to interpret the former to mean a Lebanese desire for foreign occupation, just as one would be foolish to interpret the latter to mean that Lebanon will soon be a free and democratic country. It's too soon to tell what the future holds for Lebanon, once a mecca for cosmopolitans but as of late a mecca for occupying armies, terrorists, and sectarian violence. A few demonstrations does not a democracy make.
More than 1,500 brave Americans have lost their lives in Iraq. Roughly ninety percent of these deaths have occurred since George W. Bush gave his infamous "Mission Accomplished" speech. Declaring that major combat operations have ceased doesn't make it so, particularly when the enemy doesn't cooperate.
This grim milestone, reached Thursday, comes on the heels of some good news. The enemy killed just fifty-eight Americans in February, the lowest death toll in six months. While the American casualty count decreased, terrorists inside Iraq may have actually increased the number of Iraqis they killed, as the horrific car-bombing in Hillah anecdotally suggests. By shifting emphasis from killing U.S. servicemen to killing the locals, the terrorists have abandoned any pretense of "liberating" Iraq from the Americans. The insurgents and terrorists want power, and whether it's Americans ruling Iraq or Iraqis ruling Iraq the governing power should expect more blood.
"Even as the aged pope's body shuts down in the late stages of Parkinson's disease, his will to live—and to impose his will on the Roman Catholic faithful—remains as stubborn as ever," Newsweek's Christopher Dickey writes. In case you didn't get the message, Dickey adds a few lines later that the pope "continues to assert his will in the daily life of the church" and concludes that John Paul II has "spent a generation imposing his will on the church." Dickey's prose is about as subtle as Dolly Parton's chest.
So what is Pope John Paul II trying to "impose" on Roman Catholics? Roman Catholicism. The author reminds readers that the pope, gasp, opposes abortion and homosexual marriage--and does so in a "confrontational" manner. Is the pope trying to force these views--labeled not his faith's will, but "his will"--on Catholics, or is he just stating the Church's position on human life and sexual morality since the time of St. Peter? Isn't it more accurate to claim that liberal Catholics, political pressure-groups, and agenda-driven journalists like Dickey are trying to impose their views on the Church? After all, this pope is not saying anything different on the sanctity of human life or on homosexuality than any of his predecessors. It's as if Newsweek would have us believe that once upon a time a more enlightened pope led gay-pride marches through Rome or opened up Planned Parenthood clinics in Vatican City.
Karol Wojtyla survived under the rule of Nazism and Communism. He survived an assassination attempt. In recent years, he has survived Parkinson's and other maladies. His reputation will survive the spitballs and jeers of whining scribblers.
Two years after invading Iraq to remove "an outlaw regime that threatens the peace with weapons of mass murder," one outlaw regime has acknowledged possessing nuclear weapons while a second feverishly attempts to produce such terrifying mechanisms. Could the unintended consequence of the Iraq war have been to further encourage rogue states to go nuclear?
Just a short time ago, hawks, grasping for ex post facto justifications for an invasion that they promoted on spurious grounds, seized on Libya's abandonment of its WMD program as affirmation for their war whooping. "Libya's announcement that it will close down its weapons-of-mass-destruction programs is an important vindication of American and British foreign policy," Andrew Apostolou wrote at National Review Online. "The announcement of Libyan disarmament could not have happened without the liberation of Iraq." "The danger posed by the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction is obvious to everyone," declared Powerline on the Libyan disarmament, "and if the administration's tough line can yield results like these, its wisdom should be beyond question."
Such are the dangers of viewing any positive geopolitical development through the prism of Iraq. Libya seems to have been intent on rejoining the community of civilized nations prior to the Iraq war, but who knows, perhaps that conflict was the straw that broke the camel's back. Libya's dismantling of its WMD program, although welcome, neither provides "vindication" to the Iraq campaign nor makes the intelligence of its course "beyond question." More than a year ago, hawks claimed that disarming Iraq would have beneficial effects on other gangster states. It hasn't. Instead, the remaining members of the axis of evil have grown more dangerous. Like Libya, Iran and North Korea charted their course on weapons of mass destruction prior to the Iraq war--with Kim Jong-Il likely having an atomic weapon before gameday in Iraq. But it's worth pondering whether the war accelerated attempts by the two nations to further realize their nuclear ambitions--just as it's worth pondering whether the war had a beneficial effect on Libya.
Obviously, the rulers of North Korea and Iran don't want their nations to be the next Iraq. Welcoming inspections and abandoning the pursuit of WMD is one way--the Libyan way--to avoid invasion. Another way--the Iranian and North Korean way--involves gaining nukes as quickly as possible. More reliable than the mantra that democracies don't wage full-scale wars upon other democracies is the time-tested reality that nuclear powers don't wage full-scale wars upon other nuclear powers. Rather than inspiring the abandonment of dreams of nuclear arsenals, couldn't it just as easily be said that the lesson Iraq imparted to Iran and North Korea is that nukes are the only surefire way to avoid the military wrath of the U.S.?
I have a rule about never trusting chubby, syphilis-ridden midgets wearing Carol Channing's glasses and a hybrid Don King/The King haircut. North Korea has the bomb, and that's not da bomb. Kim Jong Il's government admitted Thursday that North Korea has nuclear weapons. The ingrates failed to thank Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton in their declaration.
President Bush likes to give away money--other people's money, not his own. This gives him the political benefit of generosity (the perception of good-heartedness), but not the personal cost (a smaller bank account). It's very easy for politicians to be generous with other people's money. What takes courage is frugality, stinginess, and a stewardship that recognizes that it's not yours to give. Rules, not emotions, govern the disbursement of public funds.
Last September, I recommended Congressman Davey Crockett's "Not Yours to Give" to the president. Evidently, he didn't take me up on my suggestion. In September, the president's successful push to distribute $12 billion in hurricane relief inspired my reading recommendation. Today, the reason for again suggesting this bedtime reading for W is the president's announcement that he will seek an additional $600 million from Congress in tsunami relief.
"I will not go into an argument to prove that Congress has no power to appropriate this money as an act of charity," Crockett reportedly said on the floor of Congress. "Every member upon this floor knows it. We have the right, as individuals, to give away as much of our own money as we please in charity; but as members of Congress we have no right so to appropriate a dollar of the public money."
The American people recognize that the tsunami victims deserve our help. That's why they've voluntarily given more in private donations than they've involuntarily given in public aid.
CNN reports that a senior military official estimates that the Iraqi insurgency consists of 13,000 to 17,000 fighters and terrorists, with Baathists constituting the majority of troublemakers. The anonymous official put forward the estimate of just 500 foreigners fighting the U.S. and the Iraqi government, with another 1,000 terrorists working within al-Zarqawi's network. The bad news: the CNN report, if true, shows a larger network of insurgents than previously thought. The good news: the CNN piece contends that the U.S. military believes it has killed between 10,000-15,000 guerillas aiming to kill our soldiers, sailors, airmen, and Marines, as well as Iraqi civilians, police, and servicemen. CNN details neither the source of the estimates, nor the rank of the official advancing these numbers.
Cuba has banned smoking in public places. The state of affairs in the tropical Alcatraz is so sorry that this former trendsetter in oppression now takes its cues from Friendship Heights, Maryland and Cambridge, Massachusetts.
If the early returns hold up, the United Iraqi Alliance (UIA) will cruise to victory in Iraq's elections. What is the United Iraqi Alliance? It is a coalition of 22 parties, nearly all of which explicitly refer to Islam in their names. But the victors are going to form a secular government, really they are. I know it's true because they said so in the New York Times.
C'mon, folks. Do such UIA parties as Islamic Master of the Martyrs Movement, Supreme Council for the Islamic Revolution in Iraq, Hezbollah al-Iraq, or Islamic Virtue Party sound secular to you? Like many things comforting--daydreaming of lottery riches or imagining Marcia Brady's crush on you--the notion of a secular (in the way Westerners understand the term) postwar Iraq doesn't conform to present reality.
To be fair, many political parties in Western democracies refer to Christianity in their names (e.g., the Christian Democrats). But they don't insist on trading the secular code for Biblical law. Call me a cynic, but something tells me that UIA parties like, say, the Hezbollah Movement of Iraq, aren't into the whole tolerance and pluralism thing.
After a weekend of drunken jubilation, President Bush has awoken to an awful hangover and some Iranian named Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani lying in his bed.
Early returns from Iraq's elections suggest that Iraqis overwhelmingly voted for a slate of candidates supported by Shiite clerics and overwhelmingly shunned a slate of candidates led by the U.S.-backed moderate, Ayad Allawi. Sunday's historic elections offer several reasons for enthusiasm, but what matters more than people voting is for whom they vote. A vast majority of those ink-stained fingers marked their ballots the way the ayatollahs told them to.
Theorists imagine the success of a democratic Iraq becoming contagious in theocratic Iran. Reality offers a dramatically different possibility. Rather than democracy overwhelming theocracy, a more likely scenario involves the relatively secular Iraq becoming infected by the oppressively Islamic Iran. Should this happen, no doubt we'll never stop hearing about the noble intentions behind the big-government scheme to alchemize subjugated Muslim Iraqis into New England-style town-meeting members. This is the refrain of all world-savers and do-gooders: I meant well.
Our primary enemy is Islamic extremists, not tyrants. Did we just wage a costly war to replace the latter with the former?
A federal judge has ruled that enemy combatants captured in the war on terrorism can challenge their status in U.S. courts. Judge Joyce Hens Green ruled that imprisoning foreign fighters without hearing "negate[s] the existence of the most basic and fundamental [rights] for which the people of this country have fought and died for well over 200 years." But can you cite anything like this happening in World War II? Or, for that matter, do you recall any nation in the history of warfare that opened up its court system to prisoners of war? Judge Green is simply inventing history. Despite the insistence of liberals that we arrest bin Laden and open our courts to the complaints of foreign combatants, the "war on terrorism" is not a police action. It is, as the first word in the descriptive phrase indicates, a war.
More than a year after the arrest of Saddam Hussein, his former subjects voted in a national election this weekend. This dramatic turnabout is historic. Whether the election is an historic event or an historic novelty remains to be seen.
The day was almost wholly positive for a number of reasons. First, actual levels of violence failed to meet expected levels of violence. Second, the elections showed the world a face of Iraq they're not used to seeing. With terrorist attacks dominating the headlines, the media occassionally created an impression that confused Iraqi weariness of the occupation with Iraqi support for the terrorists. The dyed finger now stands with the toppled statue of Saddam Hussein as one of the striking visuals demonstrating the benefits of this campaign. Third, the elections facilitate the future withdrawal of U.S. troops from Iraq. Fourth, despite boycotts and death threats, the percentage of Iraqis casting votes compares to the percentage casting votes in the U.S. and other Western democracies.
But declaring democracy in Iraq now makes as much sense as declaring "mission accomplished" in May of 2003. Less consequential than the fact that Iraqis chose a government is the matter of who they chose to govern them. One election does not a democracy make. Sunday's events were encouraging, but check back one, five, or ten years from Sunday to have a better understanding of the significance of January 30, 2005.
Arthur Herman see parallels between the beheading of Charles I and this weekend's elections in Iraq. I do too, just very different ones. Herman writes: "When Charles I went to the execution block on January 30, a brave new world was born, that of sovereignty of the people." Well, a brave new world was born, but it had less to do with popular sovereignty than it did with Oliver Cromwell, a name that inexplicably appears nowhere in Herman's article about the results of the 1649 regicide. Charles I's beheading, 356 years to the day of the Iraqi elections, fortified dictatorial rule by a gang of religious fanatics. Isn't that the historical lesson that we should be concerned about when it comes to Iraq?
"Nobody expects the Spanish Inquisition!"
Reports that female interrogators at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba attempted to break-down suspected terrorists by wearing thongs and mini-skirts reminds me of Monty Python's Michael Palin torturing suspected heretics with pillows and comfy chairs. Regarding one such incident, the Associated Press reports that a female interrogator "began taunting the detainee, touching her breasts, rubbing them against the prisoner's back and commenting on his apparent erection." In another incident, a woman "took off her uniform top, exposed her brown T-shirt, ran her fingers through a detainee's hair and sat on his lap." Yet another "female interrogator grabbed a detainee's genitals."
I'm outraged, but not in the way the author of this piece wants me to be. Does our government really think that threats of close-up encounters with scantily-clad women will depress al Qaeda's recruitment of hard-up Middle Eastern males? Here's hoping the terrorists replace their methods of prisoner treatment with these American practices.
"There's a lot of money to pay for this," Paul Wolfowitz explained in March 2003. "It doesn't have to be U.S. taxpayer money. We are dealing with a country that can really finance its own reconstruction, and relatively soon." Like a lot of things that Paul Wolfowitz said before the war in Iraq, this idea turned out to be not only wrong, but wildly so.
The Bush administration this week announced that it will ask Congress for another $80 billion for operations in Iraq and Afghanistan. This will put the total spent on the Iraq war above $200 billion, a pricetag administration figures openly mocked when it was suggested prior to the war. In fact, when Bush economic advisor Larry Lindsey publicly warned in September 2002 that the war could cost as much as $200 million, his fellow Bushies came down on him, with Office of Management and Budget Director Mitch Daniels labeling his estimate "very, very high." Lindsey, who subsequently was forced out of the administration, was actually very, very low in his estimate of the cost of the Iraq campaign.
Today marks the deadliest day of the Iraq war for U.S. servicemen. Thirty-six of America's best and bravest lost their lives on Wednesday, including thirty-one Marines who perished when a CH-53 helicopter went down. More than 1,400 American soldiers, sailors, airmen, and Marines have died since the war started nearly two years ago. Keep them in your prayers.
This weekend, the Washington Post asked President George W. Bush: "Why hasn't anyone been held accountable, either through firings or demotions, for what some people see as mistakes or misjudgments [on Iraq]?" "Well, we had an accountability moment," Bush responded, "and that's called the 2004 election. And the American people listened to different assessments made about what was taking place in Iraq, and they looked at the two candidates, and chose me, for which I'm grateful."
1. How could the election be a referendum on Iraq when both major candidates supported not just the war in Iraq, but the incorrect presumptions that led to the war? 2. Exit polls showed Iraq to be a loser for Bush. Voters who chose Iraq as their most important issue swung for Kerry over Bush 73 percent to 26 percent. 3. The electorate can't hold the secretary of defense or the director of central intelligence accountable. George Bush can, but has refused to do so. The electorate can hold Bush accountable for what happened on his watch, but what happened on his watch also includes tax cuts, placing conservative judges on the bench, and a host of other popular stances that has offset the unpopularity of the colossal intelligence mess-ups over Iraq.
In other words, Bush's answer to the Washington Post's question doesn't hold water. CBS has fired more employees in its memogate scandal--four more to be exact--than George W. Bush has fired in his administration's intelligence debacles on Iraq.
Democracy is not the cure-all for the Middle East's woes. Mort Zuckerman recognized this on The McLaughlin Group this weekend. The publishing magnate ventured that if Saudi Arabia were to hold elections, seventy-five percent of the people would vote for Osama bin Laden. In Egypt, Zuckerman suggested, the Muslim Brotherhood might find itself in power if the people had the choice. In both cases, democracy would bring a worse outcome than the status quo. Zuckerman's point is exactly why placing one's faith in democracy to make everything right is misguided. The mob can be as unwise and unjust as any sultan.
Charles Graner, described as the ringleader of the abuses at Abu Ghraib by the people he describes as the ringleaders of the abuses at Abu Ghraib, was found guilty of maltreating prisoners, conspiracy, dereliction of duty, committing indecent acts, and assault. The case illustrates a basic difference between Western civilization and the more extreme parts of the Islamic world: here, an abuser of captives faces more than seventeen years in jail; there, abusers of captives are considered heroes.
One passage in the Associated Press article on the verdict caught my attention: "One witness, Syrian prisoner Amin al-Sheikh, had characterized Graner as the 'primary torturer,' who merrily whistled, sang and laughed while brutalizing him and forced him to eat pork and drink alcohol in violation of his Muslim faith." Two observations: 1. Torture occured at Abu Ghraib, but what the prisoner describes is not torture. Forcing people to engage in activities that violate their conscience is clearly wrong and all, but it's not like Graner was making the prisoners wash down raw pork with Stroh's. 2. How, precisely, did the Syrian Mr. al-Sheikh find himself in an Iraqi prison?
I would blog on this for several more hours (really, I would), but it is Friday night and I plan on torturing myself with ribs and Labatt's Blue.
Colin Powell was "absolutely sure." Ari Fleischer professed to "know for a fact." Donald Rumsfeld announced: "We know where they are." George Tenet proclaimed it a "slam dunk." George W. Bush and Dick Cheney both said there was "no doubt." It turns out all of these wise men holding the reins of government were wrong.
Nearly two years after invading Iraq, the U.S. government announced that it was calling off its search for Iraq's stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction. In case you haven't been paying attention, they couldn't find them.
It doesn't seem improbable that these men truly thought Saddam Hussein possessed such weapons. But thinking something is a lot different from knowing something. There's a wide gap between suspicion and "slam dunk," "no doubt," "absolutely sure," "know for a fact," etc. Now we know the Bush administration didn't have a single human intelligence source on the ground in Iraq, let alone one telling us that Saddam Hussein had stockpiles of WMD. Bush, Cheney, Powell, and the others had no business speaking with such certainty.
The president's defenders are left theorizing that the WMD lay hidden somewhere, making ex post facto arguments downplaying the centrality of WMD in the justification for war, and insisting that the president didn't lie. The first point is unsupported and the second ridiculous, but on the last point: fair enough. The president made a mistake. But isn't the mistake bad enough? Sure, he didn't lie, but his miscalculation has cost us hundreds of billions of dollars, international credibility, and 1,300 American lives. The partisan debate featuring the president's enemies attacking him for being a liar and his supporters defending him for being mistaken obscures the salient point: couldn't we have done better than a choice between dishonesty and incompetence?
"Don't cheerleaders all over America form pyramids six to eight times a year?" asked the lawyer of Charles Graner during the Army specialist's court martial on Monday. Referring to the infamous, naked, Abu Ghraib POW-pyramid, attorney Guy Womack wondered aloud, "Is that torture?" I might add that I strongly suspect that several gentlemen that I'm familiar with would pay between $80 and $140 to be forced to wear a dog-collar and parade around in women's undergarments, but this is hardly the type of argument that wins acquittal in court martial cases. Johnnie Cochran, Guy Womack isn't.
Hugo Chavez's government in Venezuela is set to expropriate a 32,000-acre ranch owned by a British lord. The seizure is among the first of more than 100,000 estates, farms, and other pieces of property that closet-Communist Chavez plans to redistribute in the coming months. "The full weight of the armed forces and the police will be present to implement the first phase of the land mission," explained Alexis Ortiz, the attorney general for the Venezualan province. What's phase two? I've seen this movie before. Whether it's called Zimbabwe, Uganda, or Bangladesh, this story never has a happy ending. Expropriation drives the wealth creators out of a nation. It promises the poor wealth, but instead delivers to them more poverty.
An Associated Press article caught my eye: "Iraqis in U.S. Face Big Hurdles Voting." What size hurdles do you suppose Iraqis in Iraq face in voting?
Terrorists assassinated the governor of the largest province in Iraq on Tuesday. In less than a month, Iraqis are scheduled to elect a government. With the country's most populous regions in a state of disorder, can we really expect anything resembling political liberty by January 30? Or even January 30, 2006?
Aside from the immediate concerns about holding credible elections in a state of anarchy--which certainly describes the situation in certain areas--there is the more important, and more overlooked, longterm issue of whether the vote will bring good things for Iraqis, their neighbors, and us. Ballots can elect a George Washington as easily as they can elect an Adolf Hitler. Sure, giving people a political choice is important. It's also important that people make wise choices. Would you rather be ruled by an 18th-century Virginia gentleman or a 21st-century Shiite cleric? I'll let you guess who is more likely to govern Iraq.
The contemporary fetish for democracy as a panacea for the Middle East's problems overlooks the reality that the people of many Arab countries are more barbaric and anti-American than their rulers. Democracy works neither with an unenlightened nor an oppressive electorate. What good is the ballot that votes away your paycheck, your freedom of speech, and your ability to practice your faith? We can't assume respect for these values to grow overnight in a soil forever hostile to it. Yet if we remain as an occupying force attempting to instill these values over years, we lose lives and money--and risk moving further away from the goal of a free, democratic, and stable Iraq. Democracy by gun point, after all, is an oxymoron.
Last June, I hoped that the Bush Administration's turnover of some basic governing functions of Iraq to indigenous bureaucrats and politicians would impede the insurrection and decrease the killing. It didn't. Similarly, I hope that January's election will bring peace, prosperity, stability, freedom, the rule of law, and self-government to a more enlightened Iraqi people. But I don't think that it will.
Even misers are generous when they have other people's money to give. That's why foreign aid is not the best indicator of the generosity of a people. More indicative is private giving. President Bush recognized this today by stating: "The greatest source of America's generosity is not our government; it's the good heart of the American people." But media reports on the Indian Ocean tsunami relief efforts have maximized public giving and minimized private giving. Might this have something to do with the number of cheapskates abroad? Anecdotally, any waiter or waitress will tell you this is true when it comes to tipping. Statistically, the percentage of the gross domestic product spent in donations in various nations tells us this is true too. Donations in terms of the absolute dollar amount and in terms of the percentage of gross domestic product are greater in the United States than in just about every country in the world. Strictly as a percentage of GDP, U.S. private giving--excluding religious donations--exceeds private giving in Mexico by 25 to 1, Germany by 12 to 1, Italy by 11 to 1, Japan by 7 to 1, and Jan Hegeland's Norway by 4 to 1. Who says we're stingy?
When someone gives you a whole bunch of money and expects nothing in return, the proper response is "thank you" not "blank you."
The Times of India labels the U.S. "parsimonious," its tsunami relief package "crumbs," and its record in foreign aid "less than generous." Less generous than, say, India's?
"Aid is not charity," the paper contends. "This is the basic point that the West, particularly the U.S., must realise." Government aid, whether in the form of food stamps or foreign aid, certainly isn't charity. Its dispensers give what's not theirs and its receivers are often government officials--sometimes on the take--rather than the truly needy.
I'm prepared to agree that "aid is not charity," but the India Times's following convenient supposition is not something that I--or any other rational person--would be willing to indulge. "Aid is trade," the paper claims, "nothing more or less." Really? We are giving the embattled region $350 million. What are we getting in return for what we're "trading" you? A scowl? Insults? Complaints?
There are more than 150,000 dead from the Sumatra earthquake and the ensuing tsunami. Many more will die from starvation and disease. Now is not the time to score ideological points--as the India Times is attempting to do--but to save lives. Three-hundred-fifty million dollars will help do that. Reflexively blaming America for a natural disaster won't.
America can't win for losing. When the Bush Administration made an initial pledge of $15 million for disaster relief for the Indian Ocean tsunami, United Nations hack Jan Hegeland used the occassion to indirectly criticize the U.S. foreign aid program as "stingy." Now that President Bush has upped the ante to $35 million, and vowed to work with other wealthy democracies to administer aid, the anti-American left is crying foul again.
The blogosphere is amok with reactions to this latest America-bashing outrage. Weighing-in are Captain Ed, Betsy's Page, Michael Totten, and the Anti-Idiotarian Rottweiler.
"Only really the UN can do that job," whined Clare Short, a former minister in Tony Blair's government. "It is the only body that has the moral authority. But it can only do it well if it is backed up by the authority of the great powers."
Translation: give us your money, America, and we'll spend it however we see fit. After the manner in which the United Nations handled the Oil for Food program designed to alleviate the Iraqi humanitarian crisis, can you blame Bush for not wanting U.S. aid to pass through the hands of international Eurocrats in New York?
Norwegian Jan Egeland, the United Nation's undersecretary-general for humanitarian affairs and emergency relief, yesterday used the Sumatra earthquake tragedy as an opportunity to obliquely blast U.S. foreign aid efforts as "stingy."
The United States has made an initial commitment of $15 million to aid the victims of the Sumatra earthquake and the ensuing catastrophes. That's about ten times more than Germany, fifteen times more than Canada, and fifty times more than South Africa. The European Union, which consists of twenty-five member states, pledged just $4 million. That's $160,000 per member state, if you're counting.
If UN officials really were concerned with stinginess among its members, there are 184 other member nations it might want to examine before singling out the United States--its largest benefactor. But, of course, Mr. Egeland's rant had nothing to do with helping victims of a natural disaster and everything to do with bashing America.
Never having consciously experienced an earthquake, it's tough for me to comprehend what one feels like--let alone an earthquake that hits 9.0 on the Richter scale. Scientists measured one of the aftershocks of Sunday's quake at 7.3, considerably larger than the 6.6 earthquake that killed 30,000 people in Iran last year and the 6.9 earthquake that hit San Francisco during the 1989 World Series.
To put this in perspective, a 620-mile section of the Earth moved. The earthquake pushed the entire island of Sumatra 100 feet. It even affected the rotation of the planet.
Just as the earthquake itself caused only a fraction of this tragedy's deaths, the ensuing tsunami--some reports told of 40-foot waves travelling 500 miles per hour--will account for just part of the final death toll. Millions are homeless. Decomposing bodies, sewage, and debris now mix with the drinking water. Starvation and disease loom. Currently, the death toll stands at about 22,000. Expect that number to rise.
"The fact that so many hypotheses are necessary to reconcile a theory with the facts should persuade one to abandon the theory itself," Raymond Aron wrote in The Opium of the Intellectuals. Aron's words readily apply themselves to a current controversy surrounding the Iraq war.
Prior to the war, some neoconservative theorists assured us Iraq would be a "cakewalk," that democracy in Iraq would cause a domino-effect of democracy in the surrounding countries, and that the reconstruction would be cheap and paid for with Iraqi assets. None of this has come to pass. Rather than admit flaws in their theories and predictions, pro-war pundits have turned their guns on a man they lionized up until fairly recently: Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld. Why? To absolve themselves of responsibility for the failure of their ideas in action. Crying that an idea didn't work as marvelously outside of your head as it did inside of it is, of course, the fallback position of all utopians. Ever hear a delusional academic claim that communism has never failed because it's never been tried? That's more than a bit like the blame-game that currently engulfs the pro-war scribes and bureaucrats.
Robert Novak's latest column on the internecine war between pro-war pundits and the secretary of defense is a must-read. Armed with his pen, William Kristol has inflicted the unkindest cut of all upon the beleaguered Rumsfeld. Novak writes: "the neocon message is that the war was no mistake but has been badly conducted.... [William] Kristol's call for Rumsfeld's dismissal removes culpability for those who beat the drums to go to war."
He continues: "Getting rid of Rumsfeld does not answer agonizing questions. Was the change of regime in Baghdad worth going to war? Could Saddam Hussein have been removed from power by other means? Is the use of U.S. military power to topple undemocratic regimes good policy?"
"There are no clear answers," Novak concludes. "To say simply that all would be well in Iraq, save for Don Rumsfeld, only begs these questions."
As is the case with many big-government do-gooder schemes, the public is finally catching on that the advertised benefits don't outweigh the obscured costs in Iraq. A Washington Post/ABC News poll reports that 56 percent of the American people believe the Iraq war was "not worth fighting" and that 70 percent of the American people believe that any gains from the war have come at an "unacceptable" price. President 43 would have been wise to have read President 6 before embarking on this ill-advised nation-building scheme.
An NBC News/Wall Street Journal poll asked Americans: "When it comes to the war in Iraq, do you think that removing Saddam Hussein from power was or was not worth the number of U.S. military casualties and the financial cost of the war?" More respondents answered in the negative (48 percent) than in the positive (43 percent).
We know the costs: lives, dollars, and credibility. Other than removing Iraq's brutal dictator, what, exactly, are the benefits? Blocking Hussein from attacking us with imaginary weapons of mass destruction? Retaliating against Iraq for its non-role in 9/11? Giving democracy to people who fight against it more ferociously than they fought against tyranny?
Various conservative media outlets are calling on Kofi Annan to resign as secretary general of the United Nations in light of his mishandling of the "Oil for Food" program for Iraq and his son's role in that scandal. I join these writers in calling for Annan to resign. I ask them to join me in calling on all of Kofi Annan's colleague's to resign with him.
The United Nations is a farce. It has democratic pretensions, but the majority of the national delegates were appointed by governments that don't have the consent of the governed. Seriously, does it make sense for Muamar Khadafi to have a personal representative voting in the United Nations but for the people of Libya not to have one? Even if the UN became a league exclusively of democratic nations, it would be an enemy of self-government in that it takes decision-making further and further away from the people.
With many globalists dreaming of UN taxing authority or a blue-helmeted world army, a few elites hope to further consolidate their power. This is bad news for anyone who cares about national sovereignty.
Yeah, and that scandal about stealing billions of dollars intended for the people of Iraq? Well, that was bad too but it has no bearing on whether one views the United Nations as a legitimate institution or not.
So Kofi, it's time to go. It's time for you and everyone else at the United Nations to go home.
With at least 135 U.S. deaths, November tied April as the deadliest month for American servicemen in Iraq. Although no statistic measures this, November also seems to have been the deadliest month for insurgents, terrorists, and other Arab ne'er-do-wells because of the assault on Fallujah.
With Saddam Hussein rotting in a cell, and the primary motivations for going to war--weapons of mass destruction, Hussein-9/11 link, an advanced nuclear program--proven false even to the White House's satisfaction, the question necessarily arises: what are we doing in Iraq?
What President Bush is doing is what Governor Bush denounced: nation-building. Next month's elections have caused the president to boost the U.S. troop presence in Iraq to its highest level in the short history of the war. And for what? So that Iraqis can elect a government. In other words, to nation-build.
In 2000, Republicans ran mocking the practice of nation-building, something the Clinton administration had taken part in, for instance, in Haiti and Bosnia. In 2004, Republicans eagerly support our continued presence in Iraq that focuses on one objective: nation-building. How quickly politics overtakes principle.
After proposing guidelines for medically-sanctioned infanticide, doctors at the Groningen Academic Hospital in Holland admitted that they have already begun to administer deadly amounts of poisons to infants that they judge unable to live. Issuing such a judgment on a person, and then proceeding to kill that person, is certainly one way to vindicate your "medical" assessment.
Not to worry, because the Dutch find all of this very controversial.
"As things are, people are doing this secretly and that's wrong," explained Eduard Verhagen, who runs the hospital's children's ward. Would it make it any better if doctors were murdering babies in the open?
If this callous disregard for human life strikes you, in the words of Yogi Berra, as deja vu all over again, check out Edwin Black's War Against the Weak (buy it here), which chronicles early twentieth-century efforts--particularly ones here in America--by scientists to decide who lives and who dies.
Three years ago, the Dutch legalized doctor-assisted suicide. Now, doctors are killing infants, obviously with no one's consent save their own. Who's next?
If you've ever heard the phrase "slippery slope" and were confused by its meaning, just look at how the Dutch practice of doctors aiding patients to commit suicide has evolved to encompass doctors murdering sick babies.
Marines aced an Iraqi who fired at them while he pretended to be dead. About a week ago, another Marine's killing of a wounded and unarmed Iraqi brought about an hysterical response in some quarters. Those dumbfounded by why that Marine did what he did now have a better understanding. When you're fighting an enemy that employs underhanded tactics, it helps to fight them with the expectation that they will employ underhanded tactics. In other words, the barbaric conduct of some Iraqi insurgents--faking death to kill approaching Marines--led to the disturbing death of that wounded and unarmed man broadcast to the world a few days ago. If liberals bothered to examine the conduct of the Arab fighters as closely as they scrutinize the conduct of Americans soldiers, sailors, airmen, and Marines, they might better understand why that Marine possibly took the action that he did in Fallujah.
Earlier this week, a Marine invaded our television sets by killing a wounded and unarmed insurgent in a Fallujah mosque. Naturally, the Muslim world is shocked, shocked. But so are many Americans, unaccustomed perhaps to seeing war on something other than the silver screen.
From my living room, it appears that the Marine acted callously and without regard for human life...from my living room. But the disturbing incident took place in a much less controlled environment than from where I witnessed it. Consider that the Marine shooting the unarmed fighter was wounded in the face the day prior, that a block from where the mosque incident took place a booby-trapped body had killed another Marine, and that the Marines had just been warned to look out for Iraqis feigning death to inflict death.
Our enemies get to decapitate, kidnap, and intentionally blow-up civilians. Americans are to fight by the Marquis of Queensbury rules. Marines are to be cautious, indulgent, and willing to give the enemy the benefit of the doubt. In other words, they are to be reckless with their own lives.
Should those employing every dirty trick in the book be surprised when Americans react to them as if they are capable of employing every dirty trick in the book?
George Will suggests a number of hard-hitting questions for senators to ask secretary of state nominee Condoleezza Rice during her confirmation hearing. Among them, Will wants to know whether Rice would agree with the secretary of defense during the first Iraq war, who stated: "Once you've got Baghdad, it's not clear what you do with it. It's not clear what kind of government you would put in place of the one that's currently there now. Is it going to be a Shia regime, a Sunni regime or a Kurdish regime? Or one that tilts toward the Baathists, or one that tilts toward the Islamic fundamentalists? How much credibility is that government going to have if it's set up by the United States military when it's there? How long does the United States military have to stay to protect the people that sign on for that government, and what happens to it once we leave?" The defense secretary skepticly raising these questions was none other than the current vice president, Dick Cheney.
Exactly when and by what means, in the twelve years between issuing these remarks and marking himself as the chief administration hawk balking at these very same warnings, did aliens steal Dick Cheney's brain?
If you're an Israeli and you hate Yasser Arafat, then he is dying of AIDS. If you're a Palestinian and you hate Jews, then Arafat has been poisoned by the Israelis.
Larger than life figures are mere mortals when it comes to death. Their admiring and despising publics don't believe it. The Kennedys murdered Marilyn Monroe. The CIA assassinated Martin Luther King. Prince Charles offed Lady Diana. Even the deaths of mediocre historical figures, such as Zachary Taylor, are surrounded in intrigue.
Yasser Arafat's death is remarkable only in that it occurs peacefully in a hospital bed. Like conspiracy theories surrounding Monroe, MLK, Lady Di, and General Taylor, the wild tales regarding Arafat's demise rely mostly on the imaginations of their proponents. When I see actual evidence showing that Arafat has AIDS or has been poisoned, then I'll believe it. Until then, the competing theories prove nothing save the enormous capacity man has to fantasize the worst possible things about his enemies.
Osama bin Laden issued this year's "October surprise." His videotaped message (his first in over a year) sought to influence the U.S. elections on Tuesday. It will, but not in the way intended. Americans are not Spaniards.
This spring, orchestrated bombings on passenger trains and rail stations in Spain dramatically influenced elections in that country. Going into the final weeks of the campaign, conservatives held commanding leads in the polls. The bombings happened, public opinion shifted, and socialists won the election. The new government's policies were far more agreeable to Islamic terrorists, particularly its decision to withdraw from Iraq and distance itself from the Bush administration.
Stunts like that pulled on the eve of the American election will have a very different effect. Any shift in the debate towards national security issues, particularly the war on terrorism, helps Bush and hurts Kerry. Bin Laden may have hoped to hurt Bush, but he didn't. He helped him, greatly.
He did so because he misunderstands Americans. Bin Laden confuses Americans for Europeans. Issuing threats, tacit or otherwise, might compel Frenchmen or Spaniards to recraft policy to better suit the interests of terrorists. Americans, however, live in a different hemisphere and behave in a different manner. Bin Laden's threats are far less likely to result in the American people giving bin Laden what he wants, than they are in the American people giving him something he doesn't want--a bomb dropped on his head. The man more likely to do this, the American people believe, is George Bush and not John Kerry.
Azzam the American reminds me of Dave Chappelle's comedy bit where a blind black man becomes an intellectual leader to white supremacists. Born Adam Pearlman, Azzam the American is, as his former last name suggests, Jewish, and as his current last name suggests, American. Normally, this combination would make him a dream candidate for an al Qaeda beheading. Mr. Pearlman-American, however, has joined the terrorists. This apparently means that he needn't worry about parting ways with his head anytime soon.
Mr. Pearlman-American should worry about other things. He is an American who has enlisted with the wartime enemies of the United States. This makes him a traitor. This makes him guilty of treason. Treason carries a maximum penalty of death. If Azzam the American doesn't die in combat operations, he will get captured at some point in the future.
In 1953, the United States executed the Rosenbergs for engaging in espionage for the Soviet Union. Fifty-one years later, are we serious enough about treason to punish Azzam the American in a manner more severe than the penalty meted out to John Walker Lindh?
The Washington Times reports that the U.S. government is investigating intelligence reports that 25 Chechen terrorists have crossed into the United States via Mexico. The Bush Administration failed to learn a major lesson of 9/11: immigration is now an national security issue. The President's initial solution to the border problem was to make illegal immigrants legal immigrants with the stroke of a pen. The public balked, and the plan was quietly withdrawn. Uncounted numbers of foreigners illegally enter the U.S. every year. Millions come looking for jobs. A smaller number come to sponge off the system. Twenty-five, apparently, have come hoping to kill Americans.
The Pentagon acknowledged today that at least seven detainees released from Guantanamo Bay, Cuba have since resumed a life of terrorism. According to Fox News, one former detainee killed a judge in Afghanistan, two more got killed fighting against allied forces in Afghanistan, and a third is currently in the news for threatening the lives of two kidnapped Chinese engineers in Pakistan.
We are in a war. Why were these terrorists released?
Last I checked, the other side doesn't have a very good track record in its treatment of prisoners. Certainly there was no prisoner-swap that we all failed to hear about. The war didn't end either, which is another time when it's customary to release enemy combatants. So why were these men unleashed upon the world? Because political correctness trumped the aims of the war on terror.
The usual suspects have been whining about Guantanamo Bay for several years. For evidence of this, look here, here, here, and here.
Mercy to the guilty is cruelty to the innocent. In the more than two centuries since Adam Smith wrote these words, liberals have yet to grasp this basic concept.
The people of the United States, Great Britain, Australia, and Italy all agree that the war in Iraq has made the threat of terrorism greater. The governments of these nations, obviously, disagree. The US, the UK, Australia, and Italy are the main countries that constitute the "coalition of the willing" in Iraq.
The Associated Press survey reports that more than half of Americans view the war in Iraq as increasing the terror threat, while about three in ten agree with the president that it has decreased the threat of terrorism. In the UK, Australia, and Italy, about one in twenty people view the war in Iraq as decreasing the threat of terrorism.
If you won a Roseanne Barr Award for Athletic Achievement or a Cameron Diaz Genius Prize, would you be honored or insulted?
Libya awarded Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez the Muammar Gahdafi Human Rights Prize this weekend. "I feel bathed in honor," Chavez explained upon receiving the award. His reaction speaks volumes. So does the fact that Gadhafi singled him out for "honor."
With the current Nobel Peace Prize winner claiming that Western scientists developed HIV as a weapon of biological warfare, and past winners including the liar Rigoberta Menchu and the murderer Yasser Arafat, one might wonder why a Muammar Gadhafi Human Rights Prize is even necessary.
If you're not a weirdo, the Gadhafi Human Rights Prize probably strikes you as an oxymoron. But it's not even the most Orwellian award that has been handed out on the international stage. In the 1950s, such Communist lackeys as singer/entertainer Paul Robeson (the Susan Sarandon of his day), novelist Howard Fast, and German playwright Bertolt Brecht were awarded the Stalin Peace Prize. Later, when Stalin fell out of favor within the Kremlin, the prize was renamed for Lenin, and the Soviet government bestowed it upon W.E.B. Du Bois and Angela Davis. Like Chavez, they too basked in the "glory" bestowed upon them.
Something had to take the place of the Stalin Peace Prize for unintentional humor value, and that something is the Muammer Gadhafi Human Rights Prize. Congratulations, Hugo Chavez. You deserve this award.
"Saddam Hussein is a man who has told the world he wouldn't have weapons of mass destruction, and yet he deceived the world. He's got them... We know he's got chemical weapons, probably has biological weapons."
--President George W. Bush, November 1, 2002
"Chief weapons inspector, Charles Duelfer, has now issued a comprehensive report that confirms the earlier conclusion of David Kay that Iraq did not have the weapons that our intelligence believed were there."
--President George W. Bush, October 7, 2004
The main justification for going to war in Iraq was based on a false assumption. It isn't anti-war critics saying this, but a report from President Bush's own Central Intelligence Agency. If the administration can admit its mistakes, why can't so many of the pundits who advanced the war in early 2003? Those still claiming Iraqi weapons of mass destruction stockpiles, now supposedly hidden in Syria or beneath the sands of the Mesopotamian deserts, do so based on a desire to be "right" rather than a desire to find the truth. They talk about Saddam Hussein's WMD the way Miss Havisham talked about her wedding dress.
Two Americans won the Nobel Prize for medicine today. The Nobel committee in Stockholm announced Richard Axel and Linda Buck the winners for the scientific advances the pair made relating to their discoveries about how the human sense of smell works.
How they came to the prize may be surprising. Where they are from should not be. An American has won at least a share of the Nobel Prize for medicine in nine of the last ten years. Since World War II, an American has won the award in roughly three-fourths of all years.
Americans cured polio, created vaccines for hepatitis B and yellow fever, and invented the pacemaker. Why does a country with such a disproportionately small percentage of humanity contribute a disproportionately large share of medical advances? The answer is freedom. Our freedom creates the wealth necessary for research and development. Our freedom guards the incentive to create. In other nations, the government reaps the rewards from creation. In America, the creator reaps the rewards--and thus we all do because this inspires ever-more creation.
One country bears the heaviest share of the burden in ensuring that we live healthier and longer lives. That country is the United States, strangely the object of much of the world's hate these days.
All cultures are not equal. All cultures are not equal because their contributions to the betterment of mankind differ. Nowhere does this maxim prove its validity more demonstratively than in medicine.
In June, 42 American servicemen were killed in Iraq. In July, 54; August, 66; and in September, 72 members of the American armed forces were killed there. "Facts," as John Adams said, "are stubborn things." The facts in Iraq are that it's getting worse, not better, for Americans. The trendline is pretty clear.
Saddam Hussein is in jail and weapons of mass destruction haven't been found. Most of the issues that led us to war have been resolved, for better or worse. Americans are now dying in Iraq for a nation-building exercise. Is it really in America's interests to spend billions of dollars and more than a thousand lives establishing a democracy in a climate that's proved inhospitable to political freedom? Know this one reality: the Arab fight against freedom and democracy, advanced by the Americans, has been more fierce and sustained than any fight to oust tyranny and oppression, advanced by Saddam Hussein. This is an uncomfortable truth, but a truth nonetheless.
Bush-haters projects their anti-war opinions on John Kerry, forgetting that the Senator voted for the war in Iraq. Kerry even noted in early August that knowing what he knows now, he would have still voted to authorize the war.
Kerry, ever the candidate of shades of gray, notes that he would have conducted the war differently than George W. Bush. Specifically, he states he would have taken a more multilateral approach. Last week, for instance, Kerry proclaimed: "the Bush administration would have you believe that when it comes to our allies, it won't make a difference who is president. They say the Europeans won't help us, no matter what. But I have news for President Bush: just because you can't do something, doesn't mean it can't be done."
In a blow to this notion, high government officials in France and Germany told the Financial Times this week that even if Kerry wins in November, they will not send troops to Iraq. So much for multilateralism.
Terrorists beheaded two Americans in Iraq this past week. On Tuesday, terrorists posted a video of them decapitating Eugene Armstrong. A day later, officials confirmed that Jack Hensley's headless body had been found in Iraq.
A year ago, this would have been the story for the better part of a week. Now, the media and the American public react to the beheadings as if they are pedestrian occurences. Where's the outrage? The idea that we've become so desensitized to beheadings that they compete for media attention with the Scott Peterson murder trial, Britney's faux marriage, and Rathergate is sad.
The murderers who beheaded these men have demanded that all Iraqi women be released from occupation jails. Since there are only two Iraqi women in custody and none in the jails cited by the kidnappers, and since the terrorists killed two of the three hostages before a response to their demands could be made, a disturbing conclusion must be drawn: the terrorists loyal to Jordanian Abu Musab al-Zarqawi commit acts of barbarism not out of the desire to fulfill any aim but out of the enjoyment of carrying out gruesome methods.
President Bush addressed the United Nations this morning. As the Sudanese delegation looked on, Bush plainly called what's occuring in that country a "genocide." He condemned cloning, and other such Frankensteinish science. "No human life should be produced or destroyed for the benefit of another," Bush maintained. Delivering his speech from the island that served as the focal point of 9/11, Bush outlined terrorism's global reach by invoking horrific events in Spain, Turkey, Israel, Russia, and points beyond. Bush naively confused Western values for universal values, claiming: "When it comes to the desire for liberty and justice, there is no clash of civilizations." (If anything Samuel Huntington's book by that name--buy it here--has been vindicated by events of recent years.) Whether these remarks represent lofty rhetoric typical of all politicians or the true sentiments of President Bush is unclear, but what is clear is that they ignore reality. Bush's best moment may have been welcoming the UN delegates to the United States, reminding them--tempered applause to the contrary--that he was at home. His lapel-pin American flag, too, was a classic touch for the UN crowd--sort of like wearing a Jesse Helms button to a gay pride parade. Bush concluded his remarks by predicting that "this young century, will be liberty's century."
Earlier this week, Colin Powell expressed doubts that weapons of mass destruction would ever be discovered in Iraq. The secretary of state, who offered a "conservative" estimate before the war that Hussein possessed between 100 and 500 tons of chemical weapons agent, now explains: "I think it's unlikely that we will find any stockpiles." The top U.S. weapons inspector in Iraq went a step further today. There were no stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, says Charles Duelfer, the top U.S. weapons inspector.
The primary cause for war--a menacing Hussein sitting on stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction--has been undermined by the American ouster of Hussein. The notion prior to the war that Hussein possessed WMD certainly was not implausible. After all, he had used them against Iranians and the Kurds. But now that the issue of stockpiles of WMD in Iraq is settled, why are we still there?
One reason is that in solving the problem of Hussein, we have created new problems. Foremost among them: the danger of fundamentalism replacing one of the more secular governments in the region. Another reason is the idea that after liberating the Iraqis from Hussein, we owe them the favor of giving them billions of dollars and ensuring their safety with the lives of our soldiers, sailors, airmen, and Marines. Haven't we already done enough for people who refuse to do for themselves?
Communism lasted for more than 70 years in Russia. Freedom lasted about a decade. Vladimir Putin (Are we allowed to preface his name with dictator yet?) already did away with the last vestiges of a free press. Now he's proposing to chip away at democracy in the wake of the Chechen terrorist attacks. Putin wants the power to appoint governors, instead of the people electing them. He wants candidates for the national legislature to come from party lists, eliminating any independent or unapproved office seekers. Perhaps someone can clue me in regarding what, exactly, Putin's proposals have to do with fighting terrorism.
Tomorrow is 9/11/04. It's been 1095 days since al Qaeda claimed credit for a terrorist attack on U.S. soil. This drought is not for lack of effort on the part of Osama bin Laden's disciples. So what has kept us safe from such attacks within the United States for three years?
One answer is the single-minded pursuit of security on the part of John Ashcroft, Tom Ridge, and others similar to them. The ACLU doesn't like them, but more importantly, neither do terrorists. Another, less-explored answer is the utter incompetence of many Islamic terrorists. Sure, they've pulled off something as satanically ingenious as the 9/11 attacks. But they've also demonstrated cartoonish bumbling in some of their ambitious, but failed, attempts at mass murder.
Consider that among the reasons the 1993 World Trade Center bombers were caught, in the words of the 9/11 Commission, is that one of the conspirators, “Mohammed Salameh, who had rented the truck and reported it stolen, kept calling the rental office to get back his $400 deposit." That truck, of course, was used as a giant bomb in the attack.
In Sudan, bin Laden and associates paid $1.5 million for weapons-grade uranium--or so they thought. The commission noted, "Al Qaeda apparently purchased the cylander, then discovered it to be bogus."
In late 1999, the Millenium Plot to blow up LAX failed because an al Qaeda operative cracked under pressure and exhibited extreme foolishness. Ahmed Ressam, a common criminal who graduated to terrorism, was arrested attempting to smuggle large amounts of explosives into the United States. Ressam boarded his car smuggling the explosives on a Canada-to-U.S. ferry, and waited until all of the cars had disembarked thinking that this would enhance his chances of success. It didn't. It drew attention to him, as did his strange behavior and anxiousness. The 9/11 Commission Report notes that as the INS agents inspected Ressam, he "panicked and tried to run away."
Three weeks later in January of 2000, al Qaeda attempted to blow up the U.S.S. Sullivans, a destroyer in the Gulf of Aden. The terrorists failed because zeal overcame common sense when they overloaded their boat with munitions and inadvertantly sank the murderous vessel.
Following the 9/11 attacks, al Qaeda terrorist Richard Reid attempted to ignite his sneaker, which was really a bomb, in the presence of other passengers on board a transatlantic flight. The passengers subdued him and foiled his plot. The event demonstrated the paradoxical nature of al Qaeda--capable of something as clever as a sneaker bomb and as idiotic as attempting to light it in such a conspicuous manner. Did Reid never figure out that he would have had more success in the bathroom?
It's a curse that so many Muslims are willing to engage in acts so evil. Thank God that so many of them are incredibly stupid.
Iraqis fight harder to block freedom than they did to oust tyranny. With news of the thousandth American death in the Iraq war, one can't help but come to this uncomfortable conclusion. The brutal regime of Saddam Hussein provoked no uprising similar, even after the Gulf War, to what Americans face now.
The milestone raises an important question: Was it worth it? Other than Saddam Hussein sitting in a jail cell, there's not a lot to celebrate. The dead were sent to seize the Iraqi stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction, prevent further acts of terrorism, and create a democracy in the heart of the Arab world. The WMD stockpiles proved illusory. Iraq has become a terrorist Woodstock. The notion that a bunch of James Madisons and Thomas Jeffersons were sitting around Baghdad waiting to install self-government if only America rid them of Saddam Hussein seems the stuff of comedy.
Why should Americans die giving freedom to the inhabitants of Fallujah, who die trying to block that freedom?
"We believe that the worst thieves in the world today and the worst terrorists are the Americans," Osama bin Laden told a CNN reporter three years before 9/11. "Nothing could stop you except perhaps retaliation in kind. We do not have to differentiate between military and civilian. As far as we are concerned, they are all targets."
On 9/11, two of the four targets were purely civilian. Last week in Russia, Islamic terrorists took this cowardly approach to even baser extremes, going after children on the first day of school. We should be horrified, but not surprised, when terrorists do what they say they are going to do.
Killing other Muslims seems a more controversial tactic among terrorists, particularly the captured murderers of school children in Russia who seemed shocked that their leaders killed other terrorists. In deed as well as in word, bin Laden has been clear where he stands on killing other Muslims: "when it becomes apparent that it would be impossible to repel these Americans without assaulting them, even if this involved the killing of Muslims, this is permissible under Islam."
First and foremost, terrorists are rationalizers. They justify their barbarism with certitude in the nobility of their cause. Killing other Muslims, Western civilians, and even school kids is thereby rationalized. Calls to understand why the terrorists attack us imply that there's some way to identify and correct our problem, and thus satisfy extremists who murder adolescent children. Solving the terrorist problem, however, involves a greater focus on killing the terrorists rather than understanding the terrorists. The latter course assumes that the terrorists will react rationally to change while the former course assumes that the terrorists will act like terrorists.
Could anyone have predicted 9/11? Probably not. Could anyone have prevented 9/11? Probably so.
The 9/11 Commission Report details numerous opportunities the Clinton administration had in 1998 and 1999 to kill Osama bin Laden. Political correctness and general unseriousness plagued the Clinton administration's efforts to arrest, not kill, bin Laden.
"Early drafts of this highly sensitive document emphasized that it authorized only a capture operation," the report notes of one Clinton-era directive. "The tribals were to be paid only if they captured Bin Laden, not if they killed him."
In February of 1999, a memorandum asked Clinton "to allow the CIA to give exactly the same guidance to the Northern Alliance as had just been given to the tribals: they could kill Bin Laden if a successful capture operation was not feasible. On this occasion, however, President Clinton crossed out key language he had approved in December and inserted more ambiguous language." In other words, the man who wondered what "is" is inserted weasel words to let himself off the hook. Additionally, he bowed to liberal sensibilities rather than the safety of the American people by making it unclear whether it was permissible to kill the Saudi exhile even in the event that efforts to capture him failed.
Northern Alliance leader Ahmed Massoud wasn't amused. "CIA officers described Massoud’s reaction when he heard that the United States wanted him to capture and not kill Bin Laden. One characterized Massoud’s body language as 'a wince.'" "You guys are crazy—you haven’t changed a bit," he is remembered to have said.
When not applying onerous regulations on the method in which bin Laden was to be engaged, Clinton exhibited great reluctance to strike at al Qaeda. On one occassion, Clinton administration officials balked at bombing the terrorists over concerns "that a strike would kill an Emerati prince or other senior officials who might be with Bin Laden or close by."
The report is replete with examples of other squandered chances. "I'm sure we’ll regret not acting last night," the report quotes a CIA operative named "Mike," who criticizes Clinton administration decision-makers for "worrying that some stray shrapnel might hit the Habash mosque and 'offend' Muslims." "The principals, he said, were 'obsessed' with trying to get others—Saudis, Pakistanis, Afghan tribals—to 'do what we won't do,'" the report states. "We should have done it last night," another operative commented. "We may very well come to regret the decision not to go ahead."
The report details no similar embarrassing missed opportunities on President George W. Bush's watch. Unlike Clinton, Bush never made an attempt--even of the half-hearted variety favored by his predecessor--to get bin Laden before 9/11. Eight years of missed opportunities may be worse than eight months of unpursued opportunities, but the fact is that prior to 9/11 neither administration took Islamic terrorism seriously enough. Neither did the media, or the American people. Now we do.
On 9/10, al Qaeda had killed less than fifty Americans. By 9/11, that number had increased more than sixtyfold.
The attacks occurred three years ago this week. As a result of The 9/11 Commission Report released earlier this summer, Americans now have a clearer idea of what happened that dreadful Tuesday.
Beginning with Muhammed Atta piloting American Airlines Flight 11 into the North Tower of the World Trade Center at 8:46 a.m., four planes crashed within one hour, sixteen minutes, and thirty-one seconds.
Within thirty minutes of takeoff, the three five-man teams that successfully used the planes as jet-fuel missiles had sprung into action. United Flight 93, which crashed into a field in Pennsylvania rather than the Capitol, carried just four hijackers who waited more than 45 minutes before launching their nefarious scheme. Other factors, including the fact that the plane carried numerous brave passengers in addition to the terrorists and that the flight took-off twenty-five minutes late, militated against al Qaeda’s plans. As the commission’s report explains, the hijackers of Flight 93 attempted to fend off the charging passengers by sharply elevating and then nosediving the plane. When it became apparent that they couldn’t complete their mission, the terrorists crashed the plane, shouting: “Allah is the greatest! Allah is the greatest!”
The explosion in the North Tower was so intense that a fireball traveled four stories below ground. More than a third of New York City’s fire companies had arrived at the scene of carnage in lower Manhattan prior to the collapse of either Twin Tower. “The first FDNY fatality of the day occurred at approximately 9:30, when a civilian landed on and killed a fireman near the intersection of West and Liberty streets,” The 9/11 Commission Report notes.
The South Tower, the building that got hit second but collapsed first, crashed to the ground at 9:59 a.m. So great was the force that firefighters on the upper levels of the North Tower got knocked down when the South Tower crumbled to earth. Within minutes, the firefighters in the North Tower were forcefully ordered: “All FDNY, get the f*** out!” Just as adamantly, one firefighter responded: “We’re not f***ing coming out!”
That firefighter likely died when the North Tower came down about a half-hour after the South Tower’s collapse. Amazingly, sixteen people inside of the North Tower survived its collapse. Not a single person inside the South Tower when it imploded lived.
The FDNY lost 343 men, the Port Authority Police Department endured 37 deaths, the Pentagon saw 184 Americans killed, and the NYPD suffered 23 fatalities.
At a total cost of about a half-million dollars, al Qaeda killed 2973 people, caused billions of dollars in destruction, and successfully targeted the functioning symbols of America’s military and economic power. With all that bloodshed, the terrorists no doubt view their investment as money well spent.
For Islamic terrorists, their ends always justify their means. But what end is so glorious that it justifies kidnapping hundreds of children? Chechan terrorists have taken a schoolhouse full of children hostage. Rather than a sign that a cause is noble, the rationale that the ends justify the means usually denotes an evil cause. After all, the Red Cross or the United Way don't go around killing people to bring attention to their causes. People serving evil causes do this, which includes the terrorists in Iraq killing a dozen Nepalese journalists, the terrorists in Russia holding school kids as human sheilds, and the terrorists in Israel blowing up buses. Their means are evil, and not coincidentally, so are their ends.
The espionage allegations against Defense Department official Larry Franklin have given rise to more questions than answers. One question stands out: Why wasn't Franklin fired last year when he undermined U.S. policy by holding unauthorized secret meetings with an expatriate Iranian?
Last August, a strange story emerged of Larry Franklin and another Defense Department official meeting with Iranian arms dealer Manucher Ghorbanifar of Iran-Contra fame. One upset U.S. official believed the purpose of the meetings was to "antagonise Iran so that they get frustrated and then by their reactions harden U.S. policy against them." Secretary of State Colin Powell complained directly to Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, and the White House reportedly instructed Rumsfeld to put a stop to meetings that go against official policy.
I've never worked in government, but my understanding is that it's unusual for Pentagon staffers to conduct their own foreign policy without the knowledge, and against the interests, of their superiors. The freelancing by underlings of Douglas Feith, according to one senior Department of Defense official, was the accidental result of an "unplanned, unscheduled encounter." Isn't it a bit strange for an Iran wonk to meet by chance with a famous Iranian dissident--in France and Italy no less?
The meeting was set up by Michael Ledeen, whose writings exhibit a not so mild obsession over Iran. "I'm not going to comment on any private meetings with any private people," Ledeen commented at the time. "It's nobody's business." Private people? These are government officials. It is our business.
Whether Larry Franklin was working for his own or some other party's objectives with these sub rosa meetings is unclear. What is clear is that he wasn't working towards the objectives of the government that employs him. We don't know if the allegations of espionage against Larry Franklin are true. We do know that he should have been fired more than a year ago.
Iraqi police have reportedly taken control of the Imam Ali Mosque, which fighters loyal to Muqtada al-Sadr have been using as a giant foxhole. Seventy-seven Iraqis were killed in the overnight battle to gain control of the mosque.
"The Imam Ali Mosque shrine complex is a very sensitive site for all concerned and we are working very closely with the Iraqi security forces to ensure that we have the right people going into the shrine and ensure that the least amount of damage is done to that site," declared U.S. Army Lt. Col. Myles Miyamasu.
Why? The shrine complex is sacred, but so are human lives. Insurgents were using that holy site as a sanctuary. If the U.S. Army used that mosque as a barracks, do you think the Islamic extremists would hesitate to bomb it? What the insurgents were doing in the Imam Ali Mosque violates the laws of war. If the place got leveled it would be the responsibility of those using it for warfare inside, not those responding to the attack on the outside.
The example of the Imam Ali Mosque illustrates the level of civilization exhibited by both sides in this conflict. By using a mosque as a hiding place, the Shiite insurgents count on the civilization of their foes to ensure their safety. By not leveling the mosque, the Americans show greater concern for the Shiite holy site than the Shiites themselves.
If liberals applied the same standards to Venezuela today that they applied to Florida four years ago, then Michael Moore would be leading protests to invade the South American nation.
"A 61-year-old grandmother was shot in the back as she ran for cover," Thor Halvorssen writes in the Wall Street Journal. "The bullet ripped through her aorta, kidney and stomach. She later bled to death in the emergency room. An opposition congressman was shot in the shoulder and remains in critical care. Eight others suffered severe gunshot wounds. Hilda Mendoza Denham, a British subject visiting Caracas for her mother's 80th birthday, was shot at close range with hollow-point bullets from a high-caliber pistol. She now lies sedated in a hospital bed after a long and complicated operation. She is my mother."
If only George W. Bush had goons shoot a bunch of people after the Florida recount controversy, some Republicans must be thinking, then maybe liberals would have declared him the legitimate president. Well, not really. Bush is a Republican and Hugo Chávez is a Communist. When you're a Communist, you get to rig elections, further loot your impoverished country, and allow goons to open-fire on crowds--and liberals will look the other way. When you're a Republican, discounting felons' ballots or counting absentee votes from overseas servicemen is enough to provoke cries of "fraud" and "illegitimate."
Halvorssen reports election officials moving one opposition voter's polling station hundreds of miles away and erasing others from the voting rolls. Worse still, the Chávez regime bought into a company that supplies computerized ballot boxes and then awarded the company the contract to tally the votes in Venezuela.
Halvorssen writes: "Smartmatic Corp., a Florida company that has never before supplied election machinery, is owned by two Venezuelans. The software came from Bizta Software, owned by the same two people. The Miami Herald recently revealed that the Chávez regime spent $200,000 last year to purchase 28% of Bizta and put a government official and longtime Chávez ally on the board. After the story broke, Bizta bought back the government-held shares and the official resigned from the board. But not until after the two companies were granted a significant part of the $91 million contract for the referendum."
Had George W. Bush's lackeys owned the company responsible for tallying votes in the controversial 2000 election, how do you suppose Jimmy Carter and the other liberals vouching for the fairness of the Venezuelan recall loss would have reacted?
One leads a shagadelic lifestyle filled with sex and mind-altering drugs. The other reads the Koran all day long. One wears ruffled shirts and colorful velvet jackets. The other's wardrobe knows one color: black. Despite their differences, Austin Powers and Muqtada al-Sadr have something in common: they both use Fun Dip instead of Crest to brush their teeth.
World War II ended almost sixty years ago. The Cold War has been over for more than a decade. The question regarding our military presence in Europe has shifted from why are we left defending these people, to who are we defending these people from. That latter question dawned on George W. Bush, as did the correct answer. The president has decided to bring 70,000 U.S. troops home from abroad over the course of the next decade. The focus has shifted, properly, to defending America. Additionally, it's doubtful that several of our NATO allies would lift a finger to defend us. Why should we spend our treasure, dislocate our soldiers, and promise the lives of our countrymen to defend them?
"If we do not quickly expose the vulnerability of mullahs and empower the Iranian people," Michael Ledeen writes in today's National Review Online. "I believe the next few months in Iraq will, if Tehran has its way, be bloodier than anything we have seen to date. Not to mention the planned attacks against us here at home."
Since when is it the American military's job to "empower" whole nations of people? Ledeen's "empower" rhetoric makes it sound as if the U.S. military is one giant motivational speaker or a welfare to work program. And if Ledeen has evidence that Iran is planning attacks on American soil, please share it with the rest of us. Like a lot of people, I'm afraid I'd like to see the actual evidence this time around before going to war.
Iran is a greater state-sponsor of terrorism than Iraq, and they should be stopped before creating a nuclear weapon. But the danger of taking on Iraq after Afghanistan is that it necessarily eroded support for future campaigns--no matter how much more desirable. The American people have a tolerance level for wars of aggression, and I'm happy to report we've met our limit with Iraq. Iranian state-sponsorship of future acts of terrorism against the U.S. can and will change things. For one, it will make a war of choice into perhaps a war of necessity. But to simply invade a country in order to remake it in our image is a utopian delusion destined to fail. Transforming nations overnight is what many war hawks fantasize about regarding Iran, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Libya, and despotisms beyond. They want Iraqs as far as the eye can see. Michael Ledeen's fantasy is our nightmare.
Iran's neighbors to the west are having a much better public relations go of it at the Olympics. Remarkably, Iraq's soccer team defeated Portugal--a powerhouse squad--and Costa Rica to advance to round two. So great was the enthusiasm that numerous spectators stormed the field after each Iraq goal versus Costa Rica, with one fan draping the Iraqi flag on the opposition's goal. Might their success at the Olympic Games help turn things around in Iraq?
Don't underestimate the power of sport to rally a nation. In 1980, America was emerging from a decade of defeat in Vietnam, stagflation, Watergate, and humiliation at the hands of Iranian kidnappers. The moment when things turned around wasn't Reagan's election or when the economy starting picking up steam in late '82. It was the rag-tag Team USA's hockey victory over the Soviet Union at the Winter Olympics, and their subsequent win in the gold-medal game over Finland. Let's hope that by seeing their nation's success in Athens, everyday Iraqis will rally to make their nation a better place. Certainly the on-field success can't hurt.
Venezuelans go to the polls today to decide whether Castro lackey Hugo Chavez will remain president of the oil-rich country. If there's a ballot-box victory over Chavez, it will likely prove pyrrhic. Chavez doesn't believe in freedom. He believes in Communism. If Chavez wins today, he stays in office. If Chavez loses today, he stays in office.
American intelligence officials claim that a new Osama bin Laden tape may set off a series of attacks, possibly assassinations against U.S. leaders. Evidence of such a plot was reportedly found on the laptop of captured al Qaeda operative Muhammad Naeem Noor Khan.
"There may be such a tape, but it hasn't surfaced and we haven't seen it," the source told the Washington Times about the potential of a new bin Laden message. He further explained: "The goal of the next attack is twofold: to damage the U.S. economy and to undermine the U.S. election."
Something tells me the U.S. leaders who charged that the Bush administration issued last week's terrorist warning as a political stunt are taking this latest threat more seriously.
Aristotle said that although we love both truth and our friends, piety requires us to love truth more. It's likely that Army Sgt. Joseph Darby never came upon these words, but he lived by them in putting a stop to the Abu Ghraib prison-abuse scandal. "These people were my friends," Darby testified on Friday. "It's a hard call to have to make the decision to put your friends in prison." It is, but for a person of character it's even harder to sit idle while your cohorts abuse other human beings for amusement.
General Tommy Franks told radio host Sean Hannity earlier this week that Jordan's King Abdullah and Egyptian dictator Hosni Mubarak told the U.S. prior to the Iraq war that Saddam Hussein possessed weapons of mass destruction. "A number of other leaders in the Mideast told us he had them, too," NewsMax.com reports Franks telling Hannity, with the general adding, "If you were president of the United States, could you avoid paying attention to that?"
No, but since when did we rely on the intelligence of Egypt and Jordan, or the Czech Republic, Great Britain, and Ahmed Chalabi for that matter? Intelligence sharing among allies has always occurred, but what about the primacy of U.S. intelligence? The unfortunate reality is that American intelligence didn't have a single human source on the ground in Iraq. You can't credibly gather intelligence by satellite and desk analysts alone. When you do, you're compelled to rely on other countries for human intelligence. In other words, you rely on the unreliable. Our weak intelligence led to the debacle in Iraq, the confusing of an aspirin factory for a weapons plant in Sudan, and the belief in the hoax of a genocide of Kosovar Muslims by the Serbs.
Certainly it was not absurd to believe that Iraq might have had WMD in early 2003, that Sudan might have been manufacturing dangerous weapons in the summer of 1998, or that Milosevic was capable of genocide in 1999. But to act on these suspicions, you need confirmation--something we lacked.
If you haven't noticed, there's a pattern to the major claims made prior to the U.S. invasion to justify the Iraq war. Bush Administration officials cited Czech intelligence in promoting the phantom Muhammad Atta meeting with Iraqi agents in Prague. The President relied on British intelligence for his claim that Hussein attempted to purchase uranium from Niger. And now they're trying to share blame on the weapons of mass destruction intelligence gaffes with Middle Eastern governments.
So where are the stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction? Perhaps they're buried in the mass graves of thousands in Serbia, or hidden in the chemical weapons plant disguised as an aspirin factory in Sudan. This is just a guess based on analysis, but then again isn't that what passes for intelligence within our government these days?
Tom Ridge has raised the terrorism threat level to "high" for Washington, DC, Northern New Jersey, and New York City. The targeted "Orange Alert" has led to the closing of the Holland Tunnel's inbound lanes for trucks.
The last few weeks have witnessed numerous key arrests in the war on terror. Last week, Pakistan announced that it had arrested Ahmed Khalfan Ghailani, a African who has been linked to the 1998 American embassy bombings in Kenya and Tanzania. Around the same time on the U.S.-Mexican border, U.S. border patrol agents apprehended Farida Goolam Mahomed Ahmed, a 48-year-old South African with plans to travel to New York and four pages ripped from her passport. Perhaps the biggest prize intelligence wise has been Muhammad Naeem Noor Khan, a computer expert who has revealed a plethora of new information. Khan revealed that al Qaeda had been paying him $260 a month, the group communicates primarily through the Internet, and that he doesn't know Osama bin-Laden's whereabouts.
The new information lists among possible al Qaeda targets the World Bank and IMF buildings in the Capital, the New York Stock Exchange, and the Prudential building in New Jersey. "The preferred means of attack would be car or truck bombs," Homeland Security Secretary Tom Ridge said on Sunday. "That would be a primary means of attack."
The choice of the CitiBank building suggests that the terrorists are still in a 9/11 mindset of toppling buildings. The famous Manhattan structure was poorly built, and at least until it was reinforced it was thought to be susceptible to being knocked down by hurricane-force winds.
According to intelligence, Al Qaeda has cased the buildings, knowing what time of day the body count would be highest and how many people pass the buildings per hour. They have been planning these potential attacks, apparently, since before 9/11.
Upon enlistment, they were promised seventy-two virgins and a spot in heaven. Instead, they were sent to a place they described as "hell." Like so many other soldiers, their recruiters lied to them.
The United States just released two French nationals from Guantanamo Bay who fought in Afghanistan for the Taliban. "We have emerged from hell," the Islamist duo complain. Recruitment promises aside, what did you think would happen to you upon enlisting with the terrorists? A trip to Club Med?
The United States is, and should be, held to a higher standard than Hussein's Iraq, the Taliban's Afghanistan, and the mullahs' Iran. Before we shed tears for terrorists desiring to kill us, please remember the conditions of Americans held in captivity among the Muslim radicals.
Quietly, July is turning into one of the bloodiest months of the Iraq war for U.S. armed forces. "Since the toppling of Saddam Hussein's regime in April 2003, only three months have had a higher average of daily losses than this month: April and May of this year and last November, which saw an average of almost four US and coalition military deaths per day," an article in the Boston Globe points out today. In fact, the U.S. casualty rate has spiked since the handover. Halfway through July, U.S. forces have seen about as many deaths this month as they did in the entirety of June.
Two-hundred and fifteen years ago, the French performed a dress rehearsal for the twentieth century. Like the Communists, the French Jacobins engaged in class warfare, attacked Christianity, and violently exported their revolutionary ambitions to neighboring countries. Thinking people don't celebrate Bastille Day. They mourn it. What started out as "liberty, equality, and fraternity," recognized Nicolas de Chamfort, quickly transformed into "Be my brother or I will kill you."
I knew one day, that if I read Eric Alterman enough, I would find something to agree with him on. That day has finally come.
Alterman discusses the neoconservative fetishization for democracy in the Arab world as an almost cure-all to anti-Americanism, anti-Semitism, and terrorism. It's not. Alterman writes, "the more democratic Arab nations become, the more anti-American/anti-Israeli/pro-terrorist they become."
In other words, the people in many Arab countries are more extreme than their leaders. In many cases, democracy would not be responsible; nor would democratic governments necessarily mean improvements on the current, dictatorial regimes that pollute the Arab world. Democracy doesn't work with unenlightened voters. People who almost unanimously hate the United States, prefer Osama bin Laden to any Western leader, and support Palestinian suicide bombings against Israeli civilians deserve the control of nations like death-row inmates deserve weapons stashes in their cells.
A pack of six North African youths set off a national firestorm in France after they attacked a 23-year-old French woman and her baby. The men drew swastikas on her stomach, beat her, cut her hair, and tipped over her baby carriage. They did this, the victim alleged, because the thugs incorrectly believed her to be Jewish.
The anti-Semitic assault elicited condemnation from President Jacques Chirac and drew international headlines.
The crime initially proved difficult to solve. No area surveillence tapes showed an Islamic gang, let alone one fleeing the scene. Not one of the twenty people who the victim claimed witnessed the crime came forward. And the young mother who endured the anti-Semitic assault had a history of filing phony police reports.
It turns out the attack occurred only in its victims imagination. She made it all up.
Ayn Rand died 22 years ago, but from the grave she weighs in on the war in Iraq. Her 41-year-old essay “Collectivized ‘Rights,’” outlines principles that are championed as easily in 2004 as they were in 1963. Rand contends that free nations have the right to overthrow tyrannical governments, but should do so only when it serves their national interests.
“Dictatorship nations are outlaws,” Rand wrote. “Any free nation had the right to invade Nazi Germany and, today, has the right to invade Soviet Russia, Cuba or any other slave pen. Whether a free nation chooses to do so or not is a matter of its own self-interest, not of respect for the nonexistent ‘rights’ of gang rulers. It is not a free nation’s duty to liberate other nations at the price of self-sacrifice, but a free nation has the right to do it, when and if it so chooses.”
I have a disagreement with Rand regarding the exercise of the “right” to wantonly overthrow oppressive governments, particularly in instances when the outcome of revolutionary wars—generated internally or externally—exacerbate problems (see France, 1789; see also Russia, 1917; see also Iran, 1979). But her main points stand: First, since tyrants don’t derive their powers from the consent of the governed, they are not legitimately sovereign; second, nations should act in their own interests.
In a nutshell, Rand has outlined one aspect of the rhetorical divide between pro-war and anti-war conservatives. The pro-war side is wont to reference Saddam’s cruelties, barbarism, and oppression. The anti-war side wonders how combating the very real cruelties, barbarism, and oppression furthers American interests.
Saddam Hussein got his day in court. This is better than what he gave his regime's many victims. Whether it's all "theater" as the gaunt defendant claimed at today's hearing, the public trial will show one way or the other. Amidst America's loss of lives, treasure, and credibility--and gain of next to nothing in its concrete national interest--the ouster of Saddam Hussein stands as one positive outcome of the war. Murder by the state is one of the great unpunished crimes of any, but particularly of our, age. Saddam's trial, and its expected outcome, should have a chilling effect on the killings and repression of other would-be tyrants.
The Irish counterpart to the American Civil Liberties Union is claiming the Republic's prohibition on polygamy is racist and violates the rights of Muslims. A spokeswoman for the Irish Council on Civil Liberties claims that an Irish law that requires Islamic immigrants to attest to having one spouse before gaining entry into the country "assumes that Muslims, irrespective of whether they come from secular societies or states that do not recognise polygamy, do not understand or would not respect the normal law of the land because they are 'different.'"
But Muslims are not merely "different." They are different. Muslims believe in polygamy, which is illegal in Ireland. Muslim immigrants to Ireland have sought to reject the rules of Ireland regarding marriage, and live by their own code. Your laws and rules don't necessarily immigrate with you when you arrive in a new land.
If proscribing polygamy is racist, what other unsavory aspects of foreign cultures must we respect and codify? Are we racists for rejecting female clitorectomy? Must we now allow dowry killings among Indian immigrants? How about beheadings for Christian converts? Foot-binding? Human sacrifice? Cannibalism?
The Bush Administration's turnover of power to the interim Iraqi government two days early was a brilliant maneuver. Symbolically, it told the world that the transition is ahead of schedule. Concretely, it pulled the rug out from under any wave of terrorism that might have been planned for June 30. Historically, it lets the record show America had no imperial designs on Mesopotamia.
The return of sovereignty to Iraqis might be best seen as a progression. There are more than 100,000 U.S. soldiers, sailors, airmen, and Marines still in Iraq. They didn't get to go home with Paul Bremer. A permanent constitution has yet to be ratified. National elections aren't scheduled until 2006. But with the handover, even though it's not a full handover, one hopes that future terrorist attacks in Iraq will be increasingly seen by the Arab world as attacks on the people of Iraq and not attacks on the United States.
I'm skeptical that a free, stable, and democratic society will emerge from an Iraq artificially constructed by colonial powers just seventy or so years ago, tormented by decades of brutal oppression, recovering from numerous recent wars, suffering from centuries of a backward cultural climate, and living under a faith largely inhospitable to self-government and religious pluralism. Here's hoping that I'm wrong.
My post on America's increasing view that going to war in Iraq was a mistake has become a minor point of debate in the blogosphere. Mike Krempasky and Tom Crowe have weighed in, and well, they don't like what I have to say--in some instances, they don't even like what they imagine me saying. Read their sites, and my response on Crowe's site to his piece, and judge for yourself.
On weapons of mass destruction, Krempasky admits: "Not a real issue for me, I wanted [Saddam] croaked on principle." First, Krempasky doesn't make policy. Those who did make the policy certainly thought WMD was a big issue--arguably the biggest issue--in making the case to invade Iraq. Second, Krempasky claims he wanted Saddam "croaked on principle." On what principle? There's a lot of world leaders that we'd be better off without. Is an evil tyrant running a country halfway around the world sufficient cause for sacrificing American lives and taxdollars in a nation-building scheme, particularly when more than 90 percent of that country's citizens see us as occupiers?
Tom Crowe reminds me of Kevin Bacon's ROTC-cadet character during the closing mayhem of Animal House. "Remain calm. All is well." Among his more curious statements are that the situation in Iraq is "hardly anarchy" and that "Iraqis are, in fact, now free." They're liberated from the butcher Hussein and better off, but free? I hope the future holds freedom for the Iraqis, but the present unfortunately doesn't. He calls Saddam Hussein "a benefactor of Al Qaeda" (Is this something you slip in a post without documentation?). Finally, he contends that charges of Iraqi WMD are "not our resposibility to prove."
And I guess that's my quarrel with supporters of the Iraq war in a nutshell. They believe it's not their responsibility to prove anything. From fantasies of a 9/11-Iraqi conspiracy to tales of Hussein attempting to purchase uranium from Niger to massive stockpiles of WMD that haven't been found and more importantly weren't used in the war, so many of the arguments for going to war collapse under the weight of facts--inconvenient facts, but facts nonetheless.
"In Darfur, [Sudan] there is no hunger," the Sudanese foreign minister told the Washington Post. "There is no malnutrition. There is no epidemic disease." Widespread hunger, he claimed, was "imagined" by members of the press.
One only wishes. In reality, it is Sudanese government officials, as documented in today's Post, whose imaginations have run wild.
In Sudan, there are more than a million displaced persons, vestiges of slavery, and several hundred-thousand dying of starvation or disease. Arab goons have destroyed 56,000 homes and killed 10,000 people in the last year and a half. A civil war has raged since the '80s. Be glad you don't live there.
Robert Mugabe's Zimbabwe has been engaged in an anti-white crusade for the past several years. Mugabe's policies have included governmental intimidation against English farmers and expropriation of white-owned property. Plan A, however, didn't work as well as anticipated. Plan B is outlined in a chilling document entitled, "Solution to the white problem."
The plan calls for the bombing of a significant target in Zimbabwe, which would be blamed on white terrorists. The government could then force whites to leave the country without incurring the wrath of international opinion.
"We realistically believe that expelling the British citizens will cause an 80 to 90 per cent drop in the (white) population within six months," the government document claims. "If implemented soon, we could be almost entirely free of them before the final run-up to the parliamentary elections."
Success breeds envy. Group success has bred bigotry against Jews, Huguenots, Chinese, and so many others around the world. Due north 1,000 or so miles from Zimbabwe is Uganda, which should have provided Mugabe a lesson in why not to attack groups producing wealth. In the early 1970s, Uganda seized the assets of, then deported, the community of Indian immigrants living there. In 1968, 96,000 Asians lived in Uganda. By 1973, about 1,000 remained. Uganda has yet to recover from its ill-fated experiment in creating wealth by destroying the wealth creators. Mugabe, apparently, is not a quick study.
When Zimbabwe solves its white "problem," perhaps it will be compelled to finally face its Mugabe problem.
An affiliate of al Qaeda released pictures today showing that they had beheaded American hostage Paul Johnson. What else can you say, except that these people are barbarians. Some of Johnson's suspected killers, thankfully, no longer ply their nefarious trade.
The terrorist group threatened the grisly execution unless Saudi Arabia released al Qaeda prisoners and all Americans departed the country. Knowing that these demands wouldn't and couldn't be met, the terrorists chopped off Johnson's head. The group released a statement that the beheading should be "a lesson for them to learn for whoever comes to our country, this will be their punishment."
More than half the world's immigrants are leaving predominantly Muslim nations, yet when a handful of non-Muslims work in a Muslim nation it creates a xenophobic frenzy. In addition to the xenophobia present in many Muslim states is a proclivity to engage in warfare. Samuel Huntington pointed out in The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of the World Order that although followers of Islam constituted about a sixth of the world's population, they found themselves in the 1990s involved in more than half the world's wars. Based on observation, Muslims seem to be disproportionately involved in terrorism as well.
Whereas Christians seek to convert non-believers, many Muslims gain satisfaction by simply killing them. "The Koran and other statements of Muslim beliefs contain few prohibitions on violence," Huntington notes, "and a concept of nonviolence is absent from Muslim doctrine and practice."
So how do we prevent violence--like the murder of Paul Johnson--from occuring in the future? Discarding our naivety about our enemies--e.g., Islam is a religion of peace--seems a good first step. Their culture is not like ours, and approaching regional problems with Western solutions (democracy, free-market economies, religious tolerance) will not work as long as Islamic nations revel in their backwardness and savagery. Uprooting fourteen-hundred years of tradition doesn't happen overnight, nor is it a realistic endeavor for the West to undertake.
"The underlying problem for the West is not Islamic fundamentalism," Huntington asserts. "It is Islam, a different civilization whose people are convinced of the superiority of their culture and are obsessed by the inferiority of their power."
Conservatives carrying on about Iraq-9/11 connections are beginning to sound like Miss Havisham ranting about her wedding dress. They just can't let go.
Articles by Stephen Hayes in the Weekly Standard and Andrew McCarthy on National Review Online read more like the headspinning pieces you might see in The New American about the Bilderbergers and the Trilateral Commission running the world. It's conspiracy theory stuff that cites the absence of proof as proof, demands the opposition prove negatives, relies on unfounded assertions as premises, and invents dots when the existing ones don't connect to make the right picture.
In a preview of his book The Connection, Stephen Hayes posits that an Iraqi intelligence agent may have helped plan the 9/11 attacks. Let's get Hayes's story straight: a man named Ahmed Hikmat Shakir, who may or may not have been the same Ahmed Hikmat Shakir in the Fedayeen Saddam, was in Kuala Lumpur and may or may not have attended a meeting there with three of the 9/11 terrorists. Based on this, Hayes writes: "The Shakir story is perhaps the government's strongest indication that Saddam and al Qaeda may have worked together on September 11." This information is worth investigating, but at this point Hayes doesn't commit to it being the same man, doesn't know if Shakir attended the meeting, doesn't know what was said at the meeting (although one needn't be a conspiracy theorist to imagine), and doesn't know if the man shared information from the meeting with Saddam Hussein.
Other "evidence" forwarded in the brief is similarly unpersuasive:
* Hayes quotes a 1999 "report on the psychology of terrorism" that speculates that Saddam and al Qaeda might work together in the future. Wow, that's convincing stuff!
* Hayes points to the alleged meeting of Mohammed Atta with an Iraqi intelligence agent in Prague. But U.S. intelligence has been unable to corroborate this story and even the Czech government--the sole source of the claim--has backed away from it.
* Hayes cites Bill Clinton's ill-fated bombing of a medicine factory in Sudan--widely panned as a "wag the dog" scenario at the time--as further proof of an Iraqi-al Qaeda tie. He notes, "at least six top Clinton administration officials have defended on the record the strikes in Sudan by citing a link to Iraq." (Might these be the same people who assured us that Bill Clinton "didn't have sex with that woman"?) But evidence that the al Shifa plant even manufactured chemical weapons rather than pharmaceuticals is scant at best. If it hasn't been proven that the Sudanese target made chemical weapons, what would a connection to Iraq prove?
The Weekly Standard piece is heavy on charges, but short on proof. Add a whole bunch of zeroes and you get a whole lot of nothing.
As poorly argued as the Stephen Hayes piece is, Andrew McCarthy's article on National Review Online is even worse. He assails the "pigheaded blindness" that moves "breathtakingly irresponsible" journalists and intelligence analysts to dismiss connections between Saddam Hussein's Iraq and al Qaeda terror.
Since the NRO piece relies on the "assiduous detective work" of Hayes, we don't need to explore territory we already crossed in Part I. But it is worth specifically looking at one of McCarthy's claims.
"Even if there were absolutely no other evidence of the Prague meeting than the Czech eyewitness identification corroborated by the appointment calendar, the inability to account for Atta's whereabouts on April 8, and the means he appears to have had to travel," he writes, "that would be reason enough, for national-security purposes, to assume an Iraqi tie to Atta." No, actually it wouldn't. We have our own intelligence and they are not persuaded by the story of the phantom Prague meeting, and the inability to track Atta's location on April 8 doesn't mean that he was in the Czech Republic.
Employing the twisted logic that led to the preemptive war that preempted nothing, McCarthy conjects: "we need to assume guilt until we are satisfied otherwise."
"I don't pretend to have the answers," McCarthy admits, "but it sure looks to me like Saddam was in cahoots with al Qaeda and that his regime may well have rendered assistance--probably very substantial assistance--to the 9/11 plot." When you find evidence to support this belief, do let the rest of us know.
When I want wild conspiracy theories I'll watch The X-Files. I expect better from two of the most widely-read publications of American conservatism.
Who has a longer life expectancy at this point: Johnny Sack from The Sopranos, or newly appointed interim Iraqi President Sheikh Ghazi al-Yawar? President of Iraq now has to rank up there in danger with snake charmer, suicide bomber, and parachute tester. I think the label "interim" is a bit redundant considering his position.
The Saudi Arabian hostage standoff has ended. If you're keeping score, the Saudi government and the terrorists disagree on the particulars. A website linked to the terrorists claims that most of the kidnappers escaped and, "The holy warriors didn't leave any of the hostages alive. All those infidels and Crusaders who were in their hands were liquidated." The Saudis say that they killed the terrorists and that only as many as sixteen hostages died in the standoff and rescue.
While the results of the assault are in dispute, the radical Islamists' intentions are clear. The terrorists allegedly told one man living in the compound, "We only want to hurt Westerners and Americans. Can you tell us where we can find them here?" Another explained: "They said, 'You are American,' and I told them I am an American Muslim. They said, 'We do not kill Muslims.'" In addition to being killers, the terrorists are liars too. Several Muslims, including a ten-year-old Egyptian boy, were killed in the raid.
The religion of peace strikes again. This time they attack from the mecca--so to speak--of the religion of peace. Saudi Arabian gunmen felled several people, including an American, and took dozens of hostages. Apparently, the terrorists are now attempting to separate the Muhammedans from the folks who don't practice the religion of peace. Since the captors subscribe to the tenets of the religion of peace, the captives need not worry.
Taking after their most famous fellow countryman's love for animals, Austria has passed a stringent new animals rights law. Among other things, the bill outlaws caging chickens, using lions at circuses, and placing puppies in hot pet-shop windows. Austrian Chancellor Wolfgang Schuessel maintains, "Austria is taking the role of pioneer." Pioneer of what? Foolishness?
Someone named Andreas Sax, who leads an animal rights group called Four Paws, calls the law "the first step in the right direction." What are steps two, three, and four? Legalizing interspecies marriage, banning animal crackers, and making humans the pets of dogs?
The pot is calling the kettle black. The Arab League has denounced the United States for "crimes and inhumane and immoral practices" in Iraq.
The only thing that seem to arouse the humanity of Arab leaders, curiously, are the abuses at Abu Ghraib prison. Egypt, Pakistan, and Jordan, for instance, offer leniency to perpetrators of "honor killings." An independent press free from government meddling is illegal in nearly every Arab and Islamic country. Sudanese Muslims enslave about 100,000 non-Muslim Sudanese. Converting to Christianity is punishible by beheading in Saudi Arabia and Kuwait. Anyone who follows the news could probably list numerous other offenses against the dignity of mankind that occur by force of law in Muslim nations.
Some only recognize human rights abuses when the oppressors come from one group and the oppressed from another. So, the mistreatment of Africans at the hands of white settlers in Rhodesia or South Africa sends such people into a fury, but their mistreatment by, say, Idi Amin or Mengistu Haile Mariam elicits yawns. Oppressors and oppressed come in all skin shades, and often times share the same ethnicity.
Human rights activist Paul Marshall finds the Arab world's horror at Abu Ghraib hypocritical, and notes in an article today that "members of the Arab League should be questioned, exposed, challenged, mocked, pilloried, castigated, shamed, and humiliated for their vile abdication of any real human responsibility."
Seriously guys, look in the mirror.
Novelist Tom Clancy has come out as a skeptic of the war in Iraq. The co-author with General Anthony Zinni of a new nonfiction book, Battle Ready, also revealed that he nearly threw down with neoconservative hawk Richard Perle.
"He was saying how (Secretary of State) Colin Powell was being a wuss because he was overly concerned with the lives of the troops," maintained the author of The Hunt for Red October, Patriot Games, and other bestsellers. "And I said, 'Look ..., he's supposed to think that way!' And Perle didn't agree with me on that. People like that worry me."
They worry me too.
Iraq, Marine general Anthony Zinni declared on Hardball, was a "blunder."
"I think they misled [Bush] on what to expect--the rationale, the elements for the strategy, to the situation on the ground," Zinni said of Bush's advisors. "It wasn't going to be a pie-in-the-sky welcome in the streets with flowers." If anyone would know this, it would be Zinni. A combat veteran, Zinni led American forces in the Middle East and served as President Bush's envoy to the region.
Hardball host Chris Matthews asks: "If we were misled in terms of how easy it would be for us to go into Iraq? Who should be accountable? [Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence Stephen] Cambone, [Undersecretary of Defense for Policy Douglas] Feith, [Deputy Defense Secretary Paul] Wolfowitz, Rumsfeld?
General Zinni answers: "Somebody ought to be held accountable. The president, the country, and the troops weren't served well. Why not all of them?"
Why not?
Up north, Canada's ruling government has called for new elections. This comes at a very inopportune time. Since the beginning of the year, support for the Liberal Party has dropped 23% in the polls. While it's unlikely the Conservatives will overtake the Liberals, the Liberals will almost certainly lose seats in Parliament (I am of course referring here to a legislative Parliament, and not Parliament-Funkadelic). Canada's elections will be held June 28.
When the former police chief for your entire nation gets arrested on charges of smuggling cocaine, it's generally considered a sign that your country is really, really corrupt.
George Will, onetime Iraq war cheerleader, today leads a chorus of boo-birds. Last week, Will aired his second thoughts about the war. Now, he goes even further with his criticism of the Bush administration in his latest column that ponders whether Donald Rumsfeld should resign as secretary of defense.
"[W]ho lost his or her job because the president's 2003 State of the Union address gave currency to a fraud — the story of Iraq's attempting to buy uranium in Niger?" Will asks. "Or because the primary and only sufficient reason for waging preemptive war — weapons of mass destruction — was largely spurious? Or because postwar planning, from failure to anticipate the initial looting to today's insufficient force levels, has been botched? Failures are multiplying because of choices for which no one seems accountable."
Count Tucker Carlson in as another figure on the political Right having second thoughts about the war in Iraq.
"I think it’s a total nightmare and disaster, and I’m ashamed that I went against my own instincts in supporting it," Carlson told the New York Observer. "It’s something I’ll never do again. Never. I got convinced by a friend of mine who’s smarter than I am, and I shouldn’t have done that. No. I want things to work out, but I’m enraged by it, actually."
James Robbins on National Review Online nails the difference between the terrorists' beheading of Nick Berg and the actions of the sadistic American prison guards. Aside from the obvious difference in the scale of the crimes, Robbins notes that one group looks upon their activities with pride; the other, with shame. "The outrages at Abu Ghraib were not sanctioned by higher authorities, and were halted when they were discovered," Robbins points out. "The terrorists on the other hand killed Nicholas Berg while executing their official policy."
Brazil's Marxist leader has expelled respected New York Times reporter Larry Rohter from the nation. Rohter penned an article noting that the drinking of President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva has effected his governance.
"It's not for a president to respond to such a piece of stupidity," Lula remarked. He responded anyhow by revoking Rohter's visa. Complicating things for Rohter is that he is married to a Brazilian woman and lives in the nation. He has a week to get out.
Brazil has grown increasingly anti-American since Lula's ascension to the presidency. A 2003 poll showed that only 43% of Brazilians hold a favorable view of the United States.
Terrorists posted a video showing Islamic extremists decapitating the head of Nick Berg. An American civilian, Berg had apparently travelled to Iraq to spread knowledge regarding technology.
In the video, Berg's murderer shouts "God is great!" and then beheads his victim. If this is the kind of thing that impresses your god, it's time to get a new religion.
As the nation is bombarded with ugly pictures of American soldiers engaging in disgusting conduct, we should also remember that an American soldier put a stop to the abuse at Abu Ghraib.
The prisoner abuse scandal is revolting and reflects poorly on the United States. In an interesting piece in the Boston Globe, Cathy Young shows how the scandal (or at least the reaction to it) also, "in a perverse way," demonstrates how great a country America is.
"It is almost as much of a cliche--and equally true--to say that this story reveals, in a perverse way, the strength of American democracy," Young writes. "Under Hussein, torture (far more extreme than anything done by the American soldiers) was the normal way of doing things. Under American rule, it is a scandal that calls for punishment for the culprits, a contrite speech by the president of the United States, and many voices urging the resignation of the secretary of defense. Under the American occupation, Iraqis can gather outside the prison to protest the abuse. Under Hussein, even whispering about it to friends and family was dangerous."
After making obligatory condemnations of the prisoner abuse scandal, Midge Decter declares it a "tempest in a teapot." Her New York Post article proclaims: "This new scandal is no more than an election-season opportunity seized by certain serious opponents of the war, along with many more unserious opponents of the Bush administration."
Reports of prisoners killed in U.S. custody, sodomized by guards, and attacked by vicious dogs aren't an "ersatz scandal." This is a real scandal. To find the truth, the charges need to be investigated--by elected officials, the military, the media, and others. The American people aren't tricked, they're disgusted--and their disgust manifests itself in the falling esteem in which they hold the leader that got us into the mess in Iraq.
The Arab world's feigned horror at the abuse of prisoners is hypocritical. They've yawned at far worse. But the disgust in the West is real. The United States is, and should be, held to a higher standard than Iraq's previous ruler.
Midge Decter doesn't get it.
In a piece in Monday's New York Post, Decter juxtaposes the Civil War's massive body count with the triple-digit death toll among Americans in Iraq. Contemporary Americans going wobbly over Iraq, this contrast seems to suggest, shames our ancestors who endured much worse.
And they did, but the Civil War was a contest fought over things worth fighting for--union or independence, freedom or slavery--worth dying for.
What are our young men and women dying for in Iraq? To combat mythic Iraqi connections to 9/11, a barely-existent nuclear weapons program, and weapons of mass destruction that Iraqis couldn't find when their country was invaded (for the same reason that Americans can't find them now that they have overrun Hussein's armies).
Decter contends that "an outcry is being staged--and 'staged' is the word--over casualties amounting to a few hundred" in Iraq. But this outcry isn't "staged." And the anger isn't because "a few hundred" Americans are dead. Americans are dying in pursuit of terrorists in Afghanistan, for instance, but nobody but the lunatic fringe opposes that military action.
The deaths of our soldiers, sailors, airmen, and Marines will always bother Americans. When those deaths serve vital national interests, we mourn but understand.
Americans are willing to fight and die for things worth fighting and dying for. Abstractions like nation building, righting all the world's wrongs, and imposing Western democracy on a people who either don't want it or aren't ready for it don't meet that basic criterion.
It's why Americans die in Iraq, not simply that they die, that outrages so many Americans.
We gave our blood. Where's our oil?
Prior to the war in Iraq, some of its more idiotic opponents cast the imminent conflict as a massive oil grab. Today, oil stands at its highest price since 1990.
Chile began the process of legalizing divorce. On Friday, President Ricardo Lagos signed the law that would begin allowing divorce in the South American country six months from now. The law makes divorce easier, but not easy. Couples seeking to terminate their marriage have to go through sixty days of counseling, and separate for a year before the state grants their wish. If only one spouse seeks divorce, the couple has to wait three years.
Two Catholics angered at the Madrid performance of a blasphemous play entitled In God We S@#! stormed the stage and beat up the production's director and an actor. "They beat us, they destroyed the music equipment, and they tried to set fire to the set, which is made of loo paper," the play's author complained. "The audience thought it was part of the play so no one helped us for ages."
George Will has joined the editors of National Review in re-thinking the war in Iraq. Specifically, Will takes aim at the fetish among some neoconservatives that democracy can take root in any culture no matter the climate or soil. I'm speaking metaphorically, of course.
In other words, the idea that there were a bunch of latter-day James Madisons and Thomas Jeffersons floating around Hussein's Baghdad just waiting to institute a constitutional republic if only the Americans overthrew their oppressor was pie-in-the-sky stuff. Bush, Will suggests, needs to rethink his foreign policy.
"Being steadfast in defense of carefully considered convictions is a virtue," Will writes. "Being blankly incapable of distinguishing cherished hopes from disappointing facts, or of reassessing comforting doctrines in face of contrary evidence, is a crippling political vice."
A few days after Rene Gonzalez's disgusting rant, cartoonist Ted Rall has published a despicable comic strip suggesting American hero Pat Tillman is an "idiot." Tillman, you will remember, exercised his rights as a free agent to sign with the U.S. Army rather than the Arizona Cardinals. He was killed ten days ago in Afghanistan fighting the war on terrorism.
Rall depicts Tillman as "a cog in a low-rent occupation army that shot more innocent civilians than terrorists to prop up puppet rulers and exploit gas and oil resources." (The war is in Afghanistan, not Saudi Arabia or Venezuela. What "gas and oil resources"?)
"Never mind the fine print," the cartoon Tillman asks his military recruiter. "Will I get to kill Arabs?" Based on nothing, Rall portrays Tillman as a homocidal racist. Similarly, Rene Gonzalez decided of Pat Tillman: "I could tell he was that type of macho guy, from his scowling, beefy face on the CNN pictures."
Both Rall and Gonzalez live in a delusional world where their own fantasies rather than the facts dictate how they view people. Pat Tillman volunteered to fight the war on terrorism, their thinking goes, therefore he must fit the racist, macho, killer stereotype that my imagination believes my ideological opponents to be. By all accounts, Tillman was anything but that. Rall and Gonzalez's hateful and ignorant expressions reveal far more about them than they do about Pat Tillman.
One year ago today, President Bush famously landed on the USS Abraham Lincoln and declared "mission accomplished." If we accomplished what we set out to do, then why are we still in Iraq?
More than a year after the start of the war, life is better for Iraqis. But is this why we fight wars, to make life better for other people?
Wars aren't social programs. People die. The reasons for going to war should be strong and not based on some Pentagon scribbler's elaborate plan to remake whole nations in America's image.
We know now that Hussein's Iraq had no real nuclear weapons program. The menacing chemical and biological weapons of mass destruction haven't been found. Connections to al Qaeda proved more fantasy than reality. In other words, the stated reasons for going to war have proven false.
Worse, more Americans have died in Iraq since the President declared "mission accomplished" than in the actual war itself. With 136 American deaths, this past month was the war's bloodiest. Americans elsewhere in the region, as today's events remind us, are increasingly viewed as targets.
President Bush says he stands by his "mission accomplished" speech. If the job is done, bring the boys home. If it's not, please inform us what our mission in Iraq is now that Saddam is gone, WMDs proved chimerical, and the Iraqi people's capacity for self-government seems less than advertised.
More than two centuries ago, Americans fought to gain freedom, untether their links to a foreign power, and forge a new nation. Today, Europeans fight to join a union that erodes freedom, takes decisions further from the people, and erases national identity.
Ten new countries joined the European Union today. This has millions cheering; not me.
Matt Drudge excerpts some poignant remarks from Vaclav Klaus, the only leader of a new EU country who refused to support entry into the confederation. Klaus is the elected leader of the Czech Republic, a country steeped in tradition and architectural beauty. Let's hope it remains a republic; let's hope it remains its own country.
In France, three brothers petitioned that nation's courts to ban The Passion of the Christ. Opponents of the film were more successful in Bahrain, where the government banned the movie two weeks ago. In Burma, Christian children have been reportedly forced to become Buddhist monks, and crosses are being removed from Christian villages. In Russia, where the last remaining independent television network has gone off the air, the parliament gave its initial endorsement to a bill that would effectively ban most public protests.
Thank God for the U.S. Constitution and its First Amendment. We can still say what we want, worship whatever God we care to, demonstrate for any cause, and use the airwaves, Internet, and printed word to challenge the powerful--and the federal government can't do a thing about it.
At least eight Americans were killed in two separate attacks in Iraq today.
In a scene reminiscent of Black Hawk Down, Iraqis dragged the bodies of dead Americans through the streets of Fallujah. The mob hung several corpses on a bridge over the Euphrates. Others beat a dead body with sticks and other objects. The crowd chanted and cheered as they desecrated the corpses of the dead American civilians. "I am happy to see this," one twelve-year-old boy remarked. "The Americans are occupying us so this is what will happen."
Outside of Baghdad, a bomb killed five U.S. soldiers. An M113 armored personnel carrier apparently ran over the explosive device as the convoy it was traveling in passed through Malahma.
The killings on this last day of March bring the month's death-toll for U.S. servicemen to 48. Next to the 82 deaths that occurred in November, March stands as the deadliest month for Americans since President Bush declared victory in Iraq on May 1. Of the 600 or so Marines, soldiers, airmen, and sailors that have died in the conflict, 459 have lost their lives since the "end" of the war.
Tell me why, again, giving these people the vote is such a great idea.
Terrorism works.
Need proof? Last week, terrorists believed to be linked to al Qaeda set off a series of bombings in Madrid. The carnage came just days before Spain's elections. What polls indicated would be a comfortable victory for conservatives transformed into a socialist upset. The bombings, Spaniards widely believed, were payback for the conservative government's support for the war in Iraq. Shortly after the elections, new prime minister Jose Luis Rodriguez Zapatero announced his intention to withdraw Spanish troops from Iraq.
After last week's bloodbath at the hands of Islamic terrorists, and the ensuing show of national pride, I figured the Spanish people would be ready to vote for Richard the Lionheart had his name appeared on the ballot. I was mistaken.
Without bribes, campaign contributions, or even running their own candidate, a small but determined group of fanatics was able to oust an entire government and shift a nation's policy to something more amenable to their objectives. While it is not unwise to discard a policy that a nation deems harmful, there is something terribly unsettling about accommodating the wishes of terrorists.
Throw a dog a bone and he doesn't leave satisfied. He comes back for more.
A day after anonymous cowards killed 199 rail commuters through a series of backpack bombs during Madrid's rush hour, an estimated 11 million people--one quarter of the nation's population--marched in cities across Spain. We don't know yet who is responsible for this act of barbarism. We do know that the Spanish people have taught the world a great lesson about vigilance in the face of terror.
A former staffer to four members of Congress was charged yesterday with acting as a paid agent of Saddam Hussein's regime. Did anybody really need confirmation of this sad woman's party affiliation?
A State Department official told the Senate Foreign Relations Committee on Wednesday that the number of U.S. troops in Haiti will increase yet again. Just a few weeks ago, the Bush administration announced that they would send a "team" of Marines to protect the U.S. embassy. Within days, this "team" included more than 1,000 members. Shortly thereafter, the Bush Administration declared that the 1,000 Marines would double to 2,000 Marines. Now we are informed that U.S. forces in the impoverished nation will more than double from the current 1,600 to nearly 3,500. Looks like fuzzy math to me.
Europe is moving rightward. This weekend, conservatives defeated the Left in Greece. In Austria's Carinthia province, Joerg Haider's Freedom Party shocked observers by vanquishing socialists at the ballot box. The victory ensures that the troubling Haider will retake his position as the province's governor. The results in Greece and Austria follow victories by the Right in Portugal, Italy, and elsewhere on the continent in recent years. In less than a week, Spanish conservatives are expected to take the parliamentary elections.
Why are these diverse parties of the Right gaining popularity in liberal Europe? Voters are sick of economies ruined by overbearing bureaucracies, the increasingly powerful European Union diminishing national sovereignty, and the radical alteration of native populations by waves of unlimited immigration.
"I wouldn't have sent troops to Haiti," candidate George W. Bush told moderator Jim Lehrer during his second debate with Al Gore. "I didn't think it was a mission worthwhile. It was a nation-building mission, and it was not very successful. It cost us billions--a couple billions of dollars, and I'm not so sure democracy's any better off in Haiti than it was before." President Bush, unfortunately, has "grown" in office.
Almost two weeks ago, the Bush administration announced that a "team" of Marines would be traveling to Haiti to protect the U.S. embassy. Today, 1,000 Marines are in Haiti; the number is expected to rise to as many as 2,000 within a few days.
"Part of our mission is to step in if we think there is a threat of bodily harm or deadly force to a (Haitian) citizen," explained one Marine. The Pentagon sees the mission as keeping the peace in Port-Au-Prince, delivering food and medicine, protecting American citizens, and ensuring that the nation holds elections.
President George W. Bush would be wise to heed the advice of Governor George W. Bush: "I don't think our troops ought to be used for what's called nation-building. I think our troops ought to be used to fight and win war."
Haiti is in the midst of its 33rd coup. At what number coup does nation-building begin to look like a bad idea to the architects of America's foreign policy? Coup number 37? Number 38?