14 / September
14 / September
Roberts Testimony: The Good

In response to Senator John Kyl's concerns about the trend of judges citing foreign laws to alter U.S. law, John Roberts outlined two problems with the use of international law to shape U.S. law. "If we're relying on a decision from a German judge about what our Constitution means, no president accountable to the people appointed that judge and no Senate accountable to the people confirmed that judge," Roberts noted. "And yet he's playing a role in shaping the law that binds the people in this country."

Roberts's second problem stemmed from the arbitrary nature of citing foreign law. "Domestic precedent can confine and shape the discretion of the judges," he observed. "Foreign law, you can find anything you want. If you don't find it in the decisions of France or Italy, it's in the decisions of Somalia or Japan or Indonesia or wherever. As somebody said in another context, looking at foreign law for support is like looking out over a crowd and picking out your friends. You can find them. They're there." Roberts scornfully noted that this "allows the judge to incorporate his or her own personal preferences, cloak them with the authority of precedent--because they're finding precedent in foreign law--and use that to determine the meaning of the Constitution."

In other words, don't expect to read Chief Justice John Roberts cite the "overwhelming weight of international opinion," as Justice Anthony Kennedy recently did.

posted at 12:46 AM
Comments
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?