29 / April
29 / April
Wild, Wild West

The reaction to the enactment of Arizona's new law empowering police to crackdown on illegal immigrants demonstrates the need for such a law. The lawless behavior of a Phoenix mob protesting the law and the refusal of an Arizona sheriff to enforce the new law is something straight out of Mexico, where cops are often lawbreakers and the rule of law isn't respected. Arizona doesn't want to be like Mexico. Can you blame them? The reaction also spotlights the contempt for order and the democratic process that characterizes Washington's attitude toward illegal immigration. There are fine federal immigration laws that would make Arizona's legislation unnecessary if only Washington would enforce them. But they don't, and have the gall to cry foul when Arizona attempts to solve the problem the feds don't bother to.

Epistemic Closure

Leave it to the New York Times to clue me in on an ongoing debate within the conservative movement. Julian Sanchez of the Cato Institute kicked off the debate, arguing that an "epistemic closure" has creeped into the conservative movement. This means something to the effect that the creation of parallel information outlets to the mainstream media has proliferated factually suspect but ideologically convienient beliefs among conservatives.

I prefer my term "intellectual moron"--it rolls off the tongue better than "epistemic closure"--but I guess Sanchez's argument calls for a hifalutin rather than a populist term. That said, I agree with Sanchez's general point (which in fairness seems related to, rather than the same, as the pod-people point I made in Intellectual Morons). His point is not wrong but late--Austin Bramwell and others made this point during the Bush Administration, when the problem was actually worse. The chain of falsehoods embraced by talk radio, the blogosphere, and talking heads to rationalize the unprovoked invasion of Iraq was the moment when the phenomenon became real to me. Even after the Bush administration cried uncle on WMD, their votaries refused to give up the ghost. Alas, better late than never on recognizing a pernicious trend.

Milton Friedman, Russell Kirk, and William F. Buckley are dead, and it seems next to impossible for anyone of their intellectual gravitas to get heard without undermining their intellectual gravitas. I can't picture Kirk tweeting. I can't picture rising conservatives reading Kirk's The Conservative Mind. Blame txtng, television's omnipresence, the marginalization of books, etc. If you must blame conservatives for this, blame them for not "standing athwart history yelling stop."

Ironically, the most insightful observation in the Times piece on "epistemic closure" comes from David Frum, a man who I have criticized before and who was a prominent sufferer of "epistemic closure" during the Iraq debate. [Correction: Actually, the quote comes from a friend of Frum's] Conservative intellectuals are "the ones who are supposed to uphold intellectual standards, to sift actual facts from what you call 'pretend information,'" Frum explains. "Rush Limbaugh isn't any worse than he was 20 years ago. But 20 years ago, conservatism offered something more than Rush Limbaugh. Since then, the conservative elite has collapsed. Blame them, not talk radio." I like Limbaugh, but I think it reveals the decline of the movement that the perception of the talk radio king has gone from from popularizer to intellectual. In the former role, there is no better; in the latter, iceberg ahead!

The obvious retort to all this is that from muttering nonsense about how 1 in 4 women are raped to embracing kooks who allege Bush knew of 9/11 in advance, the epistemic closure on the Left has always been exponentially worse. Point granted. But since when did conservatives hold liberals up as a standard? We are supposed to be the independent thinkers, not the drones. Unfortunately, in taking the necessary step of setting up alternative outlets to the mainstream media, those outlets have often become negative images of the mainstream media. "Whoever fights monsters should see to it that in the process he does not become a monster," Nietzsche observed. "And if you gaze long enough into an abyss, the abyss will gaze back into you." Has this, to some extent, taken place within movement conservatism?

There is a place in a conservative movement for talk radio hosts, bloggers, and talking heads. Having played all of those roles, I would be a hypocrite, and a snob, to exclude them. But that place isn't to smother, or crowd out, conservatives who prefer original ideas to slogans, principle to party, and substance to style. In too many instances, this has happened over the course of the last decade.

28 / April
28 / April
Cult of Kennedy

The federal government has already allocated almost $40 million to fund an Edward M. Kennedy Institute for the U.S. Senate in Boston. Massachusetts representatives seek about $30 million more in the next budget. Read my piece @ the American Spectator, which asks why, with all of the money the Kennedys have and all of the money the Kennedys can rave, must the votaries of the late senator take from the taxpayer.

Wearing Out Their Welcome Fast

Republicans consistently beat Democrats in Rasmussen's generic congressional ballot. Republican voters hold a 20-point edge in Gallup's measuring of the enthusiasm gap. The president's disapproval rating eclipses his approval rating. The economy stagnates, the Democrats control the strings of power, the young people and African Americans who voted overwhelmingly for the president aren't consistent voters--it doesn't take Charlie Cook to figure out this is going to be a bad year for Democrats. Even Paul Cook could tell you that.

27 / April
27 / April
Border Politics

A new Rasmussen poll shows that an overwhelming majority of Americans support Arizona's new law allowing local police to check citizenship status of suspected illegal aliens. The chasm between elite opinion and mainstreet opinion is massive on this issue. In Arizona, 70 percent support the new law while 23 percent oppose. The may have some interesting ramifications nationally. As President Obama hopes to provide amnesty to illegal aliens, the overwhelming public opposition to the proposal presents problems similar to those presented by the president's unpopular health-care legislation. This may actually hurt President Obama's 2008 rival even more. John McCain once made himself the face of amnesty for illegal aliens. That position, wildly popular among the media elites he then courted, is wildly unpopular among GOP primary voters he must now court. McCain finds himself before such primary voters in his internecine battle with J.D. Hayworth, an articulate conservative whose positions more closely mesh with Republican voters than the man Republicans nominated for president just two years ago. Hayworth has been gaining on McCain. This may be the wedge issue that pushes him over the top. The former talk radio host is still the underdog. But can't we now say that he is a live dog?

Extra! Extra! Newspapers Are Dead

How to feel about the decline in newspaper readership? On the one hand, even with the transition to online over paper reader, it's hard not to interpret the startling declines in newspaper readership to the startling decline in reading. On the other hand, businesses that habitually insult their consumers deserve to lose those consumers. Locally, the Boston Globe has dubbed its readers racists for not supporting bussing, homophobic for rejecting gay marriage, and dumb for not going along with faddish environmental theories on global warming. Unsurprisingly, the struggling Globe--which I delivered to doors in my neighborhood for more than five years--lost 23 percent of its weekday readers over the last six months. This contrasts with a 9 percent loss nationally. If newspapers wish to dismiss the message their former readers are sending them, let them fail. Other liberal broadsheets fared poorly: the Washington Post down 13 percent, the Los Angeles Times down 14 percent, and the San Fransico Chronicle down 23 percent. Of the top 25 daily newspapers, only the Wall Street Journal gained readership.

26 / April
26 / April
Ex-Americans

The number of people who renounced their American citizenship in 2009 was more than three-times the number from the previous year. When I think about Americans renouncing their citizenship, the image of the old and bitter Communist W.E.B. Du Bois heading to Ghana comes to mind. But this article from the New York Times suggests that U.S. tax laws, not anti-Americanism, is the primary motivation behind expats leaving their American citizenship behind.

22 / April
22 / April
Mother Earth's Carbon Footprint Is a Size ∞

Mother Earth doesn't celebrate the holy day with which some humans have honored her. Rather than take part in cathartic activities such as planting trees or making a compost pile, Mother Earth has decided to spend Earth Day polluting the environment. Iceland's volcano has sent sulfur, carbon, and other unpleasant emissions into the atmosphere. The natural phenomenon of volcano eruptions can alter climate in ways that all the SUV drivers in the world cannot.

21 / April
21 / April
Worth Repeating #123

"When you're seventeen you know everything. When you're twenty-seven if you still know everything you're still seventeen."
--Ray Bradbury, Dandelion Wine, 1957

20 / April
20 / April
The Temple of Ted

Ted Kennedy's former senate colleagues have siphoned more than $30 million from the federal budget to fund what the Boston Herald accurately terms a "shrine" for the late Senator. The backers of the Temple of Ted hope to make off with about $70 million before the end of the year. Ask not what you can do for your country. Ask what your country can do for the Kennedys.

Perfection in the Ring; Failure at Life

The most dangerous place for boxers is outside of the ring. The exciting Edwin Valero, whose 27-0 record with 27 knockouts was the most impressive in the sport, killed himself in a Venezuelan jail after alleging killing his wife. Never trust a man who tatoos another man's face on his chest--especially when that other man is Hugo Chavez. The suicide of Valero, arguably the most exciting up-and-coming fighter in boxer, joins a lengthy list of recent high-profile boxer deaths, including those of Diego Corrales (motorcycle accident) and Arturo Gatti (murder? suicide?)--the two most crowd-pleasing fighters of the last decade. Edwin Valero was perfect in the ring. Outside of the ropes--not so much.

19 / April
19 / April
4 of 5 Americans Don't Trust the Federal Government

In poll results befitting the 235th anniversary of the original Patriots Day, the Pew Research Center reports that 78 percent of Americans don't trust Washington. Do the remaining 22 percent work for the government?

Replaying the 1990s

Bill Clinton demagogued the Oklahoma City Bombing to great political effect in 1995. If only the event had occurred before rather than after the 1994 elections, Democrats might have held Congress. That idea seems to be the motivation behind the base campaign to portray American citizens who vocally object to the president's program of expanding government as militia members itching to get their hands on a Ryder truck, blasting caps, and a whole lot of ammonium nitrate.

Fifteen years after Oklahoma City, Bill Clinton is still at it. Nevermind that in the intervening years Islamic terrorists have killed thousands of Americans at home and abroad. Liberals like their terrorists American.

Unfortunately for the tired meme tying mainstream conservative activism to anti-government terrorism, there have not been any homegrown acts of terrorism of the Tim McVeigh variety since outraged Americans began throwing tea parties and crashing town halls. So, without evidence buttressing their insinuations, they cart out the corpse of Tim McVeigh to bolster the notion that the peaceful protests of tea partiers will necessarily lead to violence. Rachel Maddow will be airing a bizarrely timed special on Tim McVeigh tonight. History interests me, so I'll watch. But history that serves as a brickbat for present-day political disputes isn't history. It's politics.

This liberal storyline of right-wing terrorists threatening the country began one year ago, when Homeland Security chief Janet Napolitano highlighted the dangers of "rightwing extremist activity" in a government report. Since that ill-advised prognostication, the activities of rightwing extremists have been of the peaceful variety--speaking out at townhall meetings, electing Republicans, organizing tea parties. If only they could get one of these tea partiers, or someone who knows a tea partier, or someone who knows someone who knows a tea partier, to bomb a federal building--even stink bomb a federal building--then they wouldn't have to tie an act of terrorism from the past to a political movement very much in the present. Just think of how many were willing to jump to the conclusion that a Census worker who killed himself really was murdered by anti-government extremists.

"Facts are stubborn things; and whatever may be our wishes, our inclinations, or the dictates of our passion, they cannot alter the state of facts and evidence," John Adams argued 240 years ago. Better watch it. Quoting a Founding Father might get my name on a right-wing extremist list.

15 / April
15 / April
America Is In A Ron Paul Mood

The Rasmussen poll showing a hypothetical Barack Obama-Ron Paul presidential contest a dead heat (42-41) says as much about the country as it does about Ron Paul. There has been a seismic shift in American thinking as a result of the bailouts, stimulus package, and welfare/health care bill. America wasn't in a Ron Paul mood in 2008. It is now. When Congressman Paul launched his 2008 presidential bid, many compared the Ron Paul Revolution with the Buchanan Brigades. Similarities exist, but so does a glaring difference. Pat Buchanan was never a movement builder. There was no flood of Buchananite candidates in his candidacy's wake. Sure, the Buchanan Fence that was once ridiculed now stands. But it was essentially a one-man movement, which isn't a movement at all. In contrast, there are a slew of candidates inspired to run in 2010 in part by Ron Paul. Rand Paul's run for Senate in Kentucky, Rex Rammell's run for governor in Idaho, and Peter Schiff's run for Senate in Connecticut are conspicuous among those following in Paul's footsteps in 2010. Aside from the candidates there are the tea parties and raucus town halls, which are in some measure an outgrowth of Paul's message. In a strawpoll of Southern Republicans this past weekend, Paul came in one vote behind winner Mitt Romney. And at CPAC of all places, Paul actually won this year's straw vote. Republicans: act like it is still 2008 at your own risk.

14 / April
14 / April
Is It Irresponsible To Wonder If Polish President's Death Was An Accident?

Should we be dismissive of conspiracy theories involving people with a track record of being conspiracists? A Polish Member of Parliament suggests the Russian government repeatedly prevented Polish President Lech Kaczynski's plane from landing, which led to the deaths of Kaczynski and 94 other people. It's always too tempting to doubt ordinary deaths for extraordinary people. But conspiracy buffs, like broken clocks, are occasionally right. Here's a before-and-after of the conspirators in action a few years back. And who could forget Korean Airlines 007? Strangely, the Russians shot down the civilian aircraft whose passenger manifest included Georgia Democrat Congressman Larry McDonald, the chairman of the John Birch Society and perhaps the staunchest anticommunist in the House, and Idaho Republican Senator Steve Symms, also a staunch anticommunist who thankfully took another flight. Delivering the news to front porches in my neighborhood of the Soviets blasting KAL 007 out of the sky really instilled a healthy hatred for the Soviet Union. Now, the Evil Empire's progeny stands accused of complicity in the death of a head of state. Did they do it? Let's await evidence rather than speculation that massages our prejudice. Are the Russians capable of such misdeeds? Remember: Kaczynski's business in flying to Russia involved commemorating the 70th anniversary of the systematic mass-murder of 22,000 people--mostly Polish servicemen--by Stalin's henchmen. It took fifty years for the Soviet government to admit the truth about the Katyn Forest massacre. If there is something sinister to this airplane crash, don't bet on forthrightness by the Russians bringing it to light.

13 / April
13 / April
Enquiring Minds Want To Know

The National Enquirer was up for a Pulitzer. It didn't get it. A sure sign of the apocalypse has been averted. The checkout line tabloid broke the story that presidential candidate John Edwards partook in an adulterous affair that resulted in an illegitimate child. The rest of the media waited until Edwards' campaign for the presidency had ended to report the story.

The ostensible objection to the National Enquirer involves credibility. But from Gary Hart to John Edwards, the accuracy of their stories has been confirmed. When the Enquirer is wrong, it's generally money-lust that leads to errors. When the New York Times is wrong, it's generally ideology that blinds them to reality. Is the National Enquirer really less credible than, say, the New Republic? If ideological blinders cause you to judge the Soviet Union as having "the most democratic franchise yet devised in our world," the ideologically-driven media will give you a pass. But if out of a zeal to cash-in you falsely accuse a famous comedianne of public drunkeness, your reputation will forever be in tatters. Six of one, half a dozen of the other.

The real issue is decency. Sure, it's indecent to commit adultery while your wife suffers from terminal cancer. It's also indecent to chase a man into a public restroom. It's not as though the Enquirer confines its titillating reports to seekers of public office. Private citizens, albeit famous ones, are routinely harassed by the professional tabloid scolds.

What makes talk of a Pulitzer for the Enquirer plausible is the impact of the checkout line on the rest of the media. We increasingly find the sideshow of Tonya Harding, Joey Buttafuco, Tiger Woods, and Jon & Kate on the main stage. The lines are blurred. A substantial portion of cable news, talk radio, and even mainline dailies focuses upon tabloid fare. That's the business of media, which the Enquirer's sensationalistic headlines strongly suggest that it understands. With media outlets, particularly local dailies, bleeding money, following the Enquirer's lead seems a matter of survival.

Or is it? There was a strong market for publications like the National Enquirer because they filled a void. Now that everybody is doing it, the Enquirer's circulation has dropped from over 6 million to around 1 million. There may be more of a demand for gossip than ever. But there is also a greater supply of gossip than ever. The media outlets that carve out a niche, while retaining their dignity and decency, will endure. The ones that play follow the leader will eventually get trampled by the pack.

If they handed out Pulitzer's for influence, the Enquirer would win every year. All newspapers not committed to not becoming the National Enquirer eventually become the National Enquirer.

12 / April
12 / April
John Paul Stevens Retires

John Paul Stevens announced his retirement from the U.S. Supreme Court. Part of me is sad to see the High Court's most liberal member go. The Gerald Ford-appointee's presence on the bench was a 35-year reminder not to place trust in Republicans. Why can't Democrats blunder so monumentally in their judicial nominations? The retirements of Republican appointees Sandra Day O'Connor and David Souter have eroded the visceral sense of an opportunity lost in that 1969-1993 era of Republican presidents. November victories at the ballot box somehow translated into June defeats at the courthouse for conservatives. You can trust Democrats to do the wrong thing. Just don't trust Republicans to do the right thing.

09 / April
09 / April
Tea Partiers v. Obama Zombies

There are trendy movements and there are transformational movements. Two new books, Jason Mattera's Obama Zombies: How the Liberal Machine Brainwashed My Generation and Michael Graham's That's No Angry Mob, That's My Mom: Team Obama's Assault on Tea-Party, Talk-Radio Americans, discuss the potentially transformational, and certainly conflicting, major mass-movements of our times. Read my review @ the American Spectator.

Malcolm McLaren, RIP

Malcolm McLaren stole Adam's Ants (awarding them to this young vision) and replaced the Sex Pistols' competent bass player with a non-musician because he better fit their look. Life imitates art. In McLaren's case, he seems to have modeled himself on that creepy music agent guy in the "Johnny Bravo" episode of The Brady Bunch. If ever there was a musical style obsessed with image it was the anti-image image of punk. That so much of it is sonic rubbish is proof enough of this. McLaren was the svengali, or at least that's what he wanted everyone to believe, behind the Sex Pistols and the punk movement of the late 1970s. Do we first think of Brian Epstein when we think Beatles or Allen Klein when we think Rolling Stones? McLaren's skills as a promoter were so great that the manager rather than the band receives the accolades. Don't hate the player hate the game? McLaren died yesterday at 64.

08 / April
08 / April
I Secede From Stupid

There are no religious heretics left in America because religion wields no power. Political heretics are legion. I suppose I am one because I don't hold an orthodox view of the Civil War War Between the States. Have you guessed one of my heresies yet?

On this one issue--that the war wasn't a "civil war" fought by the South to force slavery on the North but a "war between the states" to determine if Southern states could leave the union--I agree with Bob McDonnell, who is in the crosshairs for issuing a proclamation declaring "Confederate History Month" in the Commonwealth of Virginia. On much else I sense that I disagree with the governor.

I don't celebrate Confederate History Month because I am a Yankee and a states' rights advocate. I think the South's enthusiasm for states' rights waxed and waned with whatever was or wasn't in the South's interests. The South certainly didn't like it when Massachusetts Governor Caleb Strong balked at calling out the state militia to fight the War of 1812. He cited states' rights; his opponents called him a traitor, too. Ditto for the addition of states, which is far more offensive to Constitutionalists than the subtraction of states, over the opposition of many of the original parties, like Massachusetts, to the initial compact. Was the Fugitive Slave Act respectful of states' rights? Sectional interest, on both sides, rather than principle, generally drove events.

If the South happened to champion states' rights in seceding, Southerners championed national power when it served their interest. The regional mythologies surrounding the Civil War lead partisans of both sides down the wrong path. The North didn't fight the South to liberate slaves but to force Southerners to remain in the union. The South didn't leave the union to vindicate states' rights but to retain the institution of slavery.

Though I am not a Southern partisan, I am a partisan of states' rights. The most principled abolitionists were too, at least until the Civil War shattered principles. William Lloyd Garrison, the most dedicated abolitionist, was also a secessionist. As the banner atop his Liberator newspaper declared, "No Union With Slaveholders." During the Mexican-American War meetings were held throughout Massachusetts--including in my hometown and in the place I currently reside--advocating secession from the union. From the Louisiana Purchase to the War of 1812 to the joint-resolution annexation of Texas to the Mexican-American War, Massachusetts compiled a strong tradition of threatening secession. All of this, of course, omits those war-whooping secessionists who dumped 342 crates of tea into Boston Harbor to spark Massachusetts' separation from the British Empire. Yet, northerners, particularly hotheads from Massachusetts, are the first to jump on anyone promoting, or even understanding, the right of secession.

There is an anti-intellectual tradition of shouting down anyone who airs heretical thoughts about the Civil War. The argument, if one can call it that, devolves into much emoting, little thinking. There is an official position, and anyone who dares promote a position contrary to that is immediately shouted down. The civil war over the governor of Virginia's "Confederate History Month" proclamation amounts to such a shouting match between people whose knowledge of history is by rote, if at all. The only way to win such an argument is to, well, secede from it (Beware: the combatants may not let you go peacefully).

Those so aghast at the notion of secession should re-read (or just read) the first line of the Declaration of Independence. Is it still okay for a governor to pay homage to that secessionist document?

06 / April
06 / April
Massachusetts, Coming to a Country Near You

Six non-profit health insurers have sued Massachusetts in response to its denial of their attempts to raise prices. In other words, price in the marketplace will be decided by neither the market nor the state but the courts. In the marketplace, millions decide price. In the courtroom, one does. The former is rational; the latter is hubristic. In contradiction to the meme that corporate greed fuels insurance hikes is the inconvenient reality that these six insurers are non profit organizations. Atop this is the fact that three of these six outfits actually operated at a loss last year. What will happen when government mandates prices below cost? Shortages, black markets, and going-out-of-business signs. Massachusetts, coming to a country near you.

And Then the Witch Doctor, He Told Me What To Do

The Western taboo on condemning maladaptive cultural practices is adaptive within the cultural milieu of intellectuals. But cultures are not merely different. Some are better than others. A case in point is the spate of the ritualistic child killings in Uganda. Twenty-nine people, including fifteen children, were sacrificed in religious ceremonies in the African nation last year. There are reasons beyond racism and geography that explain the backwardness of some countries. One such reason for backwardness is, well, backwardness.

05 / April
05 / April
A Must-Read on a Don't-Read

"It comes as a surprise to many of us on the right who have known him over the years that Rove describes himself as a 'conservative,'" Don Devine and Craig Shirley write in a review of Karl Rove's memoirs in The Washington Post. "A compassionate conservative? Sure. A big-government conservative? No doubt. But a conservative, pure and simple? Now that's a real revelation." The review contrasts the laughable subtitle of Rove's book--"My Life As a Conservative in the Fight"--with the adventuristic military campaigns, plan for amnesty for illegals, deficit explosion, and compulsion to spend the taxpayer's money that characterized the presidency of the man Rove advised. I spent much of the last decade, mainly here at FlynnFiles, pointing out that George Bush was Woodrow Wilson on foreign policy and Lyndon Johnson on domestic policy. In other words, he wasn't who his dronish supporters professed him to be. What makes this review compelling is that Donald Devine is no Johnny-come-lately to playing the conscience of conservatives. His mark of scorn for not standing during a party conservative event's standing ovation of the 43rd president is now a mark of honor (it always was). In the era of Tea Parties, with George Bush retired to Texas and Republicans out of power, it's easy to lambaste GOP transgressions of the last decade. One speaks with greater credibility when the one speaking out now also did so when it mattered. Those pining for the good old days of George W. Bush should remember that without him we wouldn't be living through the Barack Obama presidency.

02 / April
02 / April
A Recipe for Shortages

Massachusetts, whose health-insurance reform served as a model for ObamaCare, has rejected 235 of 274 proposed rate increases by health insurance companies on plans for small businesses and individuals.

Lora Pellegrini, president of the Massachusetts Association of Health Plans, told the Boston Globe, "If we're not going to be allowed to have our prices cover our costs, that will be a problem for the whole industry." Indeed, what appears at first glance as a victory for price-assailed consumers will turn out to be just another defeat. The simplest way to create scarcity is to arbitrarily force a price below cost. Price controls are, to a large extent, what created gas shortages in the 1970s. It's unlikely that in a health-care Mecca like Massachusetts that this would happen overnight. But Massachusetts does no favors to consumers by eating away at the profit margin of insurance providers. Paying high costs for services, particularly when those services mean the difference between life and death, is better than a scarcity of those services.

This isn't advanced economics, folks. It's common sense. If you ran, say, a hamburger stand, and the state mandated that you sell hamburgers at below cost, would your self-interest dictate that you keep selling hamburgers at a loss, or would your self-interest encourage you to go into another field? Once the do-gooders did bad--put the hamburger peddlers out of business rather than reduced the price of hamburgers--what effect would the pressures of supply (now obliterated) and demand (now unfulfilled) have on the price of hamburgers? Legally, one couldn't peddle them at their market-set price. But in the black market, one could make a killing.

These are the principles at work in Massachusetts today. These are the principles that will be at work in America tomorrow.