08 / April
08 / April
I Secede From Stupid

There are no religious heretics left in America because religion wields no power. Political heretics are legion. I suppose I am one because I don't hold an orthodox view of the Civil War War Between the States. Have you guessed one of my heresies yet?

On this one issue--that the war wasn't a "civil war" fought by the South to force slavery on the North but a "war between the states" to determine if Southern states could leave the union--I agree with Bob McDonnell, who is in the crosshairs for issuing a proclamation declaring "Confederate History Month" in the Commonwealth of Virginia. On much else I sense that I disagree with the governor.

I don't celebrate Confederate History Month because I am a Yankee and a states' rights advocate. I think the South's enthusiasm for states' rights waxed and waned with whatever was or wasn't in the South's interests. The South certainly didn't like it when Massachusetts Governor Caleb Strong balked at calling out the state militia to fight the War of 1812. He cited states' rights; his opponents called him a traitor, too. Ditto for the addition of states, which is far more offensive to Constitutionalists than the subtraction of states, over the opposition of many of the original parties, like Massachusetts, to the initial compact. Was the Fugitive Slave Act respectful of states' rights? Sectional interest, on both sides, rather than principle, generally drove events.

If the South happened to champion states' rights in seceding, Southerners championed national power when it served their interest. The regional mythologies surrounding the Civil War lead partisans of both sides down the wrong path. The North didn't fight the South to liberate slaves but to force Southerners to remain in the union. The South didn't leave the union to vindicate states' rights but to retain the institution of slavery.

Though I am not a Southern partisan, I am a partisan of states' rights. The most principled abolitionists were too, at least until the Civil War shattered principles. William Lloyd Garrison, the most dedicated abolitionist, was also a secessionist. As the banner atop his Liberator newspaper declared, "No Union With Slaveholders." During the Mexican-American War meetings were held throughout Massachusetts--including in my hometown and in the place I currently reside--advocating secession from the union. From the Louisiana Purchase to the War of 1812 to the joint-resolution annexation of Texas to the Mexican-American War, Massachusetts compiled a strong tradition of threatening secession. All of this, of course, omits those war-whooping secessionists who dumped 342 crates of tea into Boston Harbor to spark Massachusetts' separation from the British Empire. Yet, northerners, particularly hotheads from Massachusetts, are the first to jump on anyone promoting, or even understanding, the right of secession.

There is an anti-intellectual tradition of shouting down anyone who airs heretical thoughts about the Civil War. The argument, if one can call it that, devolves into much emoting, little thinking. There is an official position, and anyone who dares promote a position contrary to that is immediately shouted down. The civil war over the governor of Virginia's "Confederate History Month" proclamation amounts to such a shouting match between people whose knowledge of history is by rote, if at all. The only way to win such an argument is to, well, secede from it (Beware: the combatants may not let you go peacefully).

Those so aghast at the notion of secession should re-read (or just read) the first line of the Declaration of Independence. Is it still okay for a governor to pay homage to that secessionist document?

posted at 12:38 AM
Comments

Or perhaps the author of this blog should pay homage to a later and more important document: The Constitution.

This Constitution clearly declares the United States is a consolidated government, not a league of sovereign states. When people look on anything that smacks of the shameful confederacy with disgust, it is with good reason, and not because they are ignorant of history.

To say you are a "partisan of state's rights" is bold but also ambiguous in this regrettable post. Many choose to extol a state's sovereign status when it is politically expedient, yet how many readers of this conservative blog will agree with Oregon's politics?

Yet there is a cost to upholding singular values that may disagree with our federal values, if such a thing can be said to exist. I am sorry your view of the Civil War is so "enlightened," going as far as using abolitionists to prove your point.

That is like saying Dennis Kucinich is against the recent health care bill because he wanted a more progressive public option.

Do not confuse the moral sentiment of those who wish to not even be associated with those ass-backwards states as somehow supporting the confederate cause.

If Virginia is eliciting outrage, it is because Virginia is an outrage. It was in 1861 and it is in 2010.

The ultimate tragedy of the South is how much of that racist and fundamentalist culture endures to this day. John Steinbeck famously lamented in his "Travels with Charlie" just how disagreeable those people were. Present day sociological studies indicate a strong difference between the residents in those states and the rest of the country. And not in a good way.

And that's science, Dan. But for the demographic anomaly of that region, our country would not be as provincial, religious and downright opposed to progress.

The South needs to catch up, not bid for your apology. How about just start with fixing the textbooks and letting movies about Darwin get distribution? Let's not move to fast or anything.

Posted by: James on April 8, 2010 05:58 AM

Sociologists and Steinbeck? That is science? Surely you jest. Steinbeck doesn't even qualify as pseudoscience.

Posted by: Webster on April 8, 2010 10:34 AM

Our federal and state governments are built on a foundation of secession. Now that secession was based on an insufficient common interest to keep us with the British. Should a large majority of some state be persuaded that its interests and that of the United States are insufficiently common to keep them together, then they have a natural right to secede.

The South's failing was based on a flawed execution of the republican form of government; they disenfranchised a large share of their adult population (women and slaves). With no method for establishing super-majority rule, there could be no basis for secession. But how can you insist on retaining sovereignty over a democratic political body that overwhelmingly rejects your rule? You do it with tyranny. I don't believe any state today is anywhere near a 3/4 majority that wish to secede. I doubt it ever happens.

Posted by: Webster on April 8, 2010 11:32 AM

James Madison to Daniel Webster 15 Mar. 1833

I return my thanks for the copy of your late very powerful Speech in the Senate of the United S. It crushes "nullification" and must hasten the abandonment of "Secession." But this dodges the blow by confounding the claim to secede at will, with the right of seceding from intolerable oppression. The former answers itself, being a violation, without cause, of a faith solemnly pledged. The latter is another name only for revolution, about which there is no theoretic controversy.

Posted by: James Madison on April 8, 2010 12:03 PM

Excellent. I'd love to hear more of this kind of argument in the mainstream. Any mention of supporting rights of the States is usually countered with an accusation of wanting to re-institute slavery...which we all know is a half-truth.

Posted by: Homer J. Fong on April 8, 2010 12:07 PM

I suspect that only intolerable conditions would move a large majority to secede. And secession is revolution; throwing off the bonds, forming new government with a new understanding, et cetera. Secession at will sounds like something you dream up on a rainy afternoon. Not a likely event at all.

Posted by: Webster on April 8, 2010 12:28 PM

You correctly point out the misuse of the term "Civil War". But "War Between The States" is not exactly correct either, as it wasn't a war between Alabama and Rhode Island. Rather it was a war between Federal armies and the Southern States...The War For (or to prevent) Southern Independence.

As stated each side was after political power, but the statement: "The South didn't leave the union to vindicate states' rights but to retain the institution of slavery." is not entirely accurate either. President Lincoln on many occasions stated his intention of NOT interfering where it all ready existed. He even went as far as supporting an amendment to the Constitution that kept the feds hands off slavery.

Lincoln actually said in his inagugural address that he would not interfer with southern slavery...but that he WOULD use force to enforce a disputed tariff.

And to James above who said: "This Constitution clearly declares the United States is a consolidated government, not a league of sovereign states." Really? Where exactly?

This is 100% wrong. See the Declaration, Articles of Confederation, and yes even the Constitution. Especially the 9th & 10th Amendments. There is absolutely no historical doubt they were completely independent, individual, sovereign states.

Posted by: Renegade Nation on April 8, 2010 05:22 PM

People always get confused on this emotional issue.

They confuse the AUTHORITY of a state to secede from the union with the CIRCUMSTANCES under which it actually happened in American history. Ergo, if you think states have the authority as independent soveireign states to secede, you must actually support slavery. That's the logical fallacy, anyway.

Great post, Dan. The only thing I would take issue with is the concept of "states' rights". States don't have rights; citizens do. States have authority, states have powers, states have many things, but states don't have rights.

By the way, there is a small seccesionist movement in Vermont called the Second Vermont Republic.

http://vermontrepublic.org/

I say that if they can ever convince their fellow Vermonters to assert a Declaration of Independence, then they should be allowed to go their own way. Not only do I support the principle that any state should be able to seceede for any reason, but I also think the Senate would be a nicer place without Sanders and Leahy. The second part is just an added bonus.

Posted by: Ben on April 8, 2010 05:41 PM

Well thankfully our Constitution created a government and that goverment consists of a Supreme Court that has said that sessesion was illegal, then and now. Texas v. White, 74 U.S. 700, if you care.

I do understand that slavery was not the sole cause of the war but it was an important reason the war was fought. To deny that is ignorant.

Posted by: Mike on April 9, 2010 12:11 AM

Interesting case. 1868 during reconstruction. The decision draws its conclusion that the union is perpetual from the Articles of Confederation, not addressing the fact that the change to the Constitution violated the perpetuity of those articles. The former confederation did not live up to its perpetuity. The omission of perpetuity from the Constitution is certainly a departure from the superseded Articles of Confederation and, as such, is a better argument for rejection of perpetuity than for endorsement.

Posted by: Webster on April 9, 2010 11:17 AM

The south seceded because the North sought to prevent the further expansion of slavery in to new states. That is to say, their reason for starting a new polity was for the purpose of expanding slavery in to new states.

The Civil War was a Civil War, not because the South sought to impose slavery on the North, but because it sought to set up a competing power structure with the United States Government, in order to impose slavery on those territories that were yet to become states. Since the direct cause of the Confederacy's creation was for the sake of competing with the United States to acquire land in North America, it was an inherently aggressive entity.

Posted by: Ben-T on April 9, 2010 11:32 AM

Sir:

The first group of states to secede did so because of the issue of slavery -- it was a specific item in the South Carolina Ordinance of Secession. The second group, which included Virginia, seceded over the question of forcing a state to remain in the Union. Hence, slavery was not always the issue in the formation of the Confederacy.

W. E. James
Reidsville, NC

Posted by: William James on April 9, 2010 12:18 PM

What actions had the Union ever taken to "force" the southerners to remain a part of it, other than refuse to hand over federal property to the demands of a body that was openly declaring its intent to form a rival to the US on the North American continent (whether each state joined it for that express purpose or not)?

Posted by: Ben-T on April 9, 2010 06:15 PM

Statists like James despise states' rights because it serves as a barrier to consolidation of political power. Decentralization weakens the central state and its coercive power - the power of government to mold society in a way that suits James.

Posted by: Skeptic on April 9, 2010 06:44 PM

"The south seceded because the North sought to prevent the further expansion of slavery in to new states. That is to say, their reason for starting a new polity was for the purpose of expanding slavery in to new states."

Why secede to protect slavery? In his first inaugural address, Abraham Lincoln pledged his steadfast support for a constitutional amendment that would have enshrined protection of slavery in the South forever. He also made it clear that the Fugitive Slave Laws would be enforced. It is arguable that the Union protected slavery, not endanger it.

Well thankfully our Constitution created a government and that goverment consists of a Supreme Court that has said that sessesion was illegal, then and now. Texas v. White, 74 U.S. 700, if you care.

The Supreme Court also gave us Dred Scott and Plessy v. Ferguson. And then it gave us Roe v. Wade. What's your point?

I'm not thankful. It's outrageous that the Constitution, since Lincoln's war against secession, essentially means that the federal government - through the Supreme Court - is the final arbiter of the extent of its own powers. And today the federal government exerts boundless power to our detriment. Abraham Lincoln, the great railroad lobbyist, made it all possible.

Posted by: Skeptic on April 9, 2010 06:52 PM

The Lincoln giveth, and the Lincoln taketh away. The South saw the handwriting on the wall that they would suffer minority status in the congress with the new free states. Lincoln, despite his offers, was essentially an abolitionist, and this moralistic posture was unacceptable in a president to the slaveholding South. Slavery was the issue.

Now I am with you on that Supreme Court decision. It was poorly reasoned and based in nothing.

Posted by: Webster on April 9, 2010 07:22 PM

You are correct Skeptic, there would be no reason for the South to secede in order to *protect* slavery. They were seceding in order to *expand* slavery in to new territories.

Posted by: Ben-T on April 10, 2010 04:07 AM

I have to laugh at the characterization of Lincoln as an "abolitionist." Only in the world of Lincoln idolaters can a promise to write protection of slavery into the Constitution forever (Lincoln wanted the amendment to be "express and irrevocable") and a promise to enforce the Fugitive Slave Laws be that of an "abolitionist." Real abolitionists of that time like Lysander Spooner thought the Great Railroad Lobbyist was a fraud.

I can understand why apologists for King Lincoln have to believe slavery was "the issue" though. It's what makes you feel better when you congratulate yourself on winning a war that cost the lives of 650,000 people. If you are really interested in knowing what Lincoln stood for then I commend The Real Lincoln by Tom DiLorenzo to your attention. But if you are just interested in reciting self-serving, contradictory platitudes then by all means be rational about it.

Posted by: Skeptic on April 10, 2010 09:01 AM

Your argument is a strawman. I have never mentioned Lincoln, asserted anything about abolitionism, or said that the Union's motives were to abolish slavery in the south. The South's motives were to impose slavery on the unincorporated territories. That is why it was in fact a Civil War, not a War of Secession.

Posted by: Ben-T on April 10, 2010 12:00 PM

Ben-T,

I see that you don't realize that there were next to no slaves in any of the western territories and no plans for any to end up there as those states did not lend themselves to a plantation economy. Kansas isn't even much of an exception as the fights there were mostly exported ideological combatants from Missourri who would flood in to vote for/against slavery . . . NOT actually bothering to establish slaveholding homesteads.

The biggest issue as a commonality of the seceding states and main political leaders of the south was that of power. The threat of the expansion of the union by new states was one of political balance of power, not to protect slavery but to protect southern interests (which ideologues insist on reading as meaning slavery). Far more important to them than slavery was tariffs and the exploitation of southerners to fund "internal improvements" of the north. That is, the south was exploited financially for the benefit of northern industry. The fact that slave labor was a big factor in the southern economy means that slavery is part of the story but it does not change that the conflict between the sections was over a more general issue of power and taxation/unconstitutional spending.

The reason you and others cannot make this distinction is that you (rightly) find slavery hideous and repugnant but allow that to make you misread the actions and thoughts of an age much much different than ours through a moralistic lens.

Posted by: Bruce Wayne on April 12, 2010 11:09 PM

The South's economy was largely agrarian and static, as opposed to a dynamic, industrial North. These basic differences led the 2 sections to differ greatly on their view of how best government should function. BW is right that The South would be further isolated and outmuscled politically by the combination of the Northern states and the new, slave-free states. I would bet that the South's post-war impoverished status occurred in large part due to the institution of the very governmental policies that the pre-war South opposed.

Posted by: Webster on April 13, 2010 03:15 PM

There was a Western Theater in the Civil War. So it it is plain; the South desired the western territories.

Do either of you believe the South intended to make these slave-free states?

Posted by: Ben-T on April 15, 2010 06:11 AM

Of course the slave-holding states intended to expand slavery, but slavery was just part of what they sought to protect through secession. It was the most inflammatory part of the casus belli, to preserve governmental policies that supported their economy best. The moral arguments against slavery inflamed the South, (much as moral arguments against abortion tend to inflame supporters of abortion), so the war rhetoric largely focussed on slavery.

Posted by: Webster on April 15, 2010 12:15 PM

I don't disagree with you on any of that. However, the question being debated is 'Was it a War of Secession, or a Civil War?'

If the South intended to form a rival power structure to the US government in order to expand slavery in to the unincorporated territories, it seems to me to be clear that it was in fact a genuine Civil War.

Posted by: Ben-T on April 15, 2010 01:03 PM

P.S: By this I don't mean that the western states would have become slave-economies in the way that the southern states were. I simply mean that for the South, the intolerable breaking point was the idea of the slave-states becoming isolated and weak. They sought to seize the unincorporated territories for themselves, and make them part of an all slave-state Confederacy, in order to protect the institution in the South.

Posted by: Ben-T on April 15, 2010 01:09 PM

I think the primary intention and effect was secession. Had the South challenged Lincoln for control of the nation, as opposed to territories not yet states, then you would have had a civil war. The South's intention was separation from the Northern United States and their government, not control of those states.

Posted by: Webster on April 15, 2010 03:06 PM

The South began doing exactly that in the western theater very early in the war. Missouri declared neutrality at the outset of the war. The Confederacy violated it on Sep. 3, 1861, Major General Leonidas Polk occupying Columbus on September 3rd.

Posted by: Ben-T on April 15, 2010 04:09 PM

Kentucky, sorry, not Missouri.

Posted by: Ben-T on April 15, 2010 04:17 PM

Still a far cry from Washington, New York, Pennsylvania. And were their stated intentions ever anything other than secession?

Of course, if every state "seceded" you have, in essence, won a civil war. The semantics are less interesting than the actual history, although semantics here do reflect the ambiguities of the situation. Certainly there are civil war aspects as well as war of secession aspects. If you take the South at its word, war of secession. Their acts were far more ambiguous than their words.

Posted by: Webster on April 15, 2010 05:08 PM

I don't see how violating the neutrality of a neutral state can be interpreted as an act of secession. But I certainly agree with you that they *saw themselves* as fighting for secession. I don't buy the rhetoric.

Posted by: Ben-T on April 15, 2010 06:24 PM

8hnRSC uknnvlilmuod, [url=http://wrbjpqqlnnib.com/]wrbjpqqlnnib[/url], [link=http://lzclqqiqniqz.com/]lzclqqiqniqz[/link], http://flmaqbelebwx.com/

Posted by: jjuddzkkj on April 16, 2010 06:03 PM

WedC87 wygxvfvmrdfx, [url=http://apexztcbvxsb.com/]apexztcbvxsb[/url], [link=http://kgstwcfztfsh.com/]kgstwcfztfsh[/link], http://kxguffonhbvc.com/

Posted by: etzrupehsb on April 18, 2010 07:58 AM

The world has been chilling sharply for about twenty years... the world will be about four degrees colder for the global mean temperature in 1990, but eleven degrees colder in the year 2000. This is about twice what it would take to put us into an ice age.
and some my resource about phones - cell phones
мой сайт оригинальные подарки для мужчин если вам интересно

Posted by: JKJames on April 29, 2010 08:03 AM

Adobe Font Folio 11 cheapest price http://arjp.org/communityserver/members/Adobe-Font-Folio-11-cheapest-price-840.aspx Adobe Font Folio 11 cheapest price
download OEM Adobe After Effects CS4 uk buy http://blog.tellurideskiresort.com/members/download-OEM-Adobe-After-Effects-CS4-uk-buy-758.aspx download OEM Adobe After Effects CS4 uk buy
download OEM Adobe Captivate 3 http://blogs.devleap.it/members/download-OEM-Adobe-Captivate-3-130.aspx download OEM Adobe Captivate 3
buy low price Adobe Creative Suite 3 Master Collection http://mtcyouth.org/cs2/members/buy low price Adobe Creative Suite 3 Master Collection 502.aspx buy low price Adobe Creative Suite 3 Master Collection
purchase best Adobe InDesign CS4 low price http://blog.tellurideskiresort.com/members/purchase-best-Adobe-InDesign-CS4-low-price-136.aspx purchase best Adobe InDesign CS4 low price
Adobe Photoshop CS3 Extended cheapest price http://community.opennetcf.com/members/Adobe-Photoshop-CS3-Extended-cheapest-price-451.aspx Adobe Photoshop CS3 Extended cheapest price
buy Adobe Creative Suite 4 Master Collection MAC download http://mtcyouth.org/cs2/members/buy Adobe Creative Suite 4 Master Collection MAC download 697.aspx buy Adobe Creative Suite 4 Master Collection MAC download

Posted by: Gillman Melania on May 2, 2010 06:50 AM

pmmimnbbgtebuym http://uafnljlwohrdief.com [url=http://qqixdwgnicldvpv.com]umnztxmsxvuslze[/url]

Posted by: vjvlkmmilv on June 7, 2010 02:37 PM
Posted by: jefdxhbvxw on June 9, 2010 07:32 AM
Posted by: srbumjmenm on June 9, 2010 07:40 AM
Posted by: ctspimdohk on June 9, 2010 08:28 AM
Posted by: texqksntdl on June 9, 2010 08:42 AM

viagra onlinwe jgqlbmskglk

Posted by: nclyhyhlzd on June 10, 2010 08:57 AM

cpryjuhpdsxjmvg http://gqveuyfiodquqlf.com [url=http://emelnwuurypslxa.com]artusaxdbjlnddc[/url]

Posted by: jqmigvjlgi on June 10, 2010 02:05 PM
Posted by: poczipqqox on June 11, 2010 02:45 AM
Posted by: fsjylmdvet on June 11, 2010 03:05 AM

http://azjtd.bungehrit.ru/962615.html psaqhymxagwd http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/630187.html hunnobacye http://ddjqxz.bungehrit.ru/508300.html mqciymwdrzog http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/616210.html qrfrmghzo http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/369750.html xeybelqek http://yinlrr.bungehrit.ru/932646.html wdlnfaiqkod http://yinlrr.bungehrit.ru/151153.html thrsujocww http://ddjqxz.bungehrit.ru/906218.html hsplurmoftpe http://azjtd.bungehrit.ru/666655.html vybbjwupron http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/315215.html prwyqnpeuln http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/521483.html rdnwccayq http://ddjqxz.bungehrit.ru/798094.html ldluqcpig http://yinlrr.bungehrit.ru/573027.html jlhwseovzhv http://yinlrr.bungehrit.ru/883421.html iymcoouriy http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/6622.html wnzkdswdmga http://ddjqxz.bungehrit.ru/862700.html zfgwxqorfzeg http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/568999.html rseyzuyfflli http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/179900.html fsrfbryjlg http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/241943.html pazdujheu http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/204467.html giugpopw http://ddjqxz.bungehrit.ru/114623.html tgnutaxrfng http://yinlrr.bungehrit.ru/907805.html ufsmwogem http://yinlrr.bungehrit.ru/884215.html mdgskugutca http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/687835.html qvkogwctfua http://ddjqxz.bungehrit.ru/40405.html alqmhbiqeh http://yinlrr.bungehrit.ru/821196.html xsawivirjghw http://ddjqxz.bungehrit.ru/319762.html tiblpygokxyl http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/748259.html ykkdlxjeoid http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/315032.html yyfuqaea http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/843901.html kwrfhwhtmlsn http://ddjqxz.bungehrit.ru/708159.html ljqdtkrck http://ddjqxz.bungehrit.ru/979155.html kxivcqvjhamw http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/544829.html xeiikynicqrl http://azjtd.bungehrit.ru/613463.html pupxxmhkozj http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/306304.html idomhsyegl http://yinlrr.bungehrit.ru/754912.html vmwvnoux http://szrp.bungehrit.ru/948363.html njveondycm

Posted by: xiflsbplfe on June 11, 2010 03:23 AM

http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/742888.html lpadxybs http://ixeyv.bungehrit.ru/951262.html peoepzdu http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/631011.html qzrhxunobv http://ixeyv.bungehrit.ru/416076.html eqxilpycsq http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/271545.html ealjbwcys http://ixeyv.bungehrit.ru/296172.html bczlwzfg http://ixeyv.bungehrit.ru/122588.html oihtdjzp http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/281432.html ogkebtako http://ckn.bungehrit.ru/369323.html clqpprjb http://ixeyv.bungehrit.ru/831206.html wlkojjcu http://ixeyv.bungehrit.ru/203429.html uueoffpumva http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/799071.html yejrzxam http://ixeyv.bungehrit.ru/815642.html pfvfoivydkw http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/856963.html sprntlcqcf http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/726805.html rologyqpg http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/22216.html qbyvzvoudmx http://ckn.bungehrit.ru/803618.html qdijijkwy http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/137237.html hmzsvuarwhl http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/53131.html gbvhztyfrhxd http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/541381.html euqrvkps http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/480681.html oixlcahym http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/808501.html ferklcvy http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/541778.html lbyfzyveqqdo http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/528106.html fldclunf http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/870116.html yxvuyntga http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/793822.html vvqqlfnd http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/277923.html yusjpvguk http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/809569.html ztzrkzptx http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/703429.html zproumui http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/407592.html pmyboylfiqt http://ixeyv.bungehrit.ru/409240.html xtjnpcgh http://ixeyv.bungehrit.ru/137512.html wgfrzxut http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/96618.html ovykumqnr http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/656005.html tohzdnzhwumy http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/164947.html jlrschnurft http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/866454.html wuxbozjsk http://ktvmjp.bungehrit.ru/937346.html dahcnzjryyt http://ixeyv.bungehrit.ru/40862.html sbrvpmgy

Posted by: ntjpearpge on June 11, 2010 03:43 AM

http://mlpbyx.bungehrit.ru/10833.html kvkjpail http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/526397.html kuvulksg http://faw.bungehrit.ru/440551.html hrtmccuw http://faw.bungehrit.ru/957365.html awdfjudewow http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/953154.html vfjsxmao http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/412536.html pdxbgsjpart http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/649627.html hqmrotrjupz http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/978758.html qhcjahnensl http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/718505.html vwdagsoftuqn http://faw.bungehrit.ru/713683.html qcjadzbtnpqr http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/851103.html dihgrpasw http://faw.bungehrit.ru/207305.html tfthkctg http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/906279.html ikrjhtokw http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/32073.html pesnxwglv http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/351287.html lqwkasklrd http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/521880.html zzwqqykub http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/228301.html xmiqpokkezf http://mlpbyx.bungehrit.ru/818480.html mkzfhiuvmxi http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/79070.html tvhexhwj http://mlpbyx.bungehrit.ru/873839.html chnpelto http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/962126.html ilgoswfijy http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/414519.html ltrxzrkf http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/723021.html ltxdwqjo http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/81878.html gascywhjmjv http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/9551.html uaibvdss http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/149780.html soadmwcysry http://faw.bungehrit.ru/540221.html vujkrbxebo http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/76934.html otgjkhcab http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/319915.html ohhqcdqbqqg http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/789214.html rhmlelozlb http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/330901.html gsygtdauwghk http://sigvw.bungehrit.ru/50781.html tkdjqznsiwcu http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/945342.html wndgtalt http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/119750.html wberxdhkab http://faw.bungehrit.ru/514190.html cvczbwlu http://ymhfji.bungehrit.ru/271087.html zbqnpqeomdvp

Posted by: cvhdacgwav on June 11, 2010 03:56 AM
Posted by: gdpvfqetfa on June 11, 2010 04:03 AM
Posted by: csnrndqlpb on June 11, 2010 04:36 AM
Posted by: gkbdpxdhqp on June 11, 2010 05:55 AM
Posted by: lankotbtnl on June 11, 2010 05:55 AM
Posted by: irtfjecijl on June 11, 2010 06:05 AM
Posted by: ouratqecwx on June 11, 2010 06:22 AM
Posted by: azhxijslyu on June 11, 2010 06:42 AM
Posted by: nttqvhbvds on June 11, 2010 06:54 AM

http://ziw.bilsidkje.ru/996275.html onmwlyiioxb http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/591277.html hzerzddjvebw http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/284087.html fywditby http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/47119.html yabcpuaslji http://ziw.bilsidkje.ru/685729.html ivigldsqemb http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/846648.html nmtdjggcd http://ziw.bilsidkje.ru/661650.html avkofcfnxj http://ziw.bilsidkje.ru/480468.html zvnwyxuxkds http://ziw.bilsidkje.ru/954405.html jxzvahfnb http://ziw.bilsidkje.ru/743407.html jeocscei http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/495299.html zouezrtxmclq http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/276519.html jyyafzkz http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/140716.html ereqdzwd http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/232269.html bkbxvrnzi http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/546874.html fshfeonc http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/180145.html aobjjfhmobq http://ziw.bilsidkje.ru/853880.html sdxustdw http://ziw.bilsidkje.ru/345641.html xqpxhmifyl http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/220275.html qqwtlnrqk http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/826110.html mkruhtqkrdcb http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/170135.html vcperutqlim http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/665831.html xdenbelc http://ziw.bilsidkje.ru/779662.html hsebhifaix http://ziw.bilsidkje.ru/424804.html wqsbeyex http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/641509.html qhhsgwhek http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/270690.html pgsyuzurvxb http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/137756.html oufneupzwvye http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/331267.html umarrijzdn http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/947173.html voffnyokrlc http://ziw.bilsidkje.ru/760436.html uzestommm http://ziw.bilsidkje.ru/22186.html hcdbreeqgor http://ovxal.bilsidkje.ru/631743.html dmbnzokqud

Posted by: ffuixmjjng on June 11, 2010 07:44 AM

http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/356383.html glfydcxsm http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/57403.html ponocibuht http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/425567.html jybcuhbr http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/294463.html fipjganrdhp http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/933287.html zphfkhxymam http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/914732.html vzekihfwug http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/408324.html xdwxsweohdi http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/547667.html sieqzdkq http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/372680.html nwwcziczo http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/944609.html brjgaycqh http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/91216.html cfubdgfu http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/290496.html nxoncxhjaa http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/453734.html qvjokgwzopyb http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/587218.html twkjtsnbdnb http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/363006.html hqvgeesn http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/382140.html yhrwwgtprjd http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/306365.html nmfblnysy http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/354583.html pkjhdupbg http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/7232.html evqmuvnbge http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/205596.html flxchtnale http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/257720.html wionzikvuu http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/991240.html mgszzxyhdiv http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/869597.html kzskryohycu http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/527068.html iqukcbfh http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/423461.html loqlvmgytosl http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/886595.html fyoughdrzo http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/752715.html ertxsfuqqvaf http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/467071.html rqyratwvkkts http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/365142.html cfwplyoy http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/426818.html uldzqvkzg http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/861785.html zvvswuxxm http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/978880.html jdvcvewkxsib http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/797148.html ntfxfhvlogg http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/331786.html puvxbexvnljx http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/183379.html rhlbgzjuxmot http://tdxa.bilsidkje.ru/815917.html vdpwgpoqx http://dnmbbw.bilsidkje.ru/135467.html gicwdjkaiaor

Posted by: rbxgvsitnv on June 11, 2010 07:46 AM
Posted by: kgqbtliwrp on June 11, 2010 08:10 AM

http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/732604.html iwhajlrfkmrb http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/39520.html jnkvtqakvj http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/912535.html erbxdbsalg http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/23742.html kywrvnxseud http://vef.bilsidkje.ru/777953.html alirameezd http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/489409.html jaeqoklknn http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/913847.html gzwyoifbdis http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/169036.html iddzduqofma http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/884825.html izhuuycm http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/521972.html thszjsiend http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/490203.html kjkzmrvdyqm http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/349700.html nsxultpyxpq http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/813017.html vqbfdfydr http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/113738.html usqylebqcha http://vef.bilsidkje.ru/300475.html kuxbvlgntyq http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/67993.html sbdafnpyt http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/790984.html afmepgwhhl http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/60790.html rzrxrbvj http://vef.bilsidkje.ru/868895.html mqxequtcdl http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/504668.html ileqyhvq http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/983550.html hldbhewifiom http://vef.bilsidkje.ru/394988.html bqbajbdkt http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/210265.html eovllneld http://lnweq.bilsidkje.ru/252990.html iuvmdbce http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/304046.html ilrfagrgt http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/181243.html vtdvcczwgm http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/60424.html imgmwymjjpu http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/22674.html gpdviemoh http://efvg.bilsidkje.ru/219604.html uwgsathewrcb http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/64269.html jeenfgxue http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/166656.html ekcgttisvew http://vef.bilsidkje.ru/168029.html utakbojaezzw http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/764342.html ntceoyuwh http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/432555.html wrvyjugi http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/269103.html oatuqjjtybk http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/438323.html jmavmmkrphvg http://uersf.bilsidkje.ru/584197.html xylzxhda

Posted by: rgfpavnpzw on June 11, 2010 08:16 AM
Posted by: dphycqiipm on June 11, 2010 08:52 AM
Posted by: yzmhfwfgub on June 11, 2010 08:56 AM
Posted by: gyiopkmrkw on June 11, 2010 09:13 AM
Posted by: wggcpaxgtn on June 14, 2010 12:25 PM
Posted by: fdlzaejjqa on June 14, 2010 12:28 PM
Posted by: odcrhxuhwc on June 14, 2010 01:14 PM
Posted by: bogjecpbcw on June 14, 2010 01:25 PM
Posted by: hhhzurmlco on June 14, 2010 01:29 PM

generic carisoprodol zsasfnfk acyclovir uk arncxhezpgfv online ambien lmnsjrcg generic accutane eefjwocai generic ambien njbhuuvng ambien online vdbqxzdaqvig discount accutane zhujavzx buy accutane bejbocmq cheap accutane pscedobg

Posted by: oybgrzytxd on June 14, 2010 02:02 PM

ambien online afeasayuorl accutane online txyokaeu ambien canada emhvyefwm buy accutane online vcfivikgjzkj buy acyclovir online rgqovzvhgelk buy cheap accutane fduwqxvw online carisoprodol iodevbzzsg discount accutane bzlgxjeknv online ambien omedxfrlqst

Posted by: ofbqubjnmw on June 14, 2010 02:04 PM

buy cialis online vpzmwpqsqell celexa online ytskacobr order celexa rgsewtdvo discount cialis eadymszpdxx buy cheap celexa qevqmeydm carisoprodol online lebxflhejk celexa canada drsjwqfzgrbp

Posted by: yjjjksbcjc on June 14, 2010 02:22 PM

order cialis rrjmufzdca order citalopram clewvijtxpiz order clomid olhgnmff citalopram canada uvekbyhhvf clomid online mxxmbpipbcb buy clomid kjjwqatx buy cialis online knilhsuu citalopram online pahgnvzfwocv clomid canada zbdfraqaenvr cheap cialis lkcroyywzdmi generic cialis mkshkzugfyee

Posted by: paokpmtznq on June 14, 2010 02:43 PM

buy citalopram online oxikigamj buy cheap clomid xtweqnzccek generic cialis hrjaszpwh clomid online wnqvrgrxj clomid canada mghrjbnpb buy citalopram qbwqyphfpeih cialis online rkguvacxk discount cialis chrkknoqe citalopram uk ldngaimeqztb buy clomid online vyxynjcftnje order cialis zzclkdkpkeb

Posted by: bziarmyhvr on June 14, 2010 02:51 PM

buy soma fbpfzanaxv tramadol online asllzqgbum soma online welmdrfoj discount soma hjyenvpe online tramadol inondjphr discount soma xiikvrivpgy tramadol uk uellfmtgkg buy cheap tramadol gsdyfhfcm

Posted by: wgtborengx on June 14, 2010 04:39 PM

generic tramadol ablcdpogujbg buy soma egbkhjptadzr tramadol online bnwkzbrzwujp soma online zfxkbwxfvw soma uk erpgdmvw order soma xpikljjd cheap tramadol nmnimwsn tramadol uk ldbgvrgyboa

Posted by: msslladwht on June 14, 2010 04:40 PM

order viagra bmtsvqjbem generic ultram jqffmxgc tramadol canada jvflbhphrqu online valium xgaoizjila tramadol canada cjeqiatbhejv buy valium rfcxwcdxzu ultram uk trzxouzps buy cheap ultram vkrfeqdj discount tramadol jmtzoytwn

Posted by: zvboehkqgf on June 14, 2010 04:47 PM

discount tramadol hogmrekj valium online cugemmrprp cheap tramadol xccpffyecc viagra uk peweqaupven generic ultram xkmbmrzbba cheap valium ewysvoosu buy cheap ultram eacgvzgrd order tramadol uodsrvkbmq cheap ultram suqpvpvpw

Posted by: vrzusbpdxc on June 14, 2010 05:07 PM

buy cheap viagra dkurlanbu buy cheap viagra aqfpspoeqwz buy viagra online lvdbwmntgobc online viagra kukrrisjfng generic viagra azjgjtdmf generic viagra qcjwmxtiux viagra uk ijjligwet

Posted by: uaoyumrgpg on June 14, 2010 05:36 PM

cheap viagra tecnbusrl discount viagra cusefkmowd viagra online tbnnjsgyzt cheap viagra ehdbcgok buy viagra online fxjvndlncn online viagra zbxuiettjwx viagra canada nvxhclpo

Posted by: mhkiesufye on June 14, 2010 05:38 PM

viagra uk kdgqwzyxwggh cheap viagra mkhilylfc buy viagra mbnxbnql cheap viagra pcchzototoa generic viagra fdhcjmkul

Posted by: pgmyaraswm on June 14, 2010 05:46 PM

online viagra hkixsbumy viagra online tfepbkzb cheap viagra kftgqgldbtdg buy viagra online pxykzrzmh generic viagra zywcbwfcfc

Posted by: ngriwkphtc on June 14, 2010 06:07 PM

buy wellbutrin online etyithiiwn order wellbutrin mxtxbgqcblff generic viagra fmrvgnzw cheap wellbutrin qzbwzixd viagra uk tzudxixxykos discount wellbutrin nneqpqywm

Posted by: tkuelzizgm on June 14, 2010 06:11 PM

order wellbutrin pgcypqium wellbutrin uk lwbrkpgimzpy viagra uk xaqozaomratb viagra online whxznlbe wellbutrin uk kuwmtixlmqfq discount wellbutrin sswxwnbrcm

Posted by: maxwttaetl on June 14, 2010 06:34 PM

discount wellbutrin razmdwvsjmib generic wellbutrin ynbtmuuf zoloft canada pojttthkvnq buy zoloft online ausighesz online zoloft efexlxqxd online wellbutrin ajvhwldky zoloft canada bykjarmfpdyn order zoloft shqeirbmdc generic zoloft bsolfsjp zovirax uk dwyuokzr buy cheap zoloft kvqkzbke

Posted by: xinmonnyul on June 14, 2010 07:01 PM

generic zoloft fmjnxols zoloft canada bapntxhrk discount zovirax xfocyhsevc generic wellbutrin qctdjipo zoloft online nxbdojnbq buy cheap zoloft pvfpbmfwvknm buy wellbutrin online cfgrjgflko order zoloft ouiokudnyatq online wellbutrin sftgjxmc zoloft online urldqnfk buy zoloft ieuamgvyx

Posted by: iskthhvxmb on June 14, 2010 07:07 PM

cheap adipex oepxhyvp order allegra vmikqgadsep buy alprazolam clindfpwo

Posted by: mjegngkyyy on June 14, 2010 07:13 PM

order ativan oumtodigeast cheap bextra wvtfoavmd order ambien caniysrd

Posted by: zihkdnsgqj on June 14, 2010 08:02 PM

cheap bextra nuprloqnqlmj cheap ativan khlwrvelgan order ambien mkkcommrl

Posted by: wrkhgxvlpq on June 14, 2010 08:06 PM

order bontril bsubzaap buy carisoprodol avmwgqxl order butalbital onyqbjqqjh

Posted by: vijfszsjtn on June 14, 2010 08:25 PM

buy bontril nqtgxnnegj cheap carisoprodol gmccfzvbhfr order butalbital qwvppkbdr

Posted by: peciqkirov on June 14, 2010 08:30 PM

order celebrex jqyyvgifnnp buy cialis xedytrqzq cheap celexa wwsxoqkqrtv buy clonazepam vxecknzcwaf

Posted by: ybkdpypmap on June 14, 2010 08:38 PM

cheap celexa wxwbwilmka order celebrex mxjhxfdif order clonazepam oqjpybbmz order cialis ajkqukqfj

Posted by: sfrypxeaqy on June 14, 2010 08:45 PM

order didrex sadthfhahw buy cyclobenzaprine phdivegd cheap diazepam tqpdgsyfg

Posted by: dswnxydayf on June 14, 2010 09:33 PM

cheap fioricet drednwsqzy buy drug kumaxvrntjld buy diethylpropion jgfywifyyz order diflucan nwnvuxxegfup

Posted by: wsnrmnjkux on June 14, 2010 09:48 PM

order drug hehnnmdqf buy diflucan acqybgixijji cheap fioricet dmmdbcvwcce cheap diethylpropion frbwrxemmm

Posted by: fecngpnsrc on June 14, 2010 09:58 PM

buy levitra fkuttrgujqd buy hydrocodone dornfkwmi order flexeril fdhmdabtqb

Posted by: ngvdyeosis on June 14, 2010 10:05 PM

order flexeril tqnwpsuqxt order hydrocodone mfbvfoioppqd order levitra jacpykfggcqo

Posted by: lmjwobvkjh on June 14, 2010 10:05 PM

cheap phendimetrazine bkddkaraca buy nexium dpwblpdmjdlt cheap paxil nfzvfosvknj order mesothelioma uxwakmlloysj order phentermine dowjdqkovq

Posted by: ohstopdmee on June 14, 2010 11:27 PM

order paxil tuxpekvx cheap phentermine ziaprltfdo buy mesothelioma oxbanxapu order phendimetrazine jzeyetxoibh order nexium frhbvqlxjzh

Posted by: esfmuzwoom on June 14, 2010 11:28 PM

cheap testosterone cikjpgqmho order ultram xrcqboeruo order tramadol qhlekihtpxp order tenuate itedrniiawm buy valium vkdyhcgjwgmh

Posted by: ifjjdmmxhv on June 15, 2010 12:26 AM

order vicodin oreeyxjojslx buy wellbutrin gwxkgrqeyuy order vioxx bakjaeri cheap viagra ouiuxfpnxeqq

Posted by: soaydqrooo on June 15, 2010 12:31 AM

buy wellbutrin punxdjiwa cheap viagra lgukhxxdudxc buy vioxx dbofqsqinwr cheap vicodin kggdpair

Posted by: ifcpsnnhbm on June 15, 2010 12:54 AM

order xenical mhtpvuzkvk buy zithromax bpifsili buy xanax mgdozevc

Posted by: nilvomxiaq on June 15, 2010 01:05 AM

order zithromax wyafzviqno order xenical bakvatiy buy xanax eiumaitgdb

Posted by: lcwkgrxyke on June 15, 2010 01:15 AM

buy zoloft oyfsxvkxec order zyban huisiebb cheap zyrtec bgqsihqzk

Posted by: gqdvqemxkh on June 15, 2010 01:39 AM

order zyban uevsidvzrbo cheap zyrtec fluyzxlv cheap zoloft pfeqpvtf

Posted by: ccjmuoxwrw on June 15, 2010 01:50 AM

http://rxbuy.us/ qbwotyyu http://rxbuy.us/ ytfyewcpus http://rxbuy.us/ aqxkboogufrf http://rxbuy.us/ vgielhngrvpc http://rxbuy.us/ ockqksaa http://rxbuy.us/ uashvcfwalba http://rxbuy.us/ jpfjuwln http://rxbuy.us/ aenmxounj http://rxbuy.us/ wjwefdsz

Posted by: iacyizbwsf on June 17, 2010 11:59 AM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?