22 / March
22 / March
Obama Goes To War

"Large parts of Obama's base have proved equally malleable on questions of war and peace," Jim Antle writes at the American Spectator. "This is not surprising. The left uses opposition to unpopular wars to recruit supporters the same way young men use poetry and cute dogs to pick up girls. Once in power, liberals discard their antiwar convictions as quickly as a successful Don Juan ditches Fido and Sylvia Plath." This is really the best article I have read about Obama's unilateral--going it alone without Congress, not the French--operation in Libya.

posted at 09:24 AM
Comments

"More proof of my longtime thesis, Repub pols fear the GOP base; Dem pols hate the Dem base." -David Frum

Posted by: PMA on March 22, 2011 01:58 PM

When the Obama Administration began, the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq were winding down. Mr. Obama expanded the Afghan war, delayed the ending of the war in Iraq, and participated in the invasion of Libya. Didn't this guy win a Nobel Prize or something? I'm confused. To be blunt, had McCain been elected and all else being equal, the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq would have been over by now and we would not have participated in an invasion of Libya, at least not without some type of consultaion with Congress.

If we really wanted "peace", it would have made much more sense to vote for Mr. McCain. By supporting Mr. Obama it seems some people really wanted something else or perhaps they were mislead by his smooth rhetoric.

Posted by: B.Poster on March 22, 2011 03:31 PM

B. Poster wrote,

When the Obama Administration began, the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq were winding down.

To be blunt, had McCain been elected and all else being equal, the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq would have been over by now and we would not have participated in an invasion of Libya, at least not without some type of consultaion with Congress.

Do you have any evidence for either claim?

Posted by: PMA on March 22, 2011 03:43 PM

the "surge" had largely done what it was designed to do and the plans were in place to draw down forces in Iraq. This had largely begun by the time Mr. Obama came to office. Mr. Obama while not necessarily committing more troops to Iraq appears to have halted the withdrawls that were already beginning by the time he came to office.

As for Afghanistan, troops were being withdrawn with no plans to redeploy them to Afghanistan or to replace them with new troops as they were being withdrawn. If that policy had continued, the Afghan war would be all but over now. Then along came Mr. Obama and expanded the Afghan war. The evidence for the first claim is simply a remembering of the history of what was going on at the time right before Mr. Obama came to office and extapolating on what would have happened had those policies continued.

The evidence for the second claim is an examination of Mr. McCain's voting record and assuming he would continue to act in accordance with his Senatorial voting record. As his record was very simillar to the policies pushed by Mr. Bush, I am assuming he would have largely continued the same policies. Given how closely he supported the policies of Mr. Bush, it seems likely he would have consulted Congress in a simillar fashion to how Mr. Bush did before beginning military operations and before assisting in an invasion of Libya. Admitedly this is somewhat educated guess work. He may have found some excuse to behave differently.

It might be more accurate to say had Mr. Bush remained in office for a third term the Iraq and Afghan wars would be all but over by now, as this would have been the net result of a continuation of his policies. The assumptions are based upon Mr. McCain's past actions he likely would have continued Mr. Bush's foreign policies with perhaps only nominal changes.

Posted by: B.Poster on March 22, 2011 04:30 PM

BP, McCain was one of the first to bash conservatives who called the Afghan war, Obama's war. You should watch the Gen.Petraeus congressional hearings from last week. McCain strongly supports Obama's policy. The only difference is the way the media and partisan dems respond.

Posted by: adb on March 22, 2011 04:40 PM

adb,

Mr. McCain bashes Conservatives for sport. It gets a rise out of them, it scores points with the news media, and it makes him popular among the Republican leadership. As a political strategy, its all reward and no risk. I think the best way to evaluate him is by his actions rather than his testimony. He largely supported Mr. Bush's policies. I think it reasonable to assume he would have likely continued the same foreign policies he supported as a Senator had he been elected President. Had the Bush policies been continued and all else been equal the Afghan and Iraq wars would have probably been all but over right now. Furthermore, while he might be cheering Mr. Obama on right now, it seems unlikely from Mr. McCain's prior record that he would have launched a war against Libya without consultation with Congress.

Again, its probably more accurate to say had the Bush era foreign policies been continued the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq would likely be over now and a war against Libya would not have been launched without extensive consultations with Congress. Maybe the "Maverick" would have discontinued the Bush policies that he supported as a senator had he been elected President.

Posted by: B.Poster on March 22, 2011 06:13 PM

bp, you should really check out those congressional hearings from when Petraeus was in town. McCain is hellbent on staying in afghanistan for as long as it takes, and always has been. There is NO WAY he would have pulled us out of there by now.

Posted by: adb on March 22, 2011 07:52 PM

I'll do that. In this case, perhaps he has altered his positions since Bush left office. Perhaps he would have opposed the Bush policies. Essentially as the Bush Presidentail term was ending as the tours of duty of soldiers ended there were no plans to redeploy many of these men in the future nor were replacements being sent for many of them as their tours ended. The logical conclusion to this policy is the Afghanistan war would have wound down and ended had Bush era policies been continued.

For Mr. McCain to keep us there he would have had to alter Mr. Bush's policies which he generally supported while a Senator. Perhaps he has since had a change of heart regarding his policy positions or perhaps this is all for show.

Posted by: B.Poster on March 22, 2011 08:01 PM

adb,

You may well be right about Mr. McCain. As I recall, he supported the "surge" for Iraq before Mr. Bush did. Maybe his support for Mr. Obama's "surge" in Afghanistan is simillar.

Posted by: B.Poster on March 22, 2011 08:07 PM

It is, no doubt. Listen to the Petraeus congressional hearing on c-span.

Posted by: adb on March 22, 2011 08:43 PM

Do we not anymore have a representative republic that follows The Constitution of the United States that requires the President to adhere to certain standards? Or do we have a Monarch who answers only to himself and his chosen higher powers?

Obama commits the United States to a war with no formal declaration, no authorization by Congress to concur or authorize funding let alone even a meeting with Congressional leaders.

His reasoning is based on allegedly humanitarian reasons and a vote by the United Nations Security Council (which he chairs by the way), and voila! King Barack Hussein Obama the First dispatches our blood and our treasure to assist a paper thin coalition and shoves off to war with Libya.

This is not only one of his many more impeachable offenses, but it makes it ever more clear that Obama sees the Presidency of the United States as a stepping stone to becoming a Global Monarch.

Posted by: asdf on March 23, 2011 09:39 AM

The President absolutely has the authority to take these actions. That it is TOTALLY inconsistent with his past statements on the subject is interesting and fun to poke him in the eye with. However, if he were going to war with Somalia and the pirates there (which would have been a FAR more productive and useful deployment of forces), none of us (other than the truly derranged) would be arguing about this.

Posted by: Homer J. Fong on March 23, 2011 10:39 AM

Though, actually, I should add that a war with Somali pirates would actually be authorized under the War Powers Resolution, as an attack on a U.S. Navy vessel would be equivalent to an attack on the United States (as they are considered to be the soverign territory of the U.S.), and justification for such an imminent attack would be pretty easy to make.

Posted by: Homer J. Fong on March 23, 2011 10:52 AM

The president did send a letter to congress, stating his plan and point to the War Powers Resolution as the legal grounds for his then upcoming actions. Oh well, this helps Ron Paul, or a Ron Paul-endorsed candidate in 2012.

Posted by: adb on March 23, 2011 12:33 PM

Homer, it doesn’t appear that you are of one mind on this. Certainly, the President would have reason and justification to attack and war against the Pirates (i.e. – Somalia). But what reasons are there to do the same with Libya? Are they a threat to us? How have they attacked or otherwise harrassed the United States?

This, from a precedent an@alysis after 9/11 from justice.gov -

The President has broad constitutional power to take military action in response to the terrorist attacks on the United States on September 11, 2001. Congress has acknowledged this inherent executive power in both the War Powers Resolution and the Joint Resolution passed by Congress on September 14, 2001.
The President has constitutional power not only to retaliate against any person, organization, or State suspected of involvement in terrorist attacks on the United States, but also against foreign States suspected of harboring or supporting such organizations.

And now the contradiction. This from Obama in 2007 –

“The President does not have power under the Constitution to unilaterally authorize a military attack in a situation that does not involve stopping an actual or imminent threat to the nation,”

And he was right as this applies to what HE has done with regard to Libya and wrong in terms of what Bush did.

Posted by: asdf on March 23, 2011 12:44 PM

I was commenting on his authority, not necessarily the wisdom of his action.

Posted by: Homer J. Fong on March 23, 2011 01:24 PM

I should also add, that if you don't like the mushy language in the War Powers Resolution, then you should be pissed off at the Congress. The language of the Resolution is intentionally subjective and broad (a practice that I'm personally opposed to, but sadly pays my salary...). We should be actively engaged with our Government and INSIST that legislation be drafted with clear definitions. We cede all power to the courts, otherwise.

Further, if you don't like the action he's taken in Libya, you should insist that Congress introduce legislation to withdraw those troops.

50 U.S.C. 1544(c):

"(c) Concurrent resolution for removal by President of United States Armed Forces

Notwithstanding subsection (b) of this section, at any time that United States Armed Forces are engaged in hostilities outside the territory of the United States, its possessions and territories without a declaration of war or specific statutory authorization, such forces shall be removed by the President if the Congress so directs by concurrent resolution."

Posted by: Homer J. Fong on March 25, 2011 09:00 AM

I suppose I’d have to agree with that. Nothing like being definitive, eh?

What bothers me the most is that those in power, for the most part, don’t know war, don’t know combat, don’t know what it means to be in harms way. Yet, they often times treat military excursions that risk our blood and treasure like they’re handling entitlement legislation. Not seriously.

Posted by: asdf on March 25, 2011 09:57 AM

I mean, just to show how serious going to war is to these jokers, they won't even call it "war".

War is now a "kinetic military action"??! Can you imagine this doublespeak?

I think a fourth grader would think this was ridiculous.

Posted by: asdf on March 25, 2011 11:45 AM

LBUzUG xtixfruisfia, [url=http://xdulqihhqmkm.com/]xdulqihhqmkm[/url], [link=http://gtttsromcpzg.com/]gtttsromcpzg[/link], http://xtienxgllyxu.com/

Posted by: ylrdto on March 26, 2011 09:42 AM

Jansenism win a ipad 2

Posted by: Emxiqvim on March 27, 2011 07:45 AM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?