16 / August
16 / August
Ground Zero Mosque

The construction of a mosque blocks from ground zero is imprudent, provocative, and insensitive. It's not illegal. People who don't own property should not have rights above and beyond the rights of the actual holders of the property. If you don't like the way your neighbor uses his property, offer to pay his mortgage and his property taxes. Short of that, it's not your business--literally. Josh Barro has a more-light-than-heat take @ National Review on the construction of a mosque close to the site of the fallen Twin Towers. Almost as revolting as Muslims building a mosque near the spot where their coreligionists murdered several thousand people are conservatives who demand the federal government strip the deed holders of their property rights to sell, lease, or develop the land. Since when did Congress become Manhattan's zoning board?

posted at 10:35 AM
Comments

I'm not usually a fan of our courts citing foreign law in their decisions. In this case however, let's use the ruling made the last time someone proposed a new synagogue in Medina.

Posted by: Daniel(no, not that Daniel) on August 16, 2010 12:48 PM

Does any politician seriously think that allowing the Muslims to build this Victory Mosque will pacify them or prevent further attacks? In fact, it will only encourage them, in the same way that allowing the Nazis to occupy the Rhineland led to their occupation of Austria, Czechoslovakia, Poland and then the whole of Europe.

The politicians should read the links under 'Appeasement' at EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT ISLAM

Posted by: Trencherbone on August 16, 2010 08:03 PM

This mosque will never get built. There isn't a labor union in NY that would lift a shovel to build the place. No union would want blood on their hands.

Posted by: Rich on August 17, 2010 11:33 AM

Ultimately, Dan is right.

Still, I wonder what would happen if Christians wanted to build a megachurch at ground zero? Not likely.

As it turns out, there was a Greek Orthodox Church very close to the twin towers. Not a proselytizing megachurch, just a modest ninety year old building. It was destroyed on 9/11. Rebuilding it has been held up by a lot of haggling about how high the domes can be. The Port Authority doesn't want it to overshadow the 9/11 memorial that will surely be built there. I guess there's no concern about a thirteen story mosque.

Posted by: Ben on August 17, 2010 08:45 PM

These are not stupid people. They are smart, tough and anything but naïve. But they believe Americans are stupid and naïve and they were caught flat footed and by surprise by the fact that most of us know exactly what the meaning of building a mosque on or near that hallowed ground means. Most Americans have not forgotten 9/11 and still take the attack very seriously.

So there are two good things that have come out of this so far: It has woken the citizens of the United States up to the seriousness of a foreign threat to our safety and our liberty and it has highlighted those in our political classes who are not true friends of America. Both have been object lessons.

And where is our ‘President’ on this? On the opposite side of the majority of Americans, as per usual.

Posted by: asdf on August 18, 2010 09:20 AM

Same as it ever was?

Back at the formation of the republic, this occured: “...Thomas Jefferson and John Adams, then serving as American ambassadors to France and Britain, respectively, met in 1786 in London with the Tripolitan Ambassador to Britain, Sidi Haji Abdul Rahman Adja. These future American presidents were attempting to negotiate a peace treaty which would spare the United States the ravages of jihad piracy—murder, enslavement (with ransoming for redemption), and expropriation of valuable commercial assets—emanating from the Barbary states (modern Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, and Libya, known collectively in Arabic as the Maghrib). During their discussions, they questioned Ambassador Adja as to the source of the unprovoked animus directed at the nascent United States republic. Jefferson and Adams, in their subsequent report to the Continental Congress, recorded the Tripolitan Ambassador’s justification:

… that it was founded on the Laws of their Prophet, that it was written in their Koran, that all nations who should not have acknowledged their authority were sinners, that it was their right and duty to make war upon them wherever they could be found, and to make slaves of all they could take as Prisoners, and that every Musselman who should be slain in Battle was sure to go to Paradise.”

Posted by: Lefty on August 18, 2010 09:44 AM

Dan, Government has been zoning buildings, including churches and synagogues for decades, suddenly the Left wants to say "freedom of religion" or you say, "property rights" trump well established law. In principle I agree with you, but not when property principles are only going to apply as a rationale in PC cases. Equal treatment under the law is an equally important principle and that has more life in it today. The Left which drives prayer out of public places, tries to remove crosses from cemetaries, and refuses to include the Ten Commandments in schools, has suddenly found one religious liberty they can support: making Lower Manhattan a Jihadist shrine!

Posted by: Ron Robinson on August 19, 2010 09:07 AM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?