13 / February
13 / February
Bad Faith

There is no such thing as a free lunch--or a free tubal ligation. The Obama Administration's "compromise" over its "preventative services" bureaucratic edict still forces religious organizations to fund contraceptives, sterilizations, and abortifacients. The supposed accomodation is a three-card monty sleight of hand. Read my column @ Human Events on how the president has made himself pope.

posted at 08:19 AM
Comments

King Brak not only believes that he should have an open never ending checkbook, but that he can pontificate from on high to make things up as he sees fit when he sees fit to dictate how it will be.

As Pelosi said, ‘we need to pass the bill to know what’s in it’. And what’s in it is whatever they want to be in it at whatever cost they choose to impose.

This guy is not a President. In his mind, he’s a dictator and is being allowed to act out as such.

Posted by: asdf on February 13, 2012 09:13 AM

I do find it interesting that the Catholic Church has formed this Faustian relationship with liberal politicians and when it suits their quest for ‘charity’ (in this case, doing the Lords work by re-distributing other people’s money), they are surprised when they are held to the same skewed standards as others. Did the Church really think they would be immune to a Party whose very basis of their power and agenda are to be serial liars?

I suppose I was naïve in this regard as I thought I would see the Church, at least locally, take more of a stand against an odious government mandate. But at least in my little corner of the Republic of Massachusetts, I have heard little to nothing about this from my Catholic brethren. At this point, I am not questioning my faith but I am questioning my Church.

Posted by: asdf on February 13, 2012 03:58 PM

Taking care of those in need (food, clothes, medicine, etc.) is a principal concern of the Church. So, it's understandable that they would support laws that have that aim. Is the Church then against liberty? Two points.

First, given the current understanding of the Constitution by many (including many "experts"), government subsidized health-care may not be unconstitutional. I disagree, but let's not suppose that the bishops are constitutional scholars, or that being Catholic commits one to an originalist reading of the Constitution.

Second, the proper balance between liberty and virtue (in this case, providing for one's neighbor if they are in need) is a difficult question, to which reasonable people can give different answers. (As an aside, I wonder if you are opposed to providing defense for your neighbor; that is, do you begrudge your tax dollars providing police and military protection for others; for that matter, are you bothered that your money pays to put out a fire in someone else's house?)

Posted by: Ralph on February 15, 2012 08:31 AM

I can understand where the Church is coming from on the subject of “charity”. By way of definition (i.e. - generous actions or donations to aid the poor, ill, or helpless) the church is very much in the business of providing it. By the same standard, so is government to an extent (emphasis on ‘to an extent) because it is not a main tenet of government to be in the charity business.

The difference is that the Church does not threaten or coerce contributors who provide the means for that charity with fines or otherwise jail if they don’t contribute whereas the government does. Additionally the re-distribution of our funds are typically not used for high minded humanitarian ideal but for votes. At least in these days.

Last time I bothered to notice, the U.S. Constitution says nothing about providing government sponsored medical care including anti-reproductive services or forcing people to accept it. In fact, the 10th Amendment gives the Federal Government only powers that are explicitly stated and the former are not. All others are powers derived from the state and/or the people.

All else is a re-interpretation of the rule of law that the Constitution lays down by elected officials who have no right to do so.

Support by the Catholic Church, for whatever the high minded reasons, for this kind of lawlessness by progressives has me doubting it. To be clear, I don’t doubt my Faith, just the motives and the politics of those assigned as guardians of it.

Posted by: asdf on February 15, 2012 03:13 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?