01 / November
01 / November
Your Mother Should Know

Journalists seeking comment from the 90-year-old mother of Samuel Alito reminds me of the media hounding Mel Gibson's octogenarian father to discredit the filmmaker. It goes overboard.

"Of course he's against abortion," Rose Alito explained of her son from her New Jersey home. Liberals, of course, interpret this to mean Alito will automatically vote to overturn Roe v. Wade. I hope he will. I think he will. But the information passed on by his 90-year-old mother doesn't tell us so. For Sam Alito is a jurist and not a legislator, and his past decisions prove that he conducts himself as such.

Conservatives and liberals view the Constitution differently. The former reads the text; the latter acts as if it were not there. Because liberals substitute their own whims for the words of the Constitution, they imagine that conservatives do this too. Some do. But true conservatives don't. Judge Alito ruled on two important abortion cases. In each case, Alito relied on law rather than whim to guide him.

In Planned Parenthood v. Casey, Alito ruled in Casey's favor at the appellate level. He saw nothing unconstitutional about a Pennsylvania law that required spousal notification in event that a wife sought to abort her husband's child. Many disagree with such a law. No one, including Judge Alito, can find where it's prohibited by the Constitution. Several judges, including five Supreme Court justices, did find that they personally disagreed with the Pennsylvania laws regulating abortion and then constructed a chain of reasoning to justify negating the will of the people of Pennsylvania.

In Planned Parenthood v. Farmer, Alito concurred with the decision to strike down New Jersey's ban on partial-birth abortions. A Supreme Court precedent made in Stenberg v. Carhart, rather than Alito's personal view ("Of course he's against abortion"), guided his decision. Although the media has played up Alito taking the pro-life side in Planned Parenthood v. Casey, journalists have said very little about the judge's concurrence with the pro-choice side in Planned Parenthood v. Farmer. Some facts, I guess, ruin a good story.

It is clear, at least when it comes to abortion, that Alito decides based on an honest interpretation of law rather than a dishonest embrace of personal preference (I think he was wrong to value the opinion of the Supreme Court over the text of the Constitution in the Farmer case, but my side has lost that argument over precedent for now). One can't say the same for the judges lionized by Alito's Democratic critics on the judiciary committee.

Samuel Alito, I sense, will vote to overturn Roe v. Wade. His personal view of abortion, as divulged by the source who knows him best, will not factor into the decision he makes. The text of the Constitution will. All of this is because he understands that he is a judge and not a legislator.

posted at 10:43 AM
Comments

This is why the Dems will go after him with everything they have. They know the only way to get most of their agenda enacted is thru the courts. Alito is a threat to that. I just wonder if the Republicans will fight for this. It's the right thing to do. I am enough of a realist, though, to be skeptical. They are after all, politicians.

Posted by: Wm. Clement on November 1, 2005 10:50 AM

I'm hopeful for Alito's confirmation. I think as the issues surrounding the Casey decision spill out into electoral politics that Rick Santorum will be able to find some ammunition against Casey's son, who is said to be pro-life, but still doesn't benefit from how far his own party has come on this issue. Santorum has to run the race of his life to keep that seat.

I'm thinking Connie Chung and Newt Gingrich's mother with this mom-Alito interview.

Posted by: Finbar on November 1, 2005 11:17 AM

Ed Whelan, Nation Review Online:

"Given the celebrated inconsistency of Justice O'Connor's positions and her steady slide to the Left over the years, most if not all of the several instances in which the Supreme Court has disagreed with Judge Alito (out of his 15 years of rulings) have a ready and telling explanation: Judge Alito, at the time of his rulings, has taken seriously the Supreme Court precedents then in effect and has, with intellectual rigor, applied them faithfully — only to learn later the cruel lesson that O'Connor's ad hoc approach is subversive of principled decisionmaking. Alito has, in short, been far more faithful to Supreme Court precedent, and to O'Connor's previously stated positions, than O'Connor has."

Posted by: Ralph on November 1, 2005 11:19 AM

Some of you may remember this...but didn't Connie Chung get statements from Newt Gingrich's mother in the mid-late 90's before Newt left his post in the House? I remember this being a rather funny parody on SNL.

Posted by: Christopher J. Doyle on November 1, 2005 04:47 PM

The left is primarily responsible for politicizing the judiciary. Any view of the constitution as a "living document", with no fixed meaning, leaves constitutional law subject to the passing whims of democratic majorities. A malleable Constitution allows interest groups on the left to advance their agenda through the Courts in lieu of the cumbersome legislative process. The likes of Kennedy and Schumer see the Court as this quasi representative body, a "super legislature" as the saying goes. Judges should be "diverse" and represent "mainstream" America. And who better to help pick a "mainstream" justice than Senators from Massachusetts and New York?

An activist judiciary is in keeping with liberal philosophy as well. Liberals favor a society governed by enlightened elites, who will protect their favored minorities from the encroachments of democratic majorities. Judges and lawyers serve as the elites, championing an anti-majoritarian view of the Constitution often buttressed by lofty rhetoric about rights that is untethered from any principled interpretation of the document.

The liberals have both a political and a philosophical interest in the composition of the Court. This explains the blind partisanship of the Kennedy's and Schumers, and why the confirmation process is so contentious.

Posted by: CB on November 1, 2005 09:27 PM

True that, CB.

Posted by: Herman Leadready on November 2, 2005 12:03 AM

News on Alito today from the Christian Science Monitor is that in the 4 cases he heard as an appellate judge dealing directly with abortion he voted on the "pro-abortion" side in 3 of them.

I already had read about, and Dan discusses, his dissent in the 1991 Planned Parenthood v. Casey and his vote to strike down a NJ law proscribing partial-birth abortion (basing his decision on SC precedent). These were the 2 additional cases in which he took a pro-abortion side (so to speak):

"A 1995 challenge to a Pennsylvania law that required women seeking to use Medicaid funds to abort a pregnancy resulting from rape or incest to report the incident to law enforcement officials and identify the offender. Alito provided the decisive vote striking down the abortion restriction."

"A 1997 challenge to a New Jersey law that prevents parents from suing for damages on behalf of the wrongful death of a fetus. Alito ruled that the Constitution does not afford protection to the unborn."

I need to know more about these cases to figure Alito out, the one I don't like is the 1997 one but this may just be because I know that it is true that the Constitution is mute about the unborn. These decisions might just reflect that as Dan says he is a good judge who doesn't arbitrarily impose his views on the decisions he makes. I am reminded in that regard w/ Scalia pointing out to Catholics that even if you are personally opposed to capital punishment that the judge cannot impose that belief but must bend to the constitutionality of it.

Anyone know anything more about these cases? If I can find a case number or name I can locate his decisions online.

Posted by: Brian on November 2, 2005 11:38 AM

Brian,

Drudge has a story linked with pretty much the same summaries of the four cases.

I'm not too concerned about the 1995 case. On the face of it, it would seem to involve technicalities that, while definitive with respect to the case, are superfluous to the constitutional status of abortion.

The 1997 case troubles me. It seems to me that the 14th Amendment protects the unborn qua 'person' (i.e., the sense of 'person' in the 14th Amendment is not a philosophical but common one, and is roughly synonymous with 'human being').

Posted by: Ralph on November 2, 2005 12:42 PM

I have the same thought as you there Ralph. In fact, your pointing to a reasonable interpretation of the 14th amendment as actually protecting the unborn brings up a larger problem for me of legal theory. I find myself wavering over the controversy about whether or not one should take a "results" oriented stance as a judge. Alito is rightfully being praised as a non-ideological judge and clearly the judicial philosophy being expressed by many Senate democrats is a wholly results-oriented and manifestly unconstitutional one that is proceduarally unjustifiable. However, I think legal positivism (ala Scalia) can lead to a total disregard of what is in fact the just outcome in given cases and only emphasize what is procedurally and methodically correct.

So the question is: Is the legal system supposed to serve the end of justice or not? Justice is supposed to be the "result" of a judge's decision in a case. Law schools more often than not teach that justice (following Rawls I think) IS only a matter of fair procedure (so it is a positivist stance). But this view completely disregards the natural law. Clearly sometimes the end (justice) does not justify the means (extra-constitutional or unprecedented imposition of personal views like in Roe). But if the 14th Amendment can be construed in a manner which recognizes the injustice of abortion then shouldn't I as a pro-lifer want the SCOTUS to actually BAN all abortions, rather than just return the issue to the purview of the peoples of the states given that the Constitution is (very) strictly speaking silent on the status of the unborn?

The argument of conservatives generally is a strict constructionist and positivist one emphasizing the sovereignty of the states over against Congress and therefore arguing that Roe needs to be overturned b/c it usurped the legitimate powers of the states to legislate in regards to abortion. But if in fact the 14th Amendment does protect the unborn than even state legislatures would not actually be constitutionally able to legislate in favor of it. So I can't decide if the conservative tactic is one of political prudence only, or if it is both the prudential and theoretically principled tactic to take in ending abortion.

Posted by: Brian on November 2, 2005 01:32 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?