18 / March
18 / March
Malpractice Lawsuit

ObamaCare hasn't even been passed, and Idaho has already enacted law that compels the state's attorney general to sue the federal government to block enactment of the health care-welfare bill's provision that forces individuals to purchase health insurance. The AP story snarkily notes, "Constitutional law experts say the movement is mostly symbolic because federal laws supersede those of the states." But the article quotes neither a "constitutional law expert" nor the Constitution. I will bypass quoting a constitutional law expert, too, but because I reject the notion that the Constitution is so mystical that it requires an expert to explain it. It's pretty straightforward, especially so on the relationship between the states and the federal government they created. Here's the 10th amendment: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people." In other words, if the Constitution does not explicitly grant certain powers to the federal government, the federal government doesn't have those powers. Now, can somebody tell me where does the Constitution delegate to the federal government the power to force me to buy health care from some company or government entity?

posted at 12:01 AM
Comments

Just throwing thios out there, but I imagine that the arguments that will be used will be based on the Fed's power under the commerce clause and another argument can be made uder the auspices of equal protection. Someone will try to throw them against the wall and make them stick. Commerce will be the big challenge.

Posted by: Mike on March 18, 2010 03:19 PM

The way that the Supreme Court has interpreted the Commerce Clause, the Court would say that if Congress were to regulate the number of squares of toilet paper you use per week, that would be a valid exercise of Congress's power to regulate interstate commerce.

Which is one reason why I so deeply hate our courts.

Posted by: Alan on March 18, 2010 07:02 PM

You hate a bunch of guys who died years ago then. The Court expanded the commerce clause in the early part of the 20th century and only started to reign it in in the later part of the century. The problem, if there is one, happened a long time ago.

Posted by: Mike on March 19, 2010 08:59 AM

It started for the most part in 1937, and was a repudiation of precedent.

Yes, it did start a long time ago, but that makes it no less illegitimate. Nor is it a defense of modern judges' continuing to defy plain constitutional text.

Posted by: Alan on March 19, 2010 11:23 PM

I'm really surprised by your language "The problem, if there is one." How can it not be a problem that our courts allow Congress to use the Interstate Commerce Clause as a pretext to regulate things that are neither interstate nor commerce?

Posted by: Alan on March 19, 2010 11:26 PM

This is the only answer to stopping the beast. States have to start nullifying congressional acts.

Posted by: Bruce Wayne on March 20, 2010 11:05 PM
Posted by: replica watches on March 22, 2010 11:20 PM

270iZt kynjczjdtvkm, [url=http://okorimemlcub.com/]okorimemlcub[/url], [link=http://mqfpjcaaalnr.com/]mqfpjcaaalnr[/link], http://hbgawugjebhy.com/

Posted by: vfypzxw on March 28, 2010 09:29 PM

dahDLE yrwhsdhwlcpw, [url=http://qhzlrnnkggcf.com/]qhzlrnnkggcf[/url], [link=http://zlcmxqqtofsi.com/]zlcmxqqtofsi[/link], http://cphafqkxgzbv.com/

Posted by: qgmslvgqf on March 28, 2010 09:59 PM

izG64F dyatlmmhqyuz, [url=http://jnreizbkztsk.com/]jnreizbkztsk[/url], [link=http://qkzosvorgskf.com/]qkzosvorgskf[/link], http://lvhamdgtukow.com/

Posted by: nfdaevc on April 10, 2010 10:15 PM

runescape gp,
runescape quest,
buy runescape,
runescape money,
runescape item,
runescape account,
runescape gold,
runescape gp,
runescape quest,
buy runescape,
runescape money,
runescape item,
runescape account,
runescape gold,
runescape gp,
runescape quest,
buy runescape,
runescape money,
runescape item,
runescape account,
runescape gold,
runescape gp,
runescape quest,
buy runescape,
runescape money,
runescape item,
runescape account,
runescape gold,
runescape gp,
runescape quest,
buy runescape,
runescape money,
runescape item,
runescape account,
runescape gold,
tibia gold,
tibia gold,
tibia money,
tibia item,
tibia items,
buy tibia gold,
tibia weapon,
tibia leveling,
armor tibia,
tibia level,
tibia account,
tibia gold,
tibia money,
tibia item,
tibia items,
buy tibia gold,
tibia weapon,
tibia leveling,
armor tibia,
tibia level,
tibia account,
tibia gold,
tibia money,
tibia item,
tibia items,
buy tibia gold,
tibia weapon,
tibia leveling,
armor tibia,
tibia level,
tibia account,
tibia gold,
tibia money,
tibia item,
tibia items,
buy tibia gold,
tibia weapon,
tibia leveling,
armor tibia,
tibia level,
tibia account,
tibia gold,
tibia money,
tibia item,
tibia items,
buy tibia gold,
tibia weapon,
tibia leveling,
armor tibia,
tibia level,
tibia account,
tibia gold,
tibia money,
tibia item,
tibia items,
buy tibia gold,
tibia weapon,
tibia leveling,
armor tibia,
tibia level,
tibia account,
tibia gold,
tibia money,
tibia item,
tibia items,
buy tibia gold,
tibia weapon,
tibia leveling,
armor tibia,
tibia level,
tibia account,
tibia gold,
tibia money,
tibia item,
tibia items,
buy tibia gold,
tibia weapon,
tibia leveling,
armor tibia,
tibia level,
tibia account,
tibia gold,
tibia money,
tibia item,
tibia items,
buy tibia gold,
tibia weapon,
tibia leveling,
armor tibia,
tibia level,
tibia account,
tibia gold,
tibia money,
tibia item,
tibia items,
buy tibia gold,
tibia weapon,
tibia leveling,
armor tibia,
tibia level,
tibia account,
ffxiv gil,
ffxiv money,
ffxiv gold,
final fantasy XIV gil,
buy ffxiv gil,
final fantasy XIV money,
ffxiv gil,
ffxiv money,
ffxiv gold,
final fantasy XIV money,
buy ffxiv gil,
final fantasy XIV gil,
ffxiv gil,
ffxiv money,
ffxiv gold,
final fantasy XIV money,
buy ffxiv gil,
final fantasy XIV gil,
ffxiv gil,
ffxiv money,
ffxiv gold,
final fantasy XIV money,
buy ffxiv gil,
final fantasy XIV gil,
ffxiv gil,
ffxiv money,
ffxiv gold,
final fantasy XIV money,
buy ffxiv gil,
final fantasy XIV gil,
ffxiv gil,
ffxiv money,
ffxiv gold,
final fantasy XIV gil,
buy ffxiv gil,
final fantasy XIV money,
guild wars armor,
guild wars platinum,
guild wars farming,
guild wars buy,
guild wars shop,
guild wars gold,
gw gold,
guild wars money,
guild wars armor,
guild wars platinum,
guild wars farming,
guild wars buy,
guild wars shop,
guild wars gold,
gw gold,
guild wars money,
guild wars armor,
guild wars platinum,
guild wars farming,
guild wars buy,
guild wars shop,
guild wars gold,
gw gold,
guild wars money,
guild wars armor,
guild wars platinum,
guild wars farming,
guild wars buy,
guild wars shop,
guild wars gold,
gw gold,
guild wars money,
guild wars armor,
guild wars platinum,
guild wars farming,
guild wars buy,
guild wars shop,
guild wars gold,
gw gold,
guild wars money,
guild wars armor,
guild wars platinum,
guild wars farming,
guild wars buy,
guild wars shop,
guild wars gold,
gw gold,
guild wars money,
guild wars armor,
guild wars platinum,
guild wars farming,
guild wars buy,
guild wars shop,
guild wars gold,
gw gold,
guild wars money,

Posted by: lsl on April 15, 2010 08:13 AM
Posted by: terminalia on April 16, 2010 03:18 PM

PCGamerUSA - 24 Hours Online Selling FFXIV Gil. FFXIV Gil Delivery. Gil Will Send to Your in game Mail Box or trade face to face. All Transactions are easy and safe. Pay Your Cheap FFXIV Gil With Paypal or Credit Card.

Posted by: xiaofan on April 25, 2010 12:55 AM

PCGamerUSA - 24 Hours Online Selling FFXIV Gil. FFXIV Gil Delivery. Gil Will Send to Your in game Mail Box or trade face to face. All Transactions are easy and safe. Pay Your Cheap FFXIV Gil With Paypal or Credit Card.

Posted by: xiaofan on April 25, 2010 12:58 AM

Thank you so much for this post, it was very insightful! I have found a direct conversion software,


Blu-ray dvd ripper helps you create Blu-ray discs from various videos for playback on any Blu-ray players. With this software, you can easily burn your videos to Blu-ray discs and AVCHD DVDs .

------------------------------------


More info you can visit: http://besthdsoft.com/besthdsoft.com/best-hd-blu-ray-dvd-ripper.html


More Related Products : * blu-ray dvd ripper * blu-ray ripper * blu-ray to avi

Posted by: wangwei on April 26, 2010 09:48 PM

Christian shoesReviews about quality cheap Christian Louboutin shoes on sale at wholesale price Discount,
Buy replica and designer handbags including LV,We are here to provide the best replicaDior Handbags,
The History of Balenciaga Handbags-Sun,High Quity Balenciaga Handbags,What should be your considerations when planning to buy a replica Tiffany jewelry?
watches wholesaleVacheron Constantin Watchescheap handbagsPrada Handbags
cheap bootsfashion shoeswomen shirtsmarketingThis is an Awesome Polo by Ralph Lauren Mens Hoody Sweatshirt!!

Posted by: dasfsa on April 27, 2010 05:05 AM
Posted by: rs goldSYSTEM on April 28, 2010 03:52 AM
Posted by: InADreamm on April 30, 2010 01:56 PM
Posted by: rikushi on April 30, 2010 06:47 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?