02 / September
02 / September
Broken Flowers

At the risk of giving away the ending, Broken Flowers is a movie without an ending. Its protaganist, played by Bill Murray, is similarly a blank slate. Going with the film's "mystery" theme, the viewer is supposed to supply the answer to who, exactly, the leading man is. We know he's an aging Don Juan. His name, Don Johnston, and the black-and-white Don Juan movie playing on his televison, let the slower viewers pick up on this. Following in the fill-in-the-blank pattern, the dialogue is ever ambiguous--always leaving room for interpretation. When Murray goes on the road in search of a son he may have spawned twenty years earlier, his inquiries about any children his former girlfriends now have elicit answers that aren't answers. One now married old-flame responds that she never had children with her current husband, while the unforgettable "Lolita" (teenage daughter of Sharon Stone's character), when asked if she has any brothers or sisters, brattily responds: Why? Do you think I need some?

Though another Oscar nomination has been discussed for Murray, it shouldn't be in the cards this time--as his numerous supporting actresses steal scene after scene from him. It's Lost in Translation redux for Murray, who just turns the volume down in Broken Flowers on his earlier, already understated, Oscar-nominated role. Murray was better as this character the first time around.

Despite great acting, clever scenes, and the constant sense that the film's potential will be fulfilled around the next corner, Broken Flowers never delivers. Writer/director Jim Jarmusch is too clever by half. His attempts to impose deconstructionism on film grows old quick and is really a mask for laziness. If you're the painter, why not paint the whole canvass? Jarmusch offers a half-empty canvass and hands you the brush. Unfortunately, I paid $9.50 to watch Broken Flowers but received not a dime to write it.

posted at 01:53 AM
Comments

Almost dead on target with this movie, Dan. But I have to disagree with your comment that the girlfriends always steal the scene from him. I think the chemistry between him and the girlfriends is well balanced and well done. What I hated about this movie (aside from the lack of ending, of course) was the lack of any admirable girlfriend. All of them had their different personalities and quirks, but all proved to be completely shallow. In retrospect, the movie seems very bitter because of this.

Although it is humorous to note that the last boy Murray sees (as he goes by in a car) is in fact his real-life son.

Posted by: 80 year old woman on September 2, 2005 11:57 AM

Eighty-year-old women: I don't think the women are all shallow. Each actress portrays very well with her brief, necessarily superficial scenes, very interesting lives full of various types of happiness and sadness (though the bitterness does come through more strongly). In fact, I think that is part of the structure of each women's part: an emotional depth inside that is only portrayed in slight gestures. My complaint about them is that none of them is a serious *person*. They are all foolish, in one way or another. So although the movie is, in some sense, about the allure and attraction of women for Murray's character, in the end it doesn't portray any of them as independently good or serious as persons, and therefore they lack real allure or attraction. They are weak, vulnerable. They are (except perhaps Winston's wife, who is undeveloped entirely) all scarred or recovering or needy. That's a flaw in the screenplay, or in the screenwriter's view of women, I think.

Posted by: scully on September 2, 2005 12:48 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?