29 / October
29 / October
The Tipping Point

The food service industry is down for the fourth quarter in a row. Tipping, on the other hand, is up over the past few years. According to Zagat, St. Louis and Philadelphia tip the best at 19.5 percent.

I wonder about the poll's findings. It is in Zagat's interests to inflate the average tip. Also, people aren't proud of being cheapskates. If Americans will lie to pollsters about their favored candidate, or sexual preferences, then certainly they might fib that they tip more generously than they actually do. Perhaps St. Louis and Philadelphia tip the best. I just wonder if everybody lies a little, including waitstaff eager to psychologically induce higher and higher gratuities, about tipping.

The industry standard used to be 15 percent. But even the standard need not be adhered to if the service doesn't meet the customer's standard. Years ago, as a clear sign of my disgust with horrible service, I left little or nothing as a tip. I did so at a restaurant I frequented, well, frequently, so I didn't feel like a coward. A tip isn't an entitlement. Witholding a tip happened just once in thousands of visits to resturants. Bad service, unfortunately, has happened occasionally since.

I once lived with a foreigner who worked six days a week waiting tables at a French restaurant. He had strong opinions about various ethnic groups. "White people...the best, the best!," he once announced. It dawned on me that his opinions sprang from the gratuities that his customers generally left. I hesitate to call his opinions stereotypes, as they proved malleable depending upon the generosity of his previous night's patrons.

I worked two jobs that relied, to one degree or another, upon tips. As a kid, I delivered the Boston Globe for more than five years. Most customers didn't tip well at all. Only two or three customers met the 20 percent standard that Zagat suggests is normal for waiters and waitresses. I generally delivered the paper past its scheduled time (7 a.m. on weekdays, 8 a.m. on weekends), so maybe there was good reason for this. But waiters and waitresses don't deliver meals in blizzards, so I resented many of my customers for not tipping--even at Christmastime. In one of the more memorable encounters of my youth, one customer even refused payment for months of the Boston Globe. I was eleven, and it was a rotten thing for a grown adult to stick me with the bill for the paper that she read.

The ones who did tip well, and employed me to shovel out their driveways, I remember fondly. A few of the pensioners, who probably viewed the paper as a big expense, still tipped well. Collecting from them often entailed long conversations, as they didn't get out much and I have always enjoyed the company of old folks--several of my customers were children of the 19th century! The level of tipping generally did not conform to income levels. Yuppies, as they were called in the '80s, were often cheapskates. A wonderful gay couple, and a father and son who lived on respective floors of a duplex, I remember as the best tippers.

Shortly after I retired as a paperboy, I got a coveted job at Fenway Park. It's my lone foray, albeit a seven year one, into the food services industry. The vast majority of customers didn't tip. How they rationalized tipping a waiter, but not the guy who carted around a steaming hot-dog tray on a 90-degree day, I never understood. Tips were often dependant upon pricing. When a hot dog cost $1.75, people might say "Keep it" regarding the quarter. When priced at $2, tips were harder to come by. It's understable. Without spare change hanging around, who's going to give you a buck on a two-buck product?

Last night, I dined at the Outback. My tip amounted to 18 percent before tax and sixteen after tax. Whether it's customary to tip based on the percentage of the Outback's bill or the total Outback/Taxman's bill has always been a mystery to me. By Zagat's St. Louis standards, I am a bit of a cheapskate either way you cut it. By the standards of everybody, I suspect I am pretty normal. Alas, I suspect the guy who tips at ten percent thinks he's normal too.

posted at 12:23 AM
Comments

The going rate for a tip of a cab driver, a paper boy, or a hot dog hawker cannot be likened to that of a server or bartender. The bartender and server do not receive a living wage. The tip is their wage. A bartender gets 2.63 an hour and a waitresses hourly compensation does not exceed four dollars and after taxes the wage of the server and bartender is a wopping VOID.All of the afore-mentioned occupations receive a living wage, so mentioning them in the same breath is a stretch.

Posted by: anonymous on October 29, 2009 09:15 AM

My tip is always commensurate on the level of service. The food can $uck, but I'm tipping for the level of service rendered no matter what the venue or the quality of the meal/drink.

I agree totally with the pre-tax tip. The state hasn't done anything and it might seem like a slight to my server but, them's the breaks.

Generally, a buck for a beer in a bar works for me and my tipping habits have been greatly impacted by my wife who worked for years as a waitress full and part time and won't allow for me to be the blantant cheapskate that is my nature.

Tipping jobs that were good and bad? When people actually shined their shoes, I worked as a shoeshine boy and typically looked at 100% tips. Delivering the Globe, as has been written. Waiting in a faster food chain, crappy. Waiting in an upscale venue, very good.

Posted by: asdf on October 29, 2009 09:50 AM

Paperboys make a living wage? They were neither subject to minimum wage nor child-labor laws when I did it. They certainly make less an hour, perhaps justafiably, than any waiter or waitress. And it's not just in theory that they were exempt from minimum wage laws, in fact they often didn't make minimum wage.

Whereas waiters, waitresses, and bartenders generally get some guaranteed wage an hour, ballpark vendors--at least when I did it--don't have any guaranteed hourly salary. They get comission (14 percent to start). Like waiters, waitresses, and barstenders, this, in effect, meant almost never making minimum wage. So your comparison holds here better than with paperboys. But it doesn't hold up as well when you consider what a vendor is: a waiter.

Posted by: Dan Flynn on October 29, 2009 10:22 AM

The paper boy comparison is hogwash; the latter half of the occupation's name explains why. Going forward, if you were an adult paper boy, you're retarded, and on some sort of government roll/subsidies.
Also, vendors at Fenway Park get commission, regardless of their demeanor or appearance. The bartender or server does not. The bartender is assumed to get commission for what he or she hawks over the bar and if he is good he will. The underlying difference between bartender and vendor is that the customer is in complete control of the server/bartender's wage. Beware the Europeans.

Posted by: Anonymous on October 29, 2009 01:18 PM

Anonymous: You initially wrote: "The going rate for a tip of a cab driver, a paper boy, or a hot dog hawker cannot be likened to that of a server or bartender. The bartender and server do not receive a living wage." Now you concede that paperboys don't make a living wage either, but slide back into a rationalization of not tipping them because they're merely boys. The fact is, of the three groups in the post--bartenders/wait staff, paperboys, and vendors--bartenders and wait staff are the only ones that make any kind of wage--a daily or hourly payment--at all. Vendors and paperboys aren't guaranteed anything.

I understand why it might be more important to tip a bartender/waiter than a vendor, even if both are performing essentially the same service (though the vendor's job is far more physically taxing). A vendor will do far better in a stadium of cheapskates than a bartender will do in a barroom full of cheapskates. That said, the customer isn't in complete control, or perhaps more accurately isn't fully responsible, with regard to the bartender's take. You already mentioned that the bartender does get a meager hourly wage, that obviously isn't dependent upon the generousity of customers. Also, the bartender's performance is in some way determinative of his take. Good service generates better tips. It would be more accurate, though not entirely accurate, to apply what you said about the bartender being dependent on the whims of the customer upon the vendor. After all, the commission-based worker only makes money when the customer departs with money.

To sum up: Tip your paperboy. Tip the vendor who brings you a beer or a hot dog. I'm not a psychologist, but your outburst here has been a rationalization of your poor treatment of paperboys and vendors, no?

Posted by: Dan Flynn on October 29, 2009 02:30 PM

Flynnfiles wrote:
(though the vendor's job is far more physically taxing). You have done both jobs? Or do you comment on things you never have done? I don't know which is more physically taxing because I haven't done both. Your comments make which job you have never done evident.
I'm sure a down and out gin mill would be less taxing than bars that are New Years eve busy for 6-8 hours (3-4 baseball games) every single night. I'm also sure that there are stadiums that hawking hot dogs for a

The bartender never receives a check as long as his owner complies with IRS regulations. They read void to cover around five percent of the owner's hit of the legal amount a server/bartender has to legally declare 15%.
The Hot Dog vendor receives a wage from the corporate beverage and services company and often the guest he as served.
The bartender can throw ten cases of Coors over the counter and the owner will never compensate him for his efforts; if the customer does he receives a wage.

Posted by: Anony on October 29, 2009 03:06 PM

...some of the post got cut off.

Posted by: anony on October 29, 2009 03:07 PM

Walking 5-7 miles up steep stadium stairs on a 90-degree day with a heavy hot dog tray for three hours is more physically taxing than being a waiter, waitress, or bartender. You might deal with more drunks and scummy people in a bar or restaurant, so it might be more mentally taxing, but being out in the elements, having to climb stairs contantly, and carrying heavy trays generally makes it more difficult. I haven't worked construction, but I can say it's more physically taxing than being a writer. Yes, if you read the site, I do comment on jobs I haven't done (serving as president) and people I haven't met (Balloon Boy, Steve Phillips).

I also think you are using the term "wage" so loosely as to undermine its primary definition.

Posted by: Dan Flynn on October 29, 2009 03:19 PM

With reference to the beer and dog hawkers at the Fens, I would agree that those folks bust cookies for low dough. I think the patrons consider that they are lucky to be watching game the for free. I know, I know - that does not apply. But can't control what some people think.

On the inside, the beer vendors seem to clean up.

I'll be at the Gaaghden tonight and will watch as the folks pouring Bud, Bud Light and assorted other brews for $7.50 a pop get tips of the remaining .50 to $1.00 from the generous.

Sell enough suds and you could walk away with a nice purse.

This seems to apply too to the beer stands outside of Boston in venues where they serve you an actual 16 oz. bottle of cold brew. Usually for a more reasonable price.

Posted by: asdf on October 29, 2009 04:49 PM

Could the lack of tipping at ballparks reflect the cost of refresments? At Citizen's Back Park (Philly), beers are seven dollars and hot dogs are over five. I'm thinking that refreshments are even more expensive at other ballparks. This isn't to say that vendors don't deserve tips. I'm merly speculating on an explanation. I also realize that this may not be relevant to Dan's experiences, as the cost of refreshments may have been less outrageous.

Posted by: Keith on October 29, 2009 05:55 PM

You may be right, Keith. Even at the time (early 1990s), a $2 Fenway hot dog was considered expensive, so it's all relative. I think when people know they're getting ripped off, which they are in any sports/concert venue, they feel okay about withholding a tip or issuing a smaller tip. What makes the $7 beer more outrageous is that sporting venues generally serve stadium beer with 3.2 alcohol. In other words, the price and the product are inflated.

Posted by: Dan Flynn on October 29, 2009 06:19 PM


I remember the days (yes, it is another asdf anecdote) when you buy a six pack and a $6 buck Bruins matinee ticket and sit in the first balcony and talk to the reporiting class whilst watching the game.

Damn, I'm old!

Good times

Posted by: asdf on October 29, 2009 06:23 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?