04 / October
04 / October
Worth Repeating #34

"The man of culture finds the whole past relevant; the bourgeois and the barbarian find relevant only what has some pressing connection with their appetites."
--Richard Weaver, Ideas Have Consequences, 1948

posted at 11:01 AM
Comments

Can you dumb it down a shade?

Seriously, the "conservative canon" needs more books written in English. No wonder the Hannitization of America goes unabated.

Posted by: obi juan on October 3, 2006 11:23 PM

There is no present or future - only the past, happening over and over again - now.

Posted by: Eugene O'Neill on October 4, 2006 10:45 AM

Yeah, in the present, you freakin' moron.

Pardon me while I have a strange interlude.

"Party, Party, Here I am talking of parties, I came down here for a party, what happens? Nothing. Not even ice cream. The gods looked down and laughed....Hideous stumbling footsteps creaking along the misty corridors of time, and in those corridors I see figures, strange figures, weird figures.....steel 186, anaconda 74, american cane 138..."

Posted by: Homer J. Fong on October 4, 2006 10:58 AM

Was that Asian philosophy?

Posted by: asdf on October 4, 2006 11:35 AM

Marxism.

Posted by: Homer J. Fong on October 4, 2006 12:47 PM

And Ockham is responsible for the fall of Western civilization.

What a terrible book.

Posted by: Ralph on October 4, 2006 02:28 PM

Ralph-- Not even Ockham, Aquinas' Aristotelianism about form.

Homer-- Hi-larious.

Posted by: skeptic on October 4, 2006 05:51 PM

The whole of the past is certainly not relevant, even if more of it is relevant that what suits our temporary appetites. The past is full of infinite number of completely uninteresting facts, and we should care only about some of them.

This statement is as false as a progressivist one claiming that instead of worrying about the past, we should think about the future.

Posted by: skeptic on October 4, 2006 05:54 PM

"The whole of the past is certainly not relevant, even if more of it is relevant that what suits our temporary appetites. The past is full of infinite number of completely uninteresting facts, and we should care only about some of them.

This statement is as false as a progressivist one claiming that instead of worrying about the past, we should think about the future." -Skeptic

Of course it is. Any moment in history has any number of-on their own, seemingly irrelevant-facts that contributed to and shaped that moment in history and consequently the world we live in today.

Each and every part of history is in fact so relevant that it becomes impossible for human beings, with our limited faculties of reason-to calculate-at ideologues like to believe-any simple system or rules set for governing society, and then simply create a utopia by employing that formula.

Posted by: Ben-T on October 4, 2006 06:44 PM

"Each and every part of history is in fact so relevant..." -Bent

Really? Some half-evolved man several million years ago woke from a nap at precisely 3:13 in the afternoon. Weaver was an antiegalitarian, right? Well, some facts are more relevant than others.

Posted by: skeptic on October 4, 2006 07:34 PM

Eugene O'Neill- greatest American Playwright of all time.

Posted by: Sean on October 4, 2006 09:16 PM

"Really? Some half-evolved man several million years ago woke from a nap at precisely 3:13 in the afternoon. Weaver was an antiegalitarian, right? Well, some facts are more relevant than others." -Skeptic

Not relevant. You can't possibly calculate which tiny details are of no importance and which ones may have been of major imortance.

Posted by: Ben-T on October 4, 2006 10:00 PM

Ben-T,

If we take it as a given that we finite human beings can't perfectly discern which details are important and how they are important (as well as which ones aren't important--as you seem to concede that some may well be irrelevant, notwithstanding our incapacity to know them as such), is it really proper to maintain that "[e]ach and every part of history is in fact so relevant..." ?

Posted by: Buzz on October 4, 2006 11:15 PM

I think Ben-T is just playing around w/ the supposed logical connection between every moment of the past and the present, that if a fly hadn't landed on a leaf at a certain point in the mesozoic era, then a chain of events in the evolution of history wouldn't have occurred and I wouldn't have been born. Some sorta "everything is connected" theory is behind Ben's claim I think.

Ben, you a Taoist?

Posted by: Bruce Wayne on October 5, 2006 01:24 AM

I was addressing the claim that it is wise to consider the whole past relevant.

Since we can't calculate the streams of history, it is wise to consider all history, and not some history, of relevance.

Look at the assertion in context. Weaver is saying that the man of culture considers all of our past relevant, and contrasting it with ideologues, who consider only those parts of the past that suit their pre-concieved theories to be relevant.

Thats why theories of human behavior and social construct fail, time, and time, again. Each and every part of history is so relevant that we can't calculate simple models for creating utopia.

Which is the rest of the often quoted sentence here, and which changes the context considerably.

Posted by: Ben-T on October 5, 2006 10:37 AM

I thing better to go to http://www.apartments.waw.pl/ for more info.

Posted by: Warsaw apartments on October 25, 2006 06:44 AM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?