06 / August
06 / August
Worth Repeating #102

"[T]he blindness of superiority continues in spite of all and upholds the belief that vast regions everywhere on our planet should develop and mature to the level of present day Western systems which in theory are the best and in practice the most attractive. There is this belief that all those other worlds are only being temporarily prevented by wicked governments or by heavy crises or by their own barbarity or incomprehension from taking the way of Western pluralistic democracy and from adopting the Western way of life. Countries are judged on the merit of their progress in this direction. However, it is a conception which developed out of Western incomprehension of the essence of other worlds, out of the mistake of measuring them all with a Western yardstick. The real picture of our planet's development is quite different. Anguish about our divided world gave birth to the theory of convergence between leading Western countries and the Soviet Union. It is a soothing theory which overlooks the fact that these worlds are not at all developing into similarity; neither one can be transformed into the other without the use of violence. Besides, convergence inevitably means acceptance of the other side's defects, too, and this is hardly desirable."
--Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, Harvard University Commencement, June 8, 1978

posted at 02:01 AM
Comments

That's an interesting idea that finds resonance with me. All these people talking about Western Imperialism--or even declaiming a cultural hegemony of the West--in other conversations talk about Worldwide This and Worldwide That with the progress of history on their side--that it will resemble what they think is progressive, or what they like. Invariably, Utopia more resembles the west, than any other world.

Posted by: Sea King on August 6, 2008 02:08 AM

Yes, good addition Sea King.

This is the way in which modernists converge be they right-wing (economic imperialism) or left ("humanitarian" imperialism). Neither can respect cultures enough to understand why they are different and treat them as they deserve to be treated (trade with some, compete, even at times fight with others). Likewise, neither have any particular attachment to protecting their own cultures and treating it respectfully. They are "internal" colonizers as well, in fact that is a common trait of modern politics and nationalism.

Posted by: Bruce Wayne on August 6, 2008 05:23 AM

Hey, Dan, I like Western culture, and I cannot imagine anything better. So aren't I right in imposing it on everyone else? How dare I not share the "wealth?" Solzhenitsyn hits at the very root of liberal-utopianism, our version anyway. It's one thing to impose out of our own self-interest, but to kid ourselves that it is in the interests of those we impose upon?

Posted by: Webster on August 6, 2008 09:03 PM

I guess much hinges on the definition, but:

(1) Is Westernism best?
(2) Is Westernism best for all?

Particularly to the extent that it is informed by Christianity, Westernism might be judged best, or at least some (Christian Westerners, who would say screw the relativists) might be inclined to say so. But there seems to be a problem with judging it best for all.

Diagnosis?

Posted by: Buzz on August 6, 2008 11:15 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?