
I heard a sports-radio host in Chicago remark yesterday morning that Bill Bilichick belongs next to Vince Lombardi on the NFL coaches' Mount Rushmore. That leaves two open spaces. Whose stately visages should be chisled beside Lombardi and Bilichick?
Bill Parcells
Don Shula and Chuck Noll
Bill Walsh, and keep a blank spot.
Wayne Fontes and Rich Kotite.
Shula and Landry on the rock.
Walsh & Noll
Parcells, though I hate him and the guy (his name slipped my mind) for the Cowboys in the 90s.
No love for the past? I say George Halas and Paul Brown. They did as much as anyone (if not more) to help the game become what it is today. (Remember that Walsh developed his offense while in Cincinnati, with Brown.)
If any Cowboy coach were to go on the mountain (and there would have to be at least one), it wouldn't be Parcells. It wouldn't even be Jimmy. Tom Landry won two Superbowls, appeared in three more, and won the most playoff games of any coach in NFL history. He was an innovator (e.g., the flex defense) and a class act.
Next to Landry, Lombardi and Belichick, I'd have to include Walsh.
Don shula and Paul Brown. I wish I could put a few more, but there is only room for four.
It's easy to canonize Bilichick now, but some restraint may be in order. After all, I wouldn't put Jimmy Johnson on that mountain and he did, essentially, the same thing (although officially Barry Switzer got credit for Johnson's third Super Bowl).
I like Bilichick, but it's difficult to assign someone his place in history when his bandwagon is so full.
Question: if Jimmy Johnson wasn't coaching and Switzer was, how is it again that Johnson should get credit for the win?
I would have to say, George Halas and Don Shula.
Who has as many or more Super Bowl Wins than Chuck Noll?
You know, it's innovation and service to the game that goes into something like this, not just how many Super Bowls you win. Lombardi won five NFL titles; Halas and Brown were incredibly successful and long-serving. It's not their fault that the great majority of their careers came before 1967.
I'd forgotten Landry. Coached the same team for 29 years; invented the flex defense (thanks Brad) and the shotgun offense; his teams were worthy opponents to the Packer dynasty, the Steeler dynasty, even the great Miami teams of the early 70s.
Now consider that nobody has even mentioned Joe Gibbs. (Anyone who can turn Mark Rypien into a SB MVP has got to be doing something right.)
No matter what the final consensus is, we're leaving people off. What we can do?
Without using specific events to mark success, choosing the greatest of anything would subjective at best. Overall contributions might be hard to quantify.
So, although I like your Gibbs example with regards to winning a SB with a mediocre QB, the number of SB’s a coach wins should be the best measure of his success and where he stands in the pecking order of the greatest of all time.
Chuck Noll, Joe Gibbs.
Parcells and Shula



