
Cardinals elected Argentine Jorge Bergoglio the new pope on Tuesday. This is appropriate. The world's 1.2 billion Catholics represent the largest single denomination on earth. Why not then, as the new pope suggested, go to the ends of the earth for the new pontiff? The Catholic Church, despite the "Roman" prefix, is a global religion. Not concentrated in any corner of the earth, Catholicism's reach extends deep into Asia, Africa, and Latin America. Pope Francis, as Bergoglio will be called, is the first Latin American pope and the first non European pope in more than a millenium. It's about time. It's about demographics. Better to pick a pope from where the church thrives than from where it barely survives.
I am pleased with Borgoglio's election. However, I think the suggestion that it is good to elect an Argentinian because lots of Catholics are latino or from South America or non-European should be resisted. Modern identity politics should play no role in choosing the pontiff of the universal church. Doctrinal and pastoral qualitifcations are what is important. Where the Pope happens to be from is (or should be) more or less irrelevant.
It is, as the Reformation shows, highly relevant. Had JP2 been an Italian instead of a Pole, I don't think he would have had the beneficial impact on the Cold War that he had. Whether identity politics should be relevant or not, is another question. I think the identity politics runs the other way. Europe is overrepresented in the papal voting. Why? Jesus wasn't a European. The church isn't growing there. Why should one continent--the only continent where the church is shrinking--have a monopoly on popes? Isn't that the real identity politics at work? About 15% of the world's Catholics call Europe home. About 40% call Latin America home. Europe has three times as many Cardinals. It's a great thing that the cardinals took a man from the heart of the church as the head of the church here on earth.
I agree with Ralph what shouldn't be, but more in agreement with Dan's reality that the Church should go where the Catholics are.
Europe's native population is becoming more secular with an influx of an ever larger Muslim population (nature abhoring a vacuum and all that) so it seems logical to choose a Pope who could have the greatest influence on one of the largest Catholic populations in the world on one of the continents with many geopolicial ramifications.
These are all pretty pious guys to begin with and most of them move lockstep withing the Churches teachings, so at the end, it's the politics of religion that may be the deciding factor.
It's "Habemus Papam". "Papa" is a rare, masculine, first declension noun.
Pedantry rules!



